From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Fleser v. Aranjo

Supreme Court of Indiana
Oct 7, 1954
233 Ind. 694 (Ind. 1954)

Opinion

No. 29,166.

Filed October 7, 1954.

APPEAL — Jurisdiction — Supreme Court — Constitutional Question — Failure to Present to Trial Court. — An assertion by appellants in their brief that the judgment deprives them of their property without due process of law raises no constitutional question so as to confer jurisdiction in the Supreme Court under Section 4-214, Burns' 1946 Replacement, where no such question was presented to the trial court.

From the Marion Superior Court, Room No. 1, John L. Niblack, Judge.

Appellees, Timo and Joe Aranjo, filed their petition for transfer of this cause to the Appellate Court.

Petition granted and cause ordered transferred to the Appellate Court.

Gregg, Fillion, Fillenwarth Hughes, of Indianapolis, for appellants.

William B. Patrick, of Indianapolis, for appellees.


Appellees have filed their petition for transfer of this cause to the Appellate Court. It is an appeal from a judgment of permanent injunction. Clearly we are without jurisdiction unless a constitutional question is involved and duly presented. Burns' 1946 Replacement, § 4-214.

Appellants state in their brief that the judgment deprives appellants of their property without due process of law. No such question was presented to the trial court, and such mere statement in appellants' brief does not make a constitutional question involved and duly presented. Pivak v. State (1931), 202 Ind. 417, 175 N.E. 278; Dept. of Insurance v. Indiana Trav. Assur. Co. (1944), 223 Ind. 37, 57 N.E.2d 625.

Petition granted and cause ordered transferred to Appellate Court.

Bobbitt, Draper, Emmert, and Gilkison, JJ., concur.

NOTE. — Reported in 121 N.E.2d 879.

For Opinion on Merits in Appellate Court see 123 N.E.2d 248 (not yet officially reported).


Summaries of

Fleser v. Aranjo

Supreme Court of Indiana
Oct 7, 1954
233 Ind. 694 (Ind. 1954)
Case details for

Fleser v. Aranjo

Case Details

Full title:FLESER ET AL. v. ARANJO ET AL

Court:Supreme Court of Indiana

Date published: Oct 7, 1954

Citations

233 Ind. 694 (Ind. 1954)
121 N.E.2d 879

Citing Cases

Fleser v. Aranjo

The appellants' assignment of errors contain twelve specifications. Specification number five has been…

Wetter v. City of Indianapolis

We have held that questions of constitutionality which are merely incidental to the main issues or concern…