From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Ex Parte Johnson

Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas
Oct 11, 1939
137 Tex. Crim. 433 (Tex. Crim. App. 1939)

Opinion

Nos. 20602, 20647.

Delivered October 11, 1939.

Where justice court bound over one Melvin Johnson charged with murder by complaint therein, to await action of grand jury at next term of district court, at which term said person was indicted for said offense, relator charged as accessory to said killing by complaint in same justice court, which found him guilty of contempt and committed him to jail for refusal to answer question which relator claimed might incriminate him in the charge then being inquired about when called by the State as a witness in the examining trial of Melvin Johnson, held entitled to be discharged, as there is no proceedings now pending in said justice court wherein relator could purge himself of his alleged contempt.

Appeal from District Court of Collin County. Hon. J. T. Suggs, Jr., Judge.

Proceeding by relator for a writ of habeas corpus to secure his discharge from custody under a justice court's judgment committing relator to jail for contempt of court.

Relator ordered discharged.

The opinion states the case.

Smith Dowdy, of McKinney, for appellant.

Lloyd W. Davidson, State's Attorney, of Austin, for the State.


These two above styled cases, relating to the same subject matter, are consolidated, and will be treated together.

It appears from the record in cause No. 20647 that one Melvin Johnson was held by complaint in the justice court of Precinct No. 1 of Collins County, Texas, charged with murder. It also appears that the appellant, Glen Johnson, was also held by complaint in the same court, charged as accessory to the murder of the same person. On the occasion of the examining trial of Melvin Johnson, the appellant herein, Glen Johnson was called to the witness stand by the State, and by the State interrogated. He was asked but one question, and he refused to answer such question, giving as his reason for such refusal that an answer thereto might incriminate him in the charge then being inquired into by the court. Whereupon the court entered its finding and judgment that such action upon the part of the appellant constituted a contempt of court, and he was committed to jail until he saw fit to purge himself of such contempt, this above order having been entered on June 27, 1939. Thereafterwards, in cause No. 20602, this court granted Glen Johnson's request for the issuance of its writ of habeas corpus, and issued its order granting bail to this appellant, and setting the hearing for such cause at its first meeting in October, 1939, at which time both of such causes were submitted.

It now appears that the matter under inquiry in cause No. 20647, wherein this relator was held in contempt, has now passed from the jurisdiction of the examining court in that upon the conclusion of the testimony therein on June 27, 1939, the defendant Melvin Johnson was held to answer the charge filed therein, and was bound over to await the action of the grand jury at the September Term, 1939, of the district court of Collin County, Texas, and that at said term the grand jury indicted said Melvin Johnson, charging him with the murder, which was the subject of the investigation in which this relator was held in contempt; that the justice court of precinct No. 1 of Collin County, has now lost its jurisdiction in such examining trial by virtue of its function having therein terminated. It now appears that there are no proceedings pending wherein the relator could purge himself, if he desired to do so, of his alleged contempt. The law does not demand of a person that he do an impossible thing. There being no cause pending in which the applicant could purge himself of his alleged contempt, he should not be further held in custody, nor under bond on account of such order.

We are therefore of the opinion that the relator, Glen Johnson, should be discharged under both causes herein, and it is accordingly so ordered.


Summaries of

Ex Parte Johnson

Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas
Oct 11, 1939
137 Tex. Crim. 433 (Tex. Crim. App. 1939)
Case details for

Ex Parte Johnson

Case Details

Full title:EX PARTE GLEN JOHNSON (cases consolidated)

Court:Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas

Date published: Oct 11, 1939

Citations

137 Tex. Crim. 433 (Tex. Crim. App. 1939)
131 S.W.2d 971

Citing Cases

Ex Parte Dewees

W.F. Nix and Morgan, Coulton, Morgan Britain, all of Amarillo, for relator. The district judge, in this case,…

Ex Parte Carroll

Were he now to deliver the children to his wife it would not be in obedience to the temporary order, but in…