From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Fugate v. Commonwealth

Court of Appeals of Kentucky
Nov 3, 1950
233 S.W.2d 1019 (Ky. Ct. App. 1950)

Opinion

November 3, 1950.

S.M. Ward, Judge.

Gordon Fugate was convicted in the Perry Circuit Court, Perry County, S.M. Ward, J., of voluntary manslaughter and he appealed. The Court of Appeals, Stanley, C., held that where defendant made a timely and renewed motion to quash indictment because of a substantial error in the summoning and formation of grand jury which returned indictment, and seven members of the grand jury, whose names were drawn from jury wheel, were not listed on County Tax Commissioner's records as required by statute, indictment was invalid.

Judgment reversed.

Napier Napier for appellant.

A.E. Funk, Attorney General and Zeb A. Stewart, Assistant Attorney General, for appellee.


Reversing.

The appeal is by Gordon Fugate from a conviction of voluntary manslaughter with the penalty fixed at twenty years and one day in the penitentiary.

The defendant made a timely and renewed motion to quash the indictment as invalid because of a substantial error in the summoning and formation of the grand jury which returned it. Sec. 158, Criminal Code of Practice. Seven members of the grand jury, whose names were drawn from the jury wheel, were not listed on the County Tax Commissioner's records. The law requires the jury commissioners in selecting names for jury service to "take the last returned tax commissioner's book for the county" and list the names therefrom. KRS 29.050, 29.070. That was not done, the Commissioners having thereby violated the law and obstructed justice.

We have consistently held through many years that every person is entitled to the right of having the grand jury which indicts him selected according to the law, and where that right was not recognized, as in the present case, it is the duty of the trial court to quash the indictment unless the right is waived. Bain v. Commonwealth, 283 Ky. 18, 140 S.W.2d 612; Parker v. Commonwealth, 298 Ky. 204, 182 S.W.2d 653. The Attorney General concedes the error.

No other question raised on the appeal is considered.

Judgment reversed.


Summaries of

Fugate v. Commonwealth

Court of Appeals of Kentucky
Nov 3, 1950
233 S.W.2d 1019 (Ky. Ct. App. 1950)
Case details for

Fugate v. Commonwealth

Case Details

Full title:Fugate v. Commonwealth

Court:Court of Appeals of Kentucky

Date published: Nov 3, 1950

Citations

233 S.W.2d 1019 (Ky. Ct. App. 1950)
233 S.W.2d 1019

Citing Cases

Harrod v. Commonwealth

The accused, Harrod, demurred to the indictment but did not move to set it aside and did not raise the…