From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Ferrara v. Firsching

Supreme Court of Nevada
Jan 23, 1976
92 Nev. 38 (Nev. 1976)

Opinion

No. 7927

January 23, 1976

Appeal from the Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County; Carl J. Christensen, J.

Gabe Hoffenberg, of Las Vegas, for Appellant.

Beckley, Singleton, DeLanoy Jemison, Chartered, of Las Vegas, for Respondents.


OPINION


The district court granted summary judgment to the Estate of Firsching in this action for an accounting commenced by the Estate of Ferrara. Since we do not perceive a genuine issue as to any material fact, we affirm.

Frank N. Ferrara and Robert A. Firsching are deceased, and this litigation between the personal representatives of their estates concerns a written agreement made between them on June 19, 1963. That agreement was with regard to two parcels of real property in Nye County and provided that "in consideration of a waiver of any and all commissions by Ferrara Realty, and other services, Robert A. Firsching, purchaser and owner of above, agrees to pay one half of all net profit to Frank Ferrara."

1. The record before the district court, for all practical purposes, contains the requested accounting and reveals that Parcel 1, approximately 80 acres of land in Nye County, was, by Firsching, purchased for $12,000 and has not been sold; and, that Parcel 2, known as the Dollar Ranch in Pahrump Valley, Nye County, cost Firsching $135,000 and has produced only $85,000 from sales, or attempted sales thereof.

Since neither Firsching, during his lifetime, nor his estate since his death, has realized a net profit from either parcel, the district court ruled that the Firsching Estate is not presently indebted to the Ferrara Estate.

2. The complaint below also requested the court to impose an equitable lien upon the land to insure payment of one half of the net profit when realized.

There is nothing in the June 19, 1963, agreement between Ferrara and Firsching suggesting an intention to create a security interest giving rise to an equitable lien in Ferrara. Consequently, the district court properly denied that requested relief. Werner v. Mormon, 85 Nev. 662, 462 P.2d 42 (1969); Commercial Credit Corp. v. Matthews, 77 Nev. 377, 365 P.2d 303 (1961); Union Indemnity Co. v. Drumm, 57 Nev. 242, 62 P.2d 698 (1936).

Affirmed.

GUNDERSON, C.J., and BATJER, ZENOFF, and MOWBRAY, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Ferrara v. Firsching

Supreme Court of Nevada
Jan 23, 1976
92 Nev. 38 (Nev. 1976)
Case details for

Ferrara v. Firsching

Case Details

Full title:KAY FERRARA, EXECUTRIX OF THE ESTATE OF FRANK N. FERRARA, DECEASED…

Court:Supreme Court of Nevada

Date published: Jan 23, 1976

Citations

92 Nev. 38 (Nev. 1976)
544 P.2d 1198

Citing Cases

In re Stratosphere Corp.

Under Nevada law, for an equitable lien to be based on a contract between two parties, there must be (1) an…

Firsching v. Ferrara

The judgment was appealed and affirmed by this court on January 23, 1976. See Ferrara v. Firsching, 92 Nev.…