From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Dziuba v. Fletcher

Supreme Court of New Jersey
Oct 12, 2006
907 A.2d 427 (N.J. 2006)

Opinion

Argued September 11, 2006.

Decided October 12, 2006.

Appeal from the Superior Court, Appellate Division, Weissbard, J.A.D., 382 N.J.Super. 73, 887 A.2d 732.

Michael G.B. David, argued the cause for appellant ( Lewis David, attorneys).

Anthony Granato, argued the cause for respondents ( Jarve Kaplan, attorneys).


We granted certification in this matter to review the Appellate Division judgment holding that N.J.S.A. 39:6A-4.5a does not bar plaintiff's recovery of non-economic damages under the tortfeasor defendant's automobile insurance policy. Dziuba v. Fletcher, 382 N.J.Super. 73 , 82, 887 A.2d 732 (2005), certif. granted, 186 N.J. 363, 895 A.2d 450 (2006). As the Appellate Division decision noted, plaintiff, an uninsured motorist, was not operating his uninsured vehicle when he was injured in an accident involving defendant's car. Id. at 76, 887 A.2d 732. In such circumstances, we agree with the Appellate Division that N.J.S.A. 39:6A-4.5a does not preclude an injured plaintiff from recovering non-economic damages under a defendant's policy of automobile insurance. Accordingly, substantially for the reasons expressed in Judge Weissbard's opinion, we affirm the Appellate Division's judgment.

For affirmance — Chief Justice PORITZ and Justices LONG, LaVECCHIA, ZAZZALI, ALBIN, WALLACE, and RIVERASOTO — 7.

Opposed — None.


Summaries of

Dziuba v. Fletcher

Supreme Court of New Jersey
Oct 12, 2006
907 A.2d 427 (N.J. 2006)
Case details for

Dziuba v. Fletcher

Case Details

Full title:VICTOR DZIUBA AND ALEXANDRA DZIUBA, HUSBAND AND WIFE…

Court:Supreme Court of New Jersey

Date published: Oct 12, 2006

Citations

907 A.2d 427 (N.J. 2006)
907 A.2d 427

Citing Cases

Perrelli v. Pastorelle

Defendants further contend that it is the express intent of the Legislature to treat one operating and one…

Caballero-Gonzalez v. Adm'r for Harco Nat'l Ins. Co.

-------- Plaintiff argues that, even if he was required to insure the Cadillac, he was not precluded from…