From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Ehrich v. Bucki

New York Common Pleas — General Term
Feb 1, 1894
7 Misc. 118 (N.Y. Misc. 1894)

Opinion

February, 1894.

Julius Lehmann, for respondents.

John T. Walker, for appellant.


Unquestionably a wife who resides with her husband has implied authority to pledge his credit for the payment of necessaries supplied for her use and that of her family, and the same authority arises whether the wife be living with her husband or not, if it appears that he has inadequately provided for her support, or not at all; and let it be conceded that the several articles supplied to the wife, and for which plaintiffs seek to recover, were necessaries in the sense in which that word has been defined ( Bloomingdale v. Brinckerhoff, 2 Misc. 49), still it does not follow that plaintiffs were entitled to recover.

To entitle the tradesman to recover as against the husband it must appear that the goods were supplied to the wife upon the husband's credit. The presumption that the wife was acting as her husband's agent is overcome by the fact that credit was given to her. Stammers v. Macomb, 2 Wend. 454; Mitchell v. Treanor, 56 Am. Dec. 421; Schouler's Husband Wife, § 109, and cases cited in notes 5, 6, 7 and 8. The record from which we are to determine this appeal not only fails to disclose even a scintilla of evidence to the effect that the goods sued for were supplied upon the husband's credit, but affirmatively shows that credit was given therefor to the wife. Accordingly, the recovery was without adequate support by facts in evidence, and the judgment should be reversed.

GIEGERICH, J., concurs.

Judgment reversed and new trial ordered, with costs to defendant to abide the event.


Summaries of

Ehrich v. Bucki

New York Common Pleas — General Term
Feb 1, 1894
7 Misc. 118 (N.Y. Misc. 1894)
Case details for

Ehrich v. Bucki

Case Details

Full title:SAMUEL W. EHRICH et al., Respondents, v . CHARLES L. BUCKI, Appellant

Court:New York Common Pleas — General Term

Date published: Feb 1, 1894

Citations

7 Misc. 118 (N.Y. Misc. 1894)
27 N.Y.S. 247

Citing Cases

Pickhardt v. Pratt

The usual presumption of law that the necessaries were furnished to the wife on the husband's credit is,…

Matter of Smith

But a married woman may render herself and her separate estate liable even for necessaries by an express…