Opinion
2002
DOCKET DISPOSITION TITLE NUMBER DATE AND JUDGES PARISH
Suard Barge Service v. Setten Marine, Inc. 2001 CA 0632 05/10/2002 Motion Terrebonne Granted; Affirmed CARTER, C.J. PARRO, J., concurs with reasons Campbell v. Graham 2001 CA 0729 05/10/2002 Affirmed in East Baton Part; Rouge Vacated in Part; Order Issued; Case Remanded CARTER, C.J., CLAIBORNE, J., concurs Breaud v. Watkins 2001 CA 0859 05/10/2002 Remanded East Baton CARTER, Rouge C.J., CLAIBORNE, J., concurs Brady v. Sandy Bayou Hunting Club, Inc. 2001 CA 0950 05/10/2002 Judgment Livingston Reversed in Part; Amended in Part; and as Amended Affirmed CARTER, C.J., PARRO, J., concurs in the result State v. Weary 2001 KA 2286 05/10/2002 Conviction, Washington Habitual Offender Adjudication and Sentence for Armed Robbery Affirmed; Remanded for Sentencing on Conviction for Attempted First-Degree Murder CARTER, C.J. State v. Thomas 2001 KA 2558 05/10/2002 Conviction, St. Tammany Habitual Offender Adjudication and Sentence Affirmed, with Instructions CARTER, C.J. PARRO, J., concurs Lenard v. LSU Health Sciences Center 2001 CA 0651 05/10/2002 Affirmed Civil Serv. PARRO, J. Com'n State v. Jordon 2001 KA 1672 05/10/2002 Conviction East Baton and Rouge Sentence Affirmed PARRO, J. State v. Murray 2001 KA 2402 05/10/2002 Conviction East Baton and Rouge Sentence Affirmed PARRO, J. State ex rel. L.C.B. 2001 CJ 2635 05/10/2002 Affirmed East Baton PARRO, J. Rouge State ex rel. L.C.B. 2001 CJ 2636 05/10/2002 Affirmed East Baton PARRO, J. Rouge State v. Johnson 2001 KA 2066 05/10/2002 Conviction Tangipahoa Affirmed; Sentence Vacated; Remanded for Resentencing IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. State v. Mason 2001 KA 2478 05/10/2002 Convictions East Baton and Rouge Sentences Affirmed IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. State v. Washington 2001 KA 2783 05/10/2002 Conviction East Baton and Rouge Sentence Affirmed IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. El Chico Restaurants of LA, Inc. v. LA Gaming Control Bd. 2001 CA 0205, 05/10/2002 Appeal East Baton 2001 CA 0206 Stayed; Rouge Remanded with Interim Order PER CURIAM Grigsby v. Fried 2001 CA 0149 05/10/2002 Affirmed East Baton FOIL, J. Rouge PETTIGREW, J. concurs and assigns reasons Besse v. Lakewood Hosp. 2001 CA 0535 05/10/2002 Affirmed St. Mary FOIL, J. Vollenweider v. Richards; Kramer v. Morris 2001 CA 0736 05/10/2002 Affirmed St. Tammany 2001 CA 0737 FOIL, J. State v. Huttner 2001 CA 1211 05/10/2002 Affirmed East Baton FOIL, J. Rouge State v. Brady 2001 KA 2513 05/10/2002 Conviction East Baton Affirmed, Rouge Habitual Offender Adjudication and Sentence Affirmed FOIL, J. State v. Bolton 2001 KA 2740 05/10/2002 Habitual Washington Offender Adjudication and Sentence Vacated; Remanded for Reopened Habitual Offender Hearing FOIL, J. State v. Nelson 2000 KA 2497 05/10/2002 Convictions East Baton and Rouge Sentences Affirmed PETTIGREW, J. Nsofor v. Allstate Indem. Co. 2001 CA 0635 05/10/2002 Reversed East Baton in Part; Rouge Amended in Part, and as Amended, Affirmed PETTIGREW, J. Hodges v. LA Health Service and Indem. Co. 2001 CA 0671 05/10/2002 Affirmed East Baton PETTIGREW, Rouge J. State v. Finley 2001 KA 2506 05/10/2002 Conviction East Baton and Rouge Sentence Affirmed PETTIGREW, J. State v. Sargent 2001 KA 2555 05/10/2002 Affirmed Terrebonne PETTIGREW, J. Feast v. Pittman 2001 CA 0540 05/10/2002 Reversed Pointe Coupee and Remanded WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. State v. Ambo 2001 KA 0756 05/10/2002 Conviction, St. Tammany Habitual Offender Adjudication, and Sentence Affirmed WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. Morris v. Thibodaux Regional Medical Center 2001 CA 0851 05/10/2002 Affirmed LaFourche WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. Antin-Quealy Jewelers v. Brown 2001 CA 0904 05/10/2002 Affirmed Hammond WILLIAM F. City Court KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. Boudreaux v. Comeaux 2001 CA 0968 05/10/2002 Affirmed East Baton WILLIAM F. Rouge KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. State v. Martin 2001 KA 1397 05/10/2002 Conviction Washington and Sentence WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. State v. Barrie 2001 KA 1734 05/10/2002 Conviction St. Tammany and Sentence on Count I Affirmed; Conviction, Habitual Offender Adjudication, and Sentence on Count II Affirmed; Conviction on Count III Affirmed; Sentence on Count III Vacated; Remanded for Re-sentencing on Count III WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. State v. Fairchild 2001 KA 2147 05/10/2002 Conviction St. Tammany Affirmed; Sentence Vacated; Remanded for Re-sentencing WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. PETTIGREW, J. concurs State v. Paul 2001 KA 2505 05/10/2002 Conviction St. Mary and Sentence WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. State v. Burnette 2001 KA 2631 05/10/2002 Conviction St. Tammany and Sentence Affirmed WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. Taylor v. Taylor 2002 CU 0314 05/10/2002 Affirmed Tangipahoa WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. State v. Dorsey 2001 KA 0490 05/10/2002 Conviction East Baton and Rouge Sentence Affirmed WHIPPLE, J. GUIDRY, J., concurs BMA Dialysis, Inc. v. LA Workers' Compensation Second Injury Bd. 2001 CA 0544 05/10/2002 Reversed East Baton and Rouge Rendered; Remanded with Order WHIPPLE, J. Parker v. City/ Parish of Baton Rouge 2001 CA 0779 05/10/2002 Affirmed East Baton WHIPPLE, J. Rouge Bezet v. Original Library Joe's, Inc.; Moonshower v. Original Library Joe's, Inc. 2001 CA 0798, 05/10/2002 Affirmed in East Baton 2001 CA 0799 Part; Rouge Reversed in Part WHIPPLE, J. State v. Bonvillain 2001 KA 2027 05/10/2002 Conviction Terrebonne Affirmed; Sentence Vacated; Remanded for Resentencing WHIPPLE, J. State v. Gaston 2001 KA 2288 05/10/2002 Conviction, East Baton Habitual Rouge Offender Adjudication, and Sentence Affirmed WHIPPLE, J. GUIDRY, J., concurs State v. Hicks 2000 KA 2638 05/10/2002 Conviction Ascension and Sentence Affirmed in Part; Remanded in Part with Order FOGG, J. WHIPPLE, J., concurs in part and dissents in part for reason assigned LeBlanc v. Scotch 2001 CA 0650 05/10/2002 Reversed St. Mary FOGG, J. Stevens v. Oubre 2001 CA 0938 05/10/2002 Affirmed City of FOGG, J. Plaquemine WHIPPLE, J., concurs. Absent any countervailing medical testimony, the result is legally correct under the jurisprudence and principles governing our review. GUIDRY, J., concurs for reasons assigned by Judge WHIPPLE In re Medical Review Panel for Moton 2001 CA 0967 05/10/2002 Affirmed East Baton FOGG, J. Rouge WHIPPLE, J., concurs GUIDRY, J., concurs State v. Johnson 2001 KA 2026 05/10/2002 Conviction Terrebonne Affirmed; Sentence Vacated; Remanded for Resentencing FOGG, J. State v. Hood 2001 KA 2507 05/10/2002 Conviction LaFourche Affirmed; Sentence Vacated; Remanded FOGG, J. GUIDRY, J., concurs Davidson v. Timken; Timken v. Davidson 2002 CU 0011 05/10/2002 Affirmed St. Tammany 2002 CU 0012 FOGG, J. GUIDRY, J., concurs in the result Squyres v. Gilliland 2001 CA 0996 05/10/2002 Affirmed East Baton GUIDRY, J. Rouge State v. Stephenson 2001 KA 2296 05/10/2002 Conviction St. Tammany and Sentence Affirmed GUIDRY, J. State v. Bergeron 2001 KA 2400 05/10/2002 Conviction LaFourche and Sentence Affirmed GUIDRY, J. State v. Hardy 2001 KA 2559 05/10/2002 Convictions St. Tammany and Sentences Affirmed GUIDRY, J. State v. Mayo 2000 KA 1216 05/10/2002 Remanded St. Tammany with Instructions FITZSIMMONS, J. Smallen v. Zachary Fire Police Civil Service Bd. 2001 CA 0541 05/10/2002 Reversed East Baton and Rouge Remanded FITZSIMMONS, J. DOWNING, J., concurs Sylvester v. Harmony Corp. 2001 CA 0752 05/10/2002 Affirmed West Baton FITZSIMMONS, Rouge J. DOWNING, J., concurs Scott v. Bill Hood Ford, Inc. 2001 CA 0805 05/10/2002 Affirmed Tangipahoa FITZSIMMONS, J. Gulfco of LA, Inc. v. Lester 2001 CA 0966 05/10/2002 Reversed St. Mary and Remanded FITZSIMMONS, J. State v. Fallon 2001 KA 1665 05/10/2002 Conviction St. Tammany Affirmed; Sentence Vacated; Case Remanded for Resentencing FITZSIMMONS, J. State v. Barrilleaux 2001 KA 1722 05/10/2002 Conviction St. Mary Affirmed; Sentence Vacated and Remanded for Resentencing FITZSIMMONS, J. State v. Griffith 2001 KA 2810 05/10/2002 Affirmed St. Tammany DOWNING, J. State v. Galatas 2001 KA 1574 05/10/2002 Affirmed in St. Tammany Part; Reversed and Remanded in Part WALTER I. LANIER JR., J. Pro Tem. DOWNING, J., concurs State v. Sibley 2001 KA 2236 05/10/2002 Affirmed Washington WALTER I. LANIER JR., J. Pro Tem. State v. Williams 2001 KA 2508 05/10/2002 Affirmed East Baton WALTER I. Rouge LANIER JR., J. Pro Tem. State v. Lilliman 2000 KA 2421 05/10/2002 Conviction Terrebonne Affirmed; Sentence Vacated; Remanded for Resentencing GONZALES, J. State v. Lilliman 2000 KA 2422 05/10/2002 Conviction Terrebonne Affirmed; Sentence Vacated; Remanded for Resentencing GONZALES, J. Universal Health Services, Inc. v. LA Patients' Compensation Fund Oversight Bd. 2001 CA 0748 05/10/2002 Reversed; East Baton Rendered Rouge GONZALES, J. Paige v. Stuart 2001 CA 0980 05/10/2002 Affirmed Washington GONZALES, J. State v. Gross 2001 KA 2320 05/10/2002 Convictions East Baton and Rouge Sentences Affirmed GONZALES, J. State Farm Mut. v. Lavergne 2001 CA 0604 05/10/2002 Reversed Ascension and Rendered KUHN, J. Brown v. Exxon Chemical Co. 2001 CA 0740 05/10/2002 Reversed East Baton and Rouge Remanded KUHN, J. Cosenza v. Guinn 2001 CA 0957 05/10/2002 Reversed East Baton and Rouge Remanded KUHN, J. State v. Lewis 2001 KA 2174 05/10/2002 Conviction Washington and Sentence Affirmed KUHN, J. State v. Lewis 2001 KA 2175 05/10/2002 Conviction Washington and Sentence Affirmed KUHN, J. State v. Berry 2001 KA 2321 05/10/2002 Sentences East Baton Affirmed Rouge KUHN, J. Ayo v. LSU Health Sciences Center 2001 CA 0707 05/10/2002 Affirmed Civil Serv. 2001 CA 0708 PHILIP C. Com'n CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Bedford v. Magee 2001 CA 0942 05/10/2002 Affirmed St. Tammany PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Dunn Law Firm, APLC v. Wohltmann 2001 CA 1044 05/10/2002 Vacated St. Tammany in Part and Remanded; Affirmed in Part PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. 06/11/2002 Reh. den. State v. Carter 2001 KA 1954 05/10/2002 Conviction West Feliciana Affirmed, Habitual Offender Adjudication and Sentence Affirmed PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. State v. Oliver 2001 KA 2294 05/10/2002 Conviction St. Mary Affirmed; Sentence Vacated; Remanded for Resentencing PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. State v. Willie 2001 KA 2782 05/10/2002 Conviction St. Tammany and Habitual Offender Adjudication Affirmed; Sentence Vacated and Case Remanded for Resentencing PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Edwards v. Baquet 2001 CA 0880 05/10/2002 Dismissed Wkrs. Comp PER CURIAM State v. Goodlow 1999 KA 3086 05/10/2002 Conviction Ascension and Sentence Affirmed PARRO, J. GUIDRY, J., dissents in part and concurs in part and assigns reasons Homes v. Lewis Motors Inc. 2000 CA 2778 05/10/2002 Affirmed East Baton CARTER, Rouge C.J., PARRO, J., dissents and assigns reasons GUIDRY, J., concurs in the result CLAIBORNE, J., dissents for reasons assigned by Judge PARRO Boudreaux v. Boudreaux 2001 CU 1688 05/10/2002 Judgment Terrebonne Reversed and Remanded in Part; Judgment Affirmed in Part LANIER, J. CARTER, J., agrees in part and dissents in part for reasons assigned by Judge DOWNING FITZSIMMONS, J., dissents in part and assigns reasons DOWNING, J., agrees in part and dissents and assigns reasons State v. Nash 2001 KA 2178 05/10/2002 Conviction St. Mary and Sentence Affirmed; Motion to Remand Appeal Denied FOIL, J. Pritchard v. Pritchard 2001 CA 1669 05/22/2002 Amended Tangipahoa and Affirmed as amended KLINE, J. Wilson v. McElveen 2001 CA 1765 05/22/2002 Affirmed East Baton CIACCIO, Rouge J. Roberson v. USAA Cas. Ins. Co. 2001 CA 1546 05/22/2002 Affirmed East Baton LANIER, J. Rouge Brewster v. LeBlanc 2001 CA 1784 05/22/2002 Affirmed East Baton DOWNING, J. Rouge Berman Daferner, Inc. v. Causey 2001 CA 1790 05/22/2002 Reversed East Baton and Rouge Rendered CLAIBORNE, J. Ulm v. Ulm 2001 CA 1877 05/22/2002 Affirmed St. Tammany KLINE, J. Works v. Cooper 2001 CA 1840 05/22/2002 Affirmed Tangipahoa LANIER, J. Burnette v. Stalder 2001 CA 1878 05/22/2002 Affirmed East Baton CIACCIO, J. Rouge Peterson v. Walston 2001 CA 0857 05/22/2002 Reversed East Baton and Rouge Remanded FOGG, J. CIACCIO, J., dissents and assigns reasons