Opinion
Case No. 3:12-cv-01011-JST
05-08-2013
EON CORP. IP HOLDINGS, LLC, Plaintiff, v. SENSUS USA, INC., ET AL., Defendants.
Respectfully submitted, DUANE MORRIS LLP Matthew S. Yungwirth (admitted pro hac vice) L. Norwood Jameson (admitted pro hac vice) Alison M. Haddock (admitted pro hac vice) David C. Dotson (admitted pro hac vice) Stephanie A. Hansen(admitted pro hac vice) Richard L. Seabolt, Esq. (SBN 67469) COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT CISCO SYSTEMS, INC. HOPKINS & CARLEY A Law Corporation John V. Picone III (SBN 187226) Jennifer S. Coleman (SBN 213210) Christopher A. Hohn (SBN 271759) REED & SCARDINO LLP Daniel R. Scardino Jeffery R. Johnson Cabrach J. Connor Chad Ennis ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF EON CORP. IP HOLDINGS, LLC ANDREWS KURTH LLP Gerald C. Conley (admitted pro hac vice) Mark A. Shoffner (admitted pro hac vice) Ralph W. Tarr, Esq. 24011 Alder Place Calabasas, CA 91302-2394 ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT MAVENIR SYSTEMS, INC. ANDREWS KURTH LLP Robert A. Gutkin (SBN 119781) Jason N. Thelen ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT SERCOMM CORPORATION AKIN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD LLP Fred I. Williams Teresa Ghali State Bar No. 252961 Fred I. Williams ( admitted pro hac vice) Todd Landis ( admitted pro hac vice) Kellie M. Johnson ( admitted pro hac vice) ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT HTC AMERICA, INC. WILSON SONSINI GOODRICH & ROSATI Professional Corporation M. Craig Tyler ( admitted pro hac vice) Texas State Bar No. 00794762 Brian Range ( admitted pro hac vice) Texas State Bar No. 24033106 Abraham DeLaO ( admitted pro hac vice) Texas State Bar No. 24064499 ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT ARUBA NETWORKS, INC. COOLEY LLP By: Lowell D. Mead Lowell D. Mead (CA Bar No. 223989) Jonathan G. Graves ( pro hac vice) ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT BROADSOFT INC. MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP L. Scott Oliver (SBN 174824) Diana Luo (SBN 233712) ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT MERU NETWORKS, INC. Michael E. Zeliger (SBN 271118) John J. Cotter ( pro hac vice pending) ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT SPRINT SPECTRUM L.P. DUANE MORRIS LLP Matthew S. Yungwirth (admitted pro hac vice) L. Norwood Jameson (admitted pro hac vice) Alison M. Haddock (admitted pro hac vice) David C. Dotson (admitted pro hac vice) Stephanie A. Hansen(admitted pro hac vice) Richard L. Seabolt, Esq. (SBN 67469) COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT SONUS NETWORKS, INC. KTLPATRICK TOWNSEND & STOCKTON LLP Steve Moore (NC Bar No. 23367) Carl E. Sanders (NC Bar No. 34190) James L. Howard (NC Bar No. 39769) Jessica L. Hannah (State Bar No. 261802) Byron Chin (State Bar No. 259846) ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANTS MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS, INC. and MOTOROLA MOBILITY LLC SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP Richard J. O'Brien Bryan K. Anderson Ashish Magdev ATTORNEYS FOR RESPONDENTS U.S. CELLULAR CORPORATION
Richard L. Seabolt, Esq. (SBN 67469)
rlseabolt@duanemorris.com
DUANE MORRIS LLP
One Market, Spear Tower, Suite 2000
San Francisco, CA 94105-1104
Telephone: (415) 957-3000
Facsimile: (415) 957 3001
Matthew S. Yungwirth (admitted pro hac vice)
msyungwirth@duanemorris.com
L. Norwood Jameson (admitted pro hac vice)
amhaddockwjameson@duanemorris.com
Alison M. Haddock (admitted pro hac vice)
dcdotson@duanemorris.com
David C. Dotson (admitted pro hac vice)
sahansen@duanemorris.com
Stephanie A. Hansen(admitted pro hac vice)
msyungwirth@duanemorris.com
DUANE MORRIS LLP
1075 Peachtree Street, Ste. 2000
Atlanta, GA 30309
Telephone: (404) 253-6900
Facsimile: (404) 253-6901
JOINT MOTION AND [PROPOSED]
ORDER FOR BRINGING EQUIPMENT
INTO COURTROOM
Date: May 10, 2013
Courtroom: 9
Judge: Hon. Jon S. Tigar
Plaintiff EON Corp. IP Holdings, LLC ("EON") and Defendants Aruba Networks, Inc. ("Aruba"), BroadSoft, Inc. ("BroadSoft"), Cisco Systems, Inc. ("Cisco"), Mavenir Systems, Inc. ("Mavenir"), Meru Networks, Inc. ("Meru"), SerComm Corporation ("SerComm"), Sonus Networks, Inc. ("Sonus"), Sprint Spectrum, L.P. ("Sprint"), HTC America, Inc. ("HTC"), United States Cellular Corporation ("U.S. Cellular"), Motorola Mobility LLC ("MML"), and Motorola Solutions, Inc. ("Motorola Solutions") (collectively, the "Defendants") move the Court as follows:
WHEREAS, this Court has set a Claim Construction Hearing for 10:00 a.m. on May 10, 2013 in this matter (see Docket Nos. 664 and 690);
WHEREAS, the Parties intend to give oral presentations at the May 10, 2013 hearing to aid the Court's understanding of their proposed constructions;
WHEREAS, in order for the Parties to give their oral presentations, the Parties require certain technical equipment, including the following:
A. Projector (1);
B. Projector Screen (1);
C. Projector Bulb (1);
D. Projector stands (25" x 17") w/skirt (2);
E. Laptop Computers (up to 10);
F. Laptop Stand (1);
G. Document Camera (ELMO) (1);
H. Miscellaneous A/V cabling;
I. VGA Distribution Amp (3);
J. Switches (4);
K. Tech Tables (2); and
L. Cart(s) for transporting equipment.
WHEREAS the Parties are coordinating and will share the presentation equipment;
NOW THEREFORE, the Parties respectfully request permission to bring the equipment described above into the Federal Courthouse in San Francisco, California, located at 450 Golden Gate Avenue, San Francisco, 94102, and to possess and use that equipment in Courtroom 9 during the Claim Construction Technical Tutorial. The Parties further request the Court's permission, including permission for their equipment vendor Resonant Legal Media and Samir Patel, Pramel Patel, Edward Mauricio, and Mehul Mistry from ABC Tech rentals, to use the courthouse's loading docks for purposes of transporting the equipment, and access to Courtroom 9 to set up the electronic devices on Thursday May 9, 2013, at 10:00 a.m., to facilitate the timely and orderly conduct of the hearing. The contact information for ABC Tech Rentals is: (510) 887-8707 (phone) and (510) 252-1199 (fax). The contact information for Resonant Legal Media is: (415) 823-4895 (phone) and (888) 781-3591 (fax).
Respectfully submitted,
DUANE MORRIS LLP
By: _______________
Matthew S. Yungwirth (admitted pro hac vice)
L. Norwood Jameson (admitted pro hac vice)
Alison M. Haddock (admitted pro hac vice)
David C. Dotson (admitted pro hac vice)
Stephanie A. Hansen(admitted pro hac vice)
Richard L. Seabolt, Esq. (SBN 67469)
COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT
CISCO SYSTEMS, INC.
HOPKINS & CARLEY
A Law Corporation
By: _______________
John V. Picone III (SBN 187226)
Jennifer S. Coleman (SBN 213210)
Christopher A. Hohn (SBN 271759)
REED & SCARDINO LLP
By: _______________
Daniel R. Scardino
Jeffery R. Johnson
Cabrach J. Connor
Chad Ennis
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF
EON CORP. IP HOLDINGS, LLC
ANDREWS KURTH LLP
By: _______________
Gerald C. Conley (admitted pro hac vice)
Mark A. Shoffner (admitted pro hac vice)
Ralph W. Tarr, Esq.
24011 Alder Place
Calabasas, CA 91302-2394
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
MAVENIR SYSTEMS, INC.
ANDREWS KURTH LLP
By: _______________
Robert A. Gutkin (SBN 119781)
Jason N. Thelen
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
SERCOMM CORPORATION
AKIN GUMP STRAUSS HAUER & FELD LLP
By: _______________
Fred I. Williams
Teresa Ghali
State Bar No. 252961
Fred I. Williams (admitted pro hac vice)
Todd Landis (admitted pro hac vice)
Kellie M. Johnson (admitted pro hac vice)
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
HTC AMERICA, INC.
WILSON SONSINI GOODRICH & ROSATI
Professional Corporation
By: _______________
M. Craig Tyler (admitted pro hac vice)
Texas State Bar No. 00794762
Brian Range (admitted pro hac vice)
Texas State Bar No. 24033106
Abraham DeLaO (admitted pro hac vice)
Texas State Bar No. 24064499
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
ARUBA NETWORKS, INC.
COOLEY LLP
By: Lowell D. Mead
Lowell D. Mead (CA Bar No. 223989)
Jonathan G. Graves (pro hac vice)
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
BROADSOFT INC.
MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP
By: _______________
L. Scott Oliver (SBN 174824)
Diana Luo (SBN 233712)
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
MERU NETWORKS, INC.
K&L GATES LLP
By: _______________
Michael E. Zeliger (SBN 271118)
John J. Cotter (pro hac vice pending)
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT
SPRINT SPECTRUM L.P.
DUANE MORRIS LLP
By: _______________
Matthew S. Yungwirth (admitted pro hac vice)
L. Norwood Jameson (admitted pro hac vice)
Alison M. Haddock (admitted pro hac vice)
David C. Dotson (admitted pro hac vice)
Stephanie A. Hansen(admitted pro hac vice)
Richard L. Seabolt, Esq. (SBN 67469)
COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT
SONUS NETWORKS, INC.
KTLPATRICK TOWNSEND & STOCKTON LLP
By: _______________
Steve Moore (NC Bar No. 23367)
Carl E. Sanders (NC Bar No. 34190)
James L. Howard (NC Bar No. 39769)
Jessica L. Hannah (State Bar No. 261802)
Byron Chin (State Bar No. 259846)
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANTS
MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS, INC. and
MOTOROLA MOBILITY LLC
SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP
By: _______________
Richard J. O'Brien
Bryan K. Anderson
Ashish Magdev
ATTORNEYS FOR RESPONDENTS
U.S. CELLULAR CORPORATION
CERTIFICATION PURSUANT TO GENERAL RULE NO. 45, SECTION X,
RE E-FILING ON BEHALF OF MULTIPLE SIGNATORIES
In accord with the Northern District of California's General Order No. 45, Section X(B), I attest that concurrence in the filing of this document has been obtained from each of other signatories who are listed on the signature pages.
Pursuant to General Rule No. 45, I shall maintain records to support this concurrence for subsequent production for the Court if so ordered, or for inspection upon request by a party until one year after final resolution of the action (including appeal, if any).
Executed this 7th day of May, 2013, at Atlanta, Georgia.
_______________
Alison M. Haddock
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Judge Jon S. Tigar