Opinion
No. 3:01-cv-2252-CRB
08-25-2015
BETTY DUKES, PATRICIA SURGESON, EDITH ARANA, DEBORAH GUNTER, and CHRISTINE KWAPNOSKI, Plaintiffs, v. WAL-MART STORES, INC., Defendant.
ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING IN PART ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO SEAL
Now before the Court is Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s amended administrative motion to seal records in connection with its motions for summary judgment. In a series of initial motions, Wal-Mart sought to seal voluminous records that extended far beyond the "compelling reasons" standard that governs the sealing of documents in support of dispositive motions. See Order Re Administrative Motions to Seal (dkt. 1129) (describing motions); Kamakana v. City and County of Honolulu, 447 F.3d 1172, 1177 (9th Cir. 2006) (describing legal standard). In response, the Court ordered Wal-Mart to reassess its initial motion and seek to seal only a narrowly tailored list of documents in compliance with the applicable standard. See Order Re Administrative Motions to Seal.
As stated in that Order, when a motion to seal is made in connection with dispositive motions, there is "a strong presumption in favor of access to court records." See Foltz v. State Farm Mutual Auto. Insurance Company, 331 F.3d 1122, 1135 (9th Cir. 2003). "When discovery material is filed with the court . . . its status changes. If the documents are not among those which have 'traditionally been kept secret for important policy reasons,' then 'the public policy reasons behind a presumption of access to judicial documents (judicial accountability, education about the judicial process etc.),' apply." Id. at 1134 (quoting Times Mirror Co. v. United States, 873 F.2d 1210, 1219 (9th Cir. 1989) and Phillips ex rel. Estates of Byrd v. General Motors Corp., 307 F.3d 1206, 1213 (9th Cir. 2002)). Thus, a party must have "compelling reasons" to justify sealing court records; examples of such justification exist "'when such court files might have become a vehicle for improper purposes,' such as the use of records to gratify private spite, promote public scandal, circulate libelous statements, or release trade secrets." Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1179 (quoting Nixon v. Warner Communications, 435 U.S. 589, 598 (1978)). "The mere fact that the production of records may lead to a litigant's embarrassment, incrimination, or exposure to further litigation will not, without more, compel the court to seal its records." Id. (citing Foltz, 331 F.3d at 1136).
The Court has carefully reviewed Wal-Mart's amended motion to seal in light of the Court's order that Wal-Mart narrowly tailor its requests to those that comply strictly with the "compelling reasons" standard. As detailed in the following tables, the Court finds that the material Wal-Mart identified is in large part sealable, with the exception of several items falling into two categories: 1) information related to the Plaintiffs; and 2) information relevant to the underlying issues of this suit. The items that may be sealed fall into three broad categories: 1) trade secrets; 2) non-party personal information; and 3) non-party employment information.
The Court hereby ORDERS the parties to file on the public record the items indicated in the tables below as non-sealable ("NS") within ten (10) days of the entry of this Order. All other items shall remain under seal. EXHIBITS TO THE DECLARATION OF RACHEL S. BRASS IN SUPPORT OF WAL-MART STORES, INC.'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT (Dkt. 1066)
| No | Name of Document | Stated Reason | Seal (S)/Not Seal (NS):Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Brass Dec., Ex. 11:Feb. 17, 2015 Letterfrom Jenna Yott toChristine Webber. | Redactions forcompetitively sensitiveinformation. | S: Trade secret. |
| 2 | Perry Dec., Ex. 5:Deposition of PaulaVaccaro (pg. 40). | Redactions forcompetitively sensitiveinformation. | S: Trade secret. |
| 3 | Dec. of RyanPuryear. | Redactions forcompetitively sensitiveinformation. | S: Trade secret (2:8-9). |
| 4 | Dec. of Lisa Riley(pg. 5). | Redactions forcompetitively sensitiveinformation. | S: Trade secret (5:26). |
| 5 | Exhibits to Dec. ofLisa RileyRiley Dec., Ex. K:Field Non-ExemptAssociate Pay Plan(Effective Sept. 11,2010). | Wal-Mart policyreflecting maximumpay ranges subject toprotective order. | S: Trade secret (pages 6-9,12-16, 18, 20-22). |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Exhibits to Dec. ofMichelle Medlina) Medlin Dec., Ex.5: Aug. 2004 GlobalFood Safety Audit.b) Medlin Dec., Ex.6: Feb., Apr., May.,June, July, & Sept.2004 Global FoodSafety Audits.c) Medlin Dec. Ex.:7: WMDukes-000147-015-9000036,WMDukes-000147-015-9000120 -90000121. | a) Reflecting GlobalFood Safety Auditresults.b) Reflecting GlobalFood Safety Auditresults.c) Reflecting GlobalFood Safety Auditresults. | a) NS: Food safety auditresults.b) NS: This document mayhave been incorrectlylabeled. It is a CommitmentMatrix detailing each store'srank and score in variouscategories. Includes YTDsales, but not trade secrets.c) NS: Food safety auditresults. |
| 7 | Exhibits to theDec. of BrandynZobel in Supportof Wal-MartStores, Inc.'sReplyMemorandum inSupport of ItsMotions forSummaryJudgmenta) Zobel Dec., Ex.B: Sam's Club 2011Field CompensationChanges.b) Zobel Dec., Ex.C: Sam's Club 2007Facility Exempt PayPlan. | a) Current Wal-Martpolicy subject toprotective order.b) Current Wal-Martpolicy subject toprotective order. | a) S: Trade secret.b) S: Trade secret. |
|---|
PLAINTIFFS' EXHIBITS
| 8 | Renick Dec., Ex.46: Feb. 17, 2015Letter from JennaYott to ChristineWebber (duplicateof Brass Dec., Ex.11). | Redactions forcompetitively sensitiveinformation. | S: Trade secret. |
| 1 | Brass Dec., Ex. 1:Deposition of bettyDukes, Vol. 1a) Page 217:19-20;255:2-4 and 8;257:8 and 14.b) Exhibits 1, 2, 10,12, 16 and 21. | a) Testimony re: non-party employmentinformation redactedfor privacy.b) Contact and non-party informationredacted for privacyand/or under FRCP §5.2. | a) S: Non-party information.b) S: Non-party information. |
|---|
| 2 3 | Brass Dec., Ex. 5:Deposition ofKenneth S. Caglea) Page 3:17-18,and 21.b) Pages 262:7-8and 18-25; 265:11-12; 286:21; 287:1.Brass Decl., Ex. 13:Associate HistoryProfile of ArturoMireles (Dkt. 1069-45). | a) Non-party personalinformation redactedfor privacy and/orunder FRCP § 5.2.b) Testimony re: non-party employmentinformation redactedfor privacy.Non-party employmentinformation redactedfor privacy. | a) S: Non-party contactinformation.b) S: Names of non-parties(262:6-7, and 18; 265:11;286:1; 287:1).S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | Brass Decl., Ex.14: Deposition ofArturo Mireless(Dkt. 1069-46)Page 4:12-13, and15. | Non-party personalinformation redactedfor privacy and underFRCP § 5.2. | S: Non-party contactinformation. |
| 5 | Brass Dcl., Ex. 15:Expert Report ofDenise NeumannMartin. | Non-party employmentinformation redactedfor privacy. | S: Damages report re:Plaintiff Dukes cause ofaction. Only seal non-partyname on page 11 and thenumbers within the chartfrom page 11 (as tradesecret). The chart itselfshould not be redacted. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | Brass Decl., Ex. 21:Personnel File ofCarl Kirkland (Dkt.1069-48). | Non-party employmentinformation redactedfor privacy. | S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
| 7 | Brass Decl., Ex. 22:Personnel File ofIsidro Francisco(Dkt. 1069-49). | Non-party employmentinformation redactedfor privacy. | S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
| 8 | Brass Dec., Ex. 26:Deposition ofChristineKwapnoski, Vol. 1a) Page 9:19-20.b) Pages 296:16-20;297:10-11; 297:15-298:3; 298:8-22.c) Exhibits 5, 23,32, and 34. | a) Contact information.b) Testimony re: non-party employmentinformation redactedfor privacy.c) Redacted for privacyunder FRCP § 5.2. | a) S: Contact information.b) S: Testimony re: non-party employmentinformation.c) S: Non-party information. |
| 9 | Brass Dec., Ex. 27:Deposition ofChristineKwapnoski, Vol. IIPages 57:4-5; 8-9,and 23; 77:13. | Testimony re: non-party employmentinformation redactedfor privacy. | S: Non-party information. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | Brass Dec., Ex. 29:Deposition of AlanOshierPage 4:8-9 and 11. | Non-party informationredacted for privacyand under FRCP § 5.2. | S: Non-party information. |
| 11 | Brass Dec., Ex. 33:Deposition of BenDolanPage 6:14-15, 20,and 22. | Non-party informationredacted for privacyand under FRCP § 5.2. | S: Non-party information. |
| 12 | Brass Dec., Ex. 34:Deposition of PaulaVaccaroa) Page 7:16-17.b) Pages 119:2-25;122:10-11, 14, 16-17, and20-22; 123:1, 5, 20, and24; 124:1, 4, 9, 12, 17-18,21, and 24; 125:10; 126:9-11 and 15; 127:3, 10, and23-24; 128:2 and 7;154:10 and 25; 155:15, 1and 23l 156:4, 13, 16, and20-22; 157:5, 10, 13, 16and 25; 158:5, 12, 19-23,and 25; 159:1-2, and 20;160:1, 4, 8, 10, 12-14, 21,and 25; 161:1-2, 4, 10,and 21; 162:2, 9, 12, 15-17; 163:7-9 and 22-23;164:2-3, 13, 18, and 22;165:3 and 12 | a) Non-party informationredacted for privacy.b) Testimony re: non-partyemployment informationredacted for privacy. | a) S: Non-party information.b) S: Vaccaro deposition containspertinent information re: KwapnoskiCOA and general wage informationre: certain promotions and positionsrelative to Kwapnoski. Only namesof non-parties and their employmentinformation should be sealed(119:24-25; 122:10-11, 14, 16-17,and 20-22; 123:1, 20 and 24; 124:1,4, 9, 12, 17-18, 21, and 24; 126:10-11, and 15; 127:3, 10, and 23-24;128:2; 154:10, and 25; 155:15, and23; 156:4, 13, 16, and 20-22; 157:5,10, 13, 16, and 25; 158:5, 12, 19-23,and 25; 159:1-2, and 20; 160:1, 4, 8,10, 12-14, 21 and 25; 161:1-2, 4, 10,and 21; 162:2, 9, 12, and 15-17;163:7-9, and 22-23; 164:2-3, 13, 18,and 22; 165:3). |
|---|
| 13 | Brass Dec., Ex. 35:Deposition ofPhillip A. Goodwina) Page 4:4-5.b) Pages 24:14-24. | a) Non-party personal information redacted for privacy.b) Testimony re: non-party information redacted for privacy. | a) S: Non-party personal information.b) S: Testimony re: non-party information. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14 | Brass Dec., Ex. 37: Associate History Profile of Christine Kwapnoski. | Contact information redacted for privacy. | S: Contact information. |
| 15 | Brass Dec., Ex. 38: E-mail from Karen Koons to Mary Beth Lewis. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
| 16 | Brass Dec., Ex. 43:PCA01355, PCA01360, PCA01373-01375,PCA01439-01440,PCA01452-01455, PCA01543-01544, and PCA 01559-01561. | Non-party employment information, information relating to a non-party minor, and contact information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party employment information, contact information, and personal information (including family matters concerning non-party minor). |
| 17 | Brass Dec., Ex. 44: Associate History Profile of Brian Lothamer (Dkt. 1069-65). | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
| 18 | Brass Dec., Ex. 45: Associate History Profile of Roy Matherly (Dkt. 1069-66). | Non-party employment information redacting for privacy. | S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
| 19 | Brass Dec., Ex. 46: Associate History Profile of Michael Montgomery (Dkt. 1069-67). | Non-party employment information redacting for privacy. | S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
| 20 | Brass Dec., Ex. 47: Associate History Profile of AlbertoPadilla (Dkt. 1069-68). | Non-party employment information redacting for privacy. | S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
| 21 | Brass Dec., Ex. 48: Associate History Profile JoshuaReynold (Dkt.1069-69). | Non-party employment information redacting for privacy. | S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
| 22 | Brass Dec., Ex. 49: Associate History Profile of Bryce Sherman (Dkt. 1069-70). | Non-party employment information redacting for privacy. | S: Non-party employment information. |
| 23 | Brass Dec., Ex. 50: Associate History Profile of Chris Ward (Dkt. 1069-72). | Non-party employment information redacting for privacy. | S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
| 24 | Brass Dec., Ex. 51: Associate History Profile of TylerWhitney (Dkt.1069-72). | Non-party employment information redacting for privacy. | S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
| 25 | Brass Dec., Ex. 52: Associate History Profile of MarcArnold (Dkt. 1069-73). | Non-party employment information redacting for privacy. | S: Non-party employment information. |
| 26 | Brass Dec., Ex. 53: Associate History Profile of Paul Cortopassi (Dkt. 1069-74). | Non-party employment information redacting for privacy. | S: Non-party employment information. |
| 27 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 1: Deposition of Marvin Rapsa) Pages 3:11-12,14.b) Pages 120:16-20. | a) Non-party personal information redacted for privacy and underFRCP § 5.2.b) Testimony re: non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | a) S: Non-party personal information.b) S: Testimony re: non-party employment information. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 28 | Martyott Dec., Ex. 7: Deposition ofTanya Ellis (Dkt.1071-21)Page 2:10-11, and 13. | Non-party personal information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party personal information. |
| 29 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 8: Personnel File of Shaun Collins (Dkt. 1071-22). | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party personal information. |
| 30 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 12: Personnel File of Baljinder Jawanda (Dkt. 1071-23). | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party personal information. |
| 31 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 15: Deposition of Bernard Seamana) Page 3:13-16, 18,and 20.b) Page 111:3-4.c) Exhibit 3. | a) Non-party personal information redacted for privacy.b) Testimony re: non-party employment information redacted for privacy.c) Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | a) S: Non-party personal information.b) S: Non-party employment information.c) S: Non-party employment information. |
|---|
| 32 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 16: Deposition of David Riggsa) Page 4:18-19,and 21.b) Pages 241:21-242:4. | a) Non-party personal information redacted for personal information.b) Testimony regarding non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | a) S: Non-party personal information.b) S: Non-party employment information. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 33 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 17: Deposition of Varazat "John" KocharianPages 4:18-19, 22,and 24. | Non-party personal information redacted for privacy and under FRCP § 5.2. | S: Non-party personal information. |
| 34 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 18: Deposition of Judy Evans (Dkt. 1071-28)Page 4:9-10, and 20. | Non-party personal information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party personal information. |
| 35 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 19: Deposition of Lori Schmidta) Pages 7:20 and22-23.b) Exhibits 2 and 7. | a) Non-party personal information redacted for privacy.b) Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | a) S: Non-party personal information.b) S: Typo in Motion -should be Exhibits 6 and 7. Non-party employment information. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 36 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 20: Deposition of Edith Arana II(Dkt. 1070-30)Pages 69:3-6. | Testimony re: non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party employment information. |
| 37 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 21: Personnel File of Edith Arana. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party employment information. |
| 38 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 22: Deposition of Mickey AndersonPage 4:11-12, 14, 18, 23, and 25. | Non-party personal information redacted for privacy and underFRCP § 5.2. | S: Non-party personal information. |
| 39 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 24: Deposition of Deborah GunterPages 23:1-26:13; 28:1-29:22; 34:7-20; 116:21-117:2; 126:8-16; 162:9-18. | Testimony re: non-Party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party employment information. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40 | Maryott Dec., Ex. 26: Deposition of Jacqueline WilliamsPage 7:18 and 20-21. | Non-party personal information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party personal information. |
| 41 | Perry Dec., Ex. 4: Deposition of Charles Salby(Dkt. 1122-40)a) Page 4:16-20.b) Exhibit 1. | a) Non-party personal information redacted for privacy and underFRCP § 5.2.b) Non-party personal information redacted for privacy and underFRCP § 5.2. | a) S: Non-party personal information.b) S: Non-party employment information. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 42 | Perry Dec., Ex. 5: Deposition of Paula Vaccaroa) Page 7:16-17.b) Pages 75-76, 218, and Exhibit 8. | a) Non-party personal information redacted for privacy.b) Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | a) S: Non-party personal information.b) S: Non-party employment information; 75:1, and 11-12; 76:17, 20, and 22, 218 and Exhibit 8. |
| 43 | Perry Dec., Ex. 7: Deposition of Christine KwapnoskiPage 156:12. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Name of non-party. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 44 | Perry Dec., Ex. 8: Damages Report by Kirk Marangi. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Damages report re: Plaintiff Kwapnoski; wages earned, comparative wages per position, etc. Seal pay rate amount (trade secret). |
| 45 | Perry Dec., Ex. 10: Personnel File of Jon Salomone (Dkt. 1122-44). | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party employment information. |
| Perry Dec., Ex. 13: Deposition of PeterDanoffa) Page 6:13-14. | a) Non-party personal information. | a) S: Non-party personal information. | |
| b) Pages 56:3, 6, and 9; 99:1, 5, and 22-23; 103:2 and 6. | b) Non-party employment information. | b) Non-party employment information. |
| 46 | Perry Dec., Ex. 15: Deposition of JacquelineWilliams (Dkt. 1122-56)Pages 7:8, 20-21. | Non-party personal information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party personal information. |
|---|
| 47 | Declaration ofDonald Taylor. | Testimony relating tonon-party minorredacted for privacy. | S: Non-party minorinformation. |
| 48 | Exhibits to Declaration of Tracy Englebrechta) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. B: Mar. 12, 2015 Letter from Jenna Yott to Christine Webber.b) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. C: Mar. 17, 2015 Letter from Jenna Yott to Christine Webber.c) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. D: Mar. 17, 2015 Letter from Jenna Yott to Christine Webber.d) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. G: Mar. 10, 2015 Letter from Jenna Yott to Christine Webber.e) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. H: Mar. 5, 2015 Letter from Jenna Yott to Christine Webber.f) Englebrecht Decl., Ex. I: Mar. 19, 2015 Letter from Jenna Yott to Christine Webber. | a) Exhibit A: Non-party employment information.b) Exhibit A: Non-party employment information.c) Exhibit C: Non-party employment information.d) Exhibits A-B: Non-party employment information.e) Exhibit A: Non-party employment information.f) Exhibit A: Non-party employment information. | a) S: Non-party wage and employment information.b) S: Non-party wage and employment information.c) S: Non-party wage and employment information.d) S: Non-party wage and employment information.e) S: Non-party wage and employment information.f) S: Non-party wage and employment information. |
|---|
| 49 | Declaration of Paula VaccaroPages 2:17-18, 22-23, and 25-26; 3:2-5, 10, and 13; 4:27-5:2; 5:7-8. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | - NS: 2:17-18: Wage information for Plaintiff Dukes.- S: 2:22-23, and 25-26: Employment information of a non-party.- S: 3:2-5: Non-partyemployment information.- NS: 3:10 and 13: Wage and employment information of Plaintiff Dukes.- S: 4:27-5:2: Wageinformation of non-party.-NS: 5:7-8: Wageinformation of Plaintiff Arana. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 50 | Exhibits to Declaration of Paual VaccaroVaccaro Decl., Ex. 1: June 2012 RedbookInvestigation (ECF Nos. 1068-27 and 1068-28). | Non-party employment information. | NS: (Dkt. 1068-27)Investigation as to Christine Kwapnoski. Document should not be sealed in its entirety, but names of non-parties should be sealed.(Dkt. 1068-27): E-mails re:Kwapnoski. Seal contact information for non-parties. |
| 51 | Exhibits to Declaration of Michelle Medlina) Medlin Decl., Ex.1: WMDukes-086012-009-000000311.b) Medlin Decl., Ex. 2: WMDukes-000147-014-00000014-00000021.c) Medlin Decl., Ex.3: WMDukes-000147-012-00000014-00000015.d) Medlin Decl., Ex.4: Isenburg Report(PCA02584-PCA02599). | a) Non-party employment information redacted for privacy.b) Non-party employment information redacted for privacy.c) Non-party personal and employment information redacted for privacy.d) Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | a) S: Letter from non-party re: Plaintiff Kwapnoski. Only seal signature.b) S: Letter from non-party re: Plaintiff Kwapnoski. Seal names of non-party individuals.c) S: Declaration re: statement made by Plaintiff Kwapnoski. Seal names non-party individuals.d) S: Investigation report re: Plaintiff Kwapnoski. Seal names/information of non-party individuals. |
|---|
| 52 | Declaration of Brandyn Zobel in Support of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'sReplyMemorandum in Support of Its Motions for Summary JudgmentPages 5-6. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Non-party employmentinformation. |
|---|
| 53 | Exhibits to the Decl, of Brandyn Zobel in Support of Wal-Mart's Reply Memorandum in Support of its Mot. for Summary Judgmenta) Zobel Dec., Ex. A:March 17, 2015 Letter from Jenna Yott to Christine Webber, Ex. B.b) Zobel Dc., Ex. D:March 9, 2015 Letter from Jenna Yott to Christine Webber, Exhibits B & D (excerpts).c) Zobel Dec., Ex. E: Associate History Profile of William Biggs.d) Zobel Dec., Ex. F: Associate History Profile of Shawn Hill.e) Zobel Dec., Ex. G: Associate History Profile of Dwayne Givens.f) Zobel Dec., Ex. H: Associate History profile of Arthur French. | a) Non-party employment information redacted for privacy.b) Non-party employment information redacted for privacy.c) Non-party employment information.d) Non-party employment information.e) Non-party employment information.f) Non-party employment information. | a) S: Non-party employment information.b) S: Non-party employment information.c) S: Non-party employment information.d) S: Non-party employment information.e) S: Non-party employment information.f) S: Non-party employment information. |
|---|
| g) Zobel Dec., Ex. I:Associate History Profile of Ian Holm.h) Zobel Dec., Ex. J: Associate History Profile of Bruce Dreier.i) Zobel Dec., Ex. K: Associate History Profile of Chad Penn.j) Zobel Dec., Ex. L: Associate History Profile of Ronald Olguin. k) Zobel Dec., Ex. M: Associate History Profile of Frederic Frost. l) Zobel Dec., Ex. N: Associate History Profile of Zechariah Meyer. | g) Non-party employment information.h) Non-party employment information.i) Non-party employment information.j) Non-party employment information.k) Non-party employment information.l) Non-party employment information. | g) S: Non-party employment information.h) S: Non-party employment information.i) S: Non-party employment information.j) S: Non-party employment information.k) S: Non-party employment information.l) S: Non-party employment information. |
In the Administrative Motion to Seal, the numerical order is incorrect. That error is repeated here for purposes of consistency and cross reference. --------
BRIEFS
| 54 | Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s Notice of Motion and Motion for Partial Summary Judgment AgainstPlaintiff BettyDukes on her Second and Third Claims for Relief; Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support Thereof. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Only non-party names and information should besealed (4:6-9; 24:4). |
|---|---|---|---|
| 55 | Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s Notice of Motion and Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Against Plaintiff Christine Kwapnoski on her Second Claim forRelief;Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support Thereof. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Only non-party names and information should be sealed (10:8-9). |
| 56 | Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s Notice of Motion and Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Against Plaintiffs Patricia Surgeson, Edith Arana, and Deborah Gunter on their Second Claim forRelief;Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support Thereof. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Only non-party names and information should be sealed. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 57 | Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s Reply in Support of Motion for Partial Summary Judgment AgainstPlaintiff BettyDukes. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Only non-party names and information should besealed (17:14-18). |
| 58 | Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s Reply in Support of Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Against Plaintiff Christine Kwapnoski. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Only non-party names and information should besealed (15:2-21). |
|---|---|---|---|
| 59 | Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.'s Reply in Support of Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Against Plaintiffs Patricia Surgeson, Edith Arana, and Deborah Gunter. | Non-party employment information redacted for privacy. | S: Only non-party names and information should be sealed (15:28-16:5-7; 30:6-7). |
IT IS SO ORDERED. Date: August 25, 2015
/s/_________
CHARLES R. BREYER
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE