From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Dyer v. Ayoob

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Aroostook County
Nov 5, 1936
187 A. 757 (Me. 1936)

Opinion

Decided November 5, 1936.

J. Frederick Burns, for plaintiff.

M. P. Roberts, Herchel Shaw, for defendant.


Action on the case for negligence. Verdict for the plaintiff with reasonable assessment of compensatory damages. General motion for a new trial on the usual grounds.

There is evidence in the case tending to show that the plaintiff, somewhat advanced in years, on June 7, 1934, in attempting to cross the main highway running through the Town of Blaine, was struck by the defendant's Peerless sedan and seriously injured. The driver of the automobile, with full opportunity to observe the plaintiff crossing the street in front of him, continued on with excessive speed until his belated application of the brakes and a swerve to the right did not and could not prevent an accident. A finding that the driver of the car, who was the defendant's employee, was negligent and the owner chargeable therefor is not manifestly wrong.

Nor can it be held upon this record as a matter of law that the plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence. He testifies without contradiction that, as he came out from behind the car from which he had alighted and before he started to cross, he looked up and down the road and saw no automobiles coming towards him. A consideration of the distance to the point where an approaching car would come into view and the apparent speed of the defendant's automobile supports his assertion. The jury was warranted in finding that under the circumstances of this case an ordinarily careful and prudent person would have deemed it safe to have attempted to make the crossing. This is the measure of care required of a pedestrian crossing a public street. Wetzler v. Gould, 119 Me. 276; Sturtevant v. Ouellette, 126 Me. 558. Motion overruled.


Summaries of

Dyer v. Ayoob

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Aroostook County
Nov 5, 1936
187 A. 757 (Me. 1936)
Case details for

Dyer v. Ayoob

Case Details

Full title:JAMES A. DYER vs. WILLIAM AYOOB

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Aroostook County

Date published: Nov 5, 1936

Citations

187 A. 757 (Me. 1936)
187 A. 757

Citing Cases

Mccullough v. Lalumiere

" See also McMann v. Reliable Furniture Co., 153 Me. 383, 140 A.2d 736; Gosselin v. Collins, 147 Me. 432, 87…

Marsh v. Wardwell

The question presented to us is whether the conduct of the plaintiff as disclosed by the record amounted to…