From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Duncan v. Fourth Judicial Dist

Supreme Court of Utah
Apr 4, 2007
156 P.3d 792 (Utah 2007)

Opinion

Nos. 20051009, 20060203.

February 2, 2007. Rehearing Denied April 4, 2007.

Original Proceedings in this Court.

Clark R. Nielsen, Salt Lake City, for petitioners Duncan, KWD Assoc, and Julee Assoc.

Michael R. Carlston, R. Brent Stephens, David L. Pinkston, Salt Lake City, for petitioners Rannoch and Carie.

Brent M. Johnson, Salt Lake City, for respondents Fourth District and Judges Howard, Stott, and Taylor.

Steven W. Call, Michael D. Mayfield, Herschel J. Saperstein, Benjamin J. Kotter, Salt Lake City, for respondent BYU.

Eric K. Schnibbe, Salt Lake City, for respondent Tremco.


¶ 1 This opinion pertains to two petitions brought under Utah Rule of Civil Procedure 65B. We have consolidated the two petitions because both parties ask for essentially the same relief — the vacation of the July 10, 2002 supplemental order entered in favor of Brigham Young University (BYU) and a cessation of collection activities by BYU against petitioners. In light of our holding in Brigham Young University v. Tremco Consultants, Inc., 2007 UT 17, 156 P.3d 782, the petitions are granted and the July 10, 2002 supplemental order is vacated.

¶ 2 Chief Justice DURHAM, Justice PARRISH, and Judge ATHERTON concur in Justice NEHRING's opinion.

¶ 3 Having disqualified themselves, Associate Chief Justice WILKINS and Justice DURRANT do not participate herein; Judge JUDITH S.H. ATHERTON sat.


Summaries of

Duncan v. Fourth Judicial Dist

Supreme Court of Utah
Apr 4, 2007
156 P.3d 792 (Utah 2007)
Case details for

Duncan v. Fourth Judicial Dist

Case Details

Full title:Kenneth W. DUNCAN; KWD Associates, L.C.; Lee Duncan; and Julee Associates…

Court:Supreme Court of Utah

Date published: Apr 4, 2007

Citations

156 P.3d 792 (Utah 2007)
2007 UT 18