From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Downing v. McGrath

Supreme Court of California,In Bank
Jun 25, 1912
163 Cal. 813 (Cal. 1912)

Opinion

S.F. Nos. 5457, 5450, 5455, 5456, 5458.

June 25, 1912.

APPEALS from judgments of the Superior Court of the City and County of San Francisco and from orders refusing a new trial. George H. Buck, Judge presiding.

The facts are similar to those stated in the opinion in Dahler v. All Persons, ante, p. 160.

Norman H. Hurd, and A.A. Sanderson, for Appellant.

William J. Herrin, William S. Downing, and Oscar C. Mueller, for Respondents.

Crittenden Thornton, Amicus Curiae, on petition for a rehearing in Bank in No. 5458.


These cases, one and all, present the same proposition decided in Dahler v. All Persons (S.F. No. 5622), ante, p. 160, [ 124 P. 995].

The so-called abstract of title and certificate thereto of date February 24, 1908, were improperly admitted for the reasons given in the Dahler case. Wherefore, in each of the above entitled cases the judgment and order refusing a new trial are reversed and the cause remanded.

Rehearing denied.


Summaries of

Downing v. McGrath

Supreme Court of California,In Bank
Jun 25, 1912
163 Cal. 813 (Cal. 1912)
Case details for

Downing v. McGrath

Case Details

Full title:W.S. DOWNING et al., Respondents, v. WILLIAM McGRATH et al., CHRISTIANA G…

Court:Supreme Court of California,In Bank

Date published: Jun 25, 1912

Citations

163 Cal. 813 (Cal. 1912)
124 P. 997