From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Fellows and Fellows

Oregon Court of Appeals
Nov 17, 1993
124 Or. App. 476 (Or. Ct. App. 1993)

Summary

upholding indefinite grant of spousal support based on preexisiting osteoporosis that became unexpectedly severe, a lack of evidence that the condition would improve, increased expenses for medication, and a doubt in the wife's ability to continue working

Summary of this case from In re Marriage of Deboer

Opinion

8901731 CV; CA A74898

Argued and submitted September 10, 1993.

Reversed and remanded with instructions November 17, 1993.

Appeal from Circuit Court, Klamath County, Donald A.W. Piper, Senior Judge.

Enver Bozgoz argued the cause and filed the brief for appellant.

Matthew Newman and Parks Ratliff filed the brief for respondent.

Before Warren, Presiding Judge, and Edmonds and Landau, Judges.


WARREN, P.J.

Reversed and remanded for entry of modified judgment awarding indefinite spousal support to wife of $250 per month. Costs to wife.


Wife appeals from a modification of a dissolution judgment that denied her permanent spousal support. On de novo review, we modify the judgment.

The parties were married for 25 years, and their marriage was dissolved by a stipulated judgment in April, 1990. The judgment ordered husband to pay spousal support of $250 per month for 24 months. In 1991, wife moved to modify the judgment, requesting an award of permanent spousal support because of an unexpected deterioration of her health. The trial court extended the spousal support for an additional six months. Wife assigns error to the trial court's failure to make the award permanent.

Both parties argue about whether there has been a substantial change in circumstances that would warrant a modification of the dissolution judgment. At the time of the dissolution, wife acknowledged that she had osteoporosis and that she did not know how much longer she could work. After the dissolution, wife's condition unexpectedly became much more severe. The osteoporosis spread and she had to have surgery on one foot to relieve her symptoms. Her expenditures for prescription medication have increased significantly. Nothing in the record suggests that her condition will improve. Wife's ability to continue working is in doubt. On de novo review, we conclude wife has shown a substantial unanticipated change of circumstances and that the award of spousal support should be made indefinite.

Reversed and remanded for entry of modified judgment awarding indefinite spousal support to wife of $250 per month. Costs to wife.


Summaries of

Fellows and Fellows

Oregon Court of Appeals
Nov 17, 1993
124 Or. App. 476 (Or. Ct. App. 1993)

upholding indefinite grant of spousal support based on preexisiting osteoporosis that became unexpectedly severe, a lack of evidence that the condition would improve, increased expenses for medication, and a doubt in the wife's ability to continue working

Summary of this case from In re Marriage of Deboer

reversing denial of modification where the "wife's condition unexpectedly became much more severe"

Summary of this case from In re Marriage of Williams
Case details for

Fellows and Fellows

Case Details

Full title:In the Matter of the Marriage of Jerry Dean FELLOWS, Respondent, and…

Court:Oregon Court of Appeals

Date published: Nov 17, 1993

Citations

124 Or. App. 476 (Or. Ct. App. 1993)
862 P.2d 1325

Citing Cases

In the Matter of Marriage of Medlyn

The trial court's letter opinion states, in part: "The Court's been referred to Fellows [and] Fellows, 124…

Matter of Marriage of Tomos

Wife was not required to show that she was literally unable to perform physical labor or manage desk work in…