Opinion
Case No. 2:11-CV-00098-JAM-JFM
07-12-2012
JERALD CLINTON (J.C.) EAGLESMITH, RAMONA EAGLESMITH, EILEEN COX, and BRUCE BARNES, Plaintiffs, v. JEFF RAY, as an individual, SUE SEGURA, as an individual, and BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF PLUMAS COUNTY OFFICE OF EDUCATION/ PLUMAS COUNTY UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT, Defendants.
DAN SIEGEL, SBN 56400 PETER HABERFELD, SBN 41723 MICHAEL SIEGEL, SBN 269439 SIEGEL & YEE Attorneys for Plaintiffs JERALD CLINTON (J.C.) EAGLESMITH, RAMONA EAGLESMITH, EILEEN COX, and BRUCE BARNES
DAN SIEGEL, SBN 56400
PETER HABERFELD, SBN 41723
MICHAEL SIEGEL, SBN 269439
SIEGEL & YEE
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
JERALD CLINTON (J.C.) EAGLESMITH,
RAMONA EAGLESMITH,
EILEEN COX, and BRUCE BARNES
STIPULATION AND ORDER TO
PRODUCE INDEPENDENT MEDICAL
EXAMINER TESTS AND TEST RESULTS
TO PARTIES, PURSUANT TO
FED.R.CIV.P. 35(b)(1) and (5)
Plaintiffs J.C. Eaglesmith, Eileen Cox and Bruce Barnes allege in their Complaint that defendants' conduct caused them emotional distress. Because they thereby placed their mental condition at issue, they agreed to submit to an independent medical examination by defendants' expert Dr. Matt Gould. In the course of examining each plaintiff, Dr. Gould conducted various psychological tests, and enlisted Dr. Bronson to analyze the results.
Plaintiffs have requested that defendants produce the tests and test results in order that plaintiffs can prepare cross examination of Dr. Gould and any other defendant expert that relies on those tests and test results. According to defendant's attorneys, Dr. Gould believes that the ethical rules of the American Psychiatric Association preclude him from sharing "the test and raw data results" with anyone other than a licensed clinical psychologist or psychiatrist.
On July 27, 2011, the parties entered a Stipulation for Protective Order (Dkt. No. 47). The Court signed the Order on July 29, 2011.
Fed.R.Civ.P. 35(b)(1) entitles the person examined to be provided with a copy of the medical examiner's written report and requires that the report include "in detail* * * the results of any tests." Rule35(b)(5) grants to the Court the authority to order on motion that the party deliver the report, as defined by Rule 35(b)(1), and "[i]f the report is not provided, the court may exclude the examiner's testimony at trial."
Therefore, plaintiffs and defendants hereby stipulate that the Court enter an Order that directs Dr. Matt Gould to produce the tests and test results to the parties' attorneys.
SIEGEL & YEE
By: __________________
Peter Haberfeld
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
STUBBS & LEONE
By: __________________
Brian Duus
Attorneys for Defendants SO ORDERED
__________________
Hon. John A. Mendez
U. S. District Court Judge