Opinion
2003
DOCKET DISPOSITION TITLE NUMBER DATE AND JUDGES PARISH
Joseph v. Housing Authority of New Orleans; Cox v. Housing Authority of New Orleans; Celious v. Housing Authority of New Orleans 2002 CA 0013, 01/15/2003 Appeals Civil Serv. 2002 CA 0014, Dismissed Com'n DOWNING, J. 2002 CA 0015 02/28/2003 Reh. den. Robertson v. Robertson 2001 CA 2859 03/05/2003 Motion to St. Tammany Strike Granted. Affirmed in Part, Amended in Part and Affirmed as Amended McDONALD, J. Ramazanzadeh v. Cooney 2002 CA 0725 03/28/2003 Affirmed East Baton CARTER, J. Rouge Walker v. Harden 2002 CA 0838 03/28/2003 Appeal East Baton Dismissed; Rouge Remanded for Further Proceedings CARTER, J. Wheelock v. Fife 2002 CA 1059 03/28/2003 Affirmed East Baton CARTER, J. Rouge Moran v. Louisiana Dept. of Social Services 2002 CA 1160 03/28/2003 Affirmed Tangipahoa CARTER, J. State v. Pier 2002 KA 1476 03/28/2003 Conviction Ascension and Sentence CARTER, J. Parker v. First American Ins. Co. 2002 CA 1564 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany State v. Stephens 2002 KA 1851 03/28/2003 Conviction, Livingston Habitual Offender Adjudication and Sentence Affirmed CARTER, J. Ferrant v. Ferrant 2002 CU 2654 03/28/2003 Reversed Tangipahoa CARTER, J. WHIPPLE, J., concurs in the results Dupre v. Clarendon Nat. Ins. Co. 2002 CA 0647 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Mary WHIPPLE, J. Guillory v. ORYX Energy Co. 2002 CA 1148 03/28/2003 Affirmed Terrebonne WHIPPLE, J. Arrington v. Louisiana Bd. of Review 2002 CA 1610 03/28/2003 Reversed East Baton WHIPPLE, J. Rouge State v. Gant 2002 KA 1885 03/28/2003 Remanded East Feliciana for Evidentiary Hearing WHIPPLE, J. Blackmar v. Richardson 2002 CA 0365 03/28/2003 Vacated East Baton and Rouge Remanded with Instructions PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Reese v. State Farm Ins. Co. 2002 CA 0411 03/28/2003 Affirmed East Baton PHILIP C. Rouge CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. WHIPPLE, J., dissents for reasons assigned Colvin v. Medical Center of Baton Rouge 2002 CA 0605 03/28/2003 Affirmed East Baton PHILIP C. Rouge CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. CARTER, J., concurs Levy v. St. Tammany Parish School Bd. 2002 CA 0781 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Johnson v. Williams 2002 CA 0885 03/28/2003 Affirmed West Feliciana PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Parish Nat. Bank v. King 2002 CA 0991 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Kimble v. Fleet Mortg. Co. 2002 CA 1082 03/28/2003 Vacated East Baton and Rouge Remanded PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. State v. McNabb 2002 KA 1696 03/28/2003 Conviction East Baton Reversed, Rouge Sentence Vacated, and Case Remanded to the Trial Court for Further Proceedings PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. State v. Davis 2002 KA 1939 03/28/2003 Conviction St. Tammany Affirmed; Sentence Affirmed as Amended PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Berry v. Cain 2002 CA 1147 03/28/2003 Reversed East Baton and Rouge Remanded PARRO, J. State v. Dehart 2002 KA 1478 03/28/2003 Convictions Terrebonne and Sentences Affirmed PARRO, J. State v. Horne 2002 KA 1904 03/28/2003 Convictions St. Tammany on Counts 1 and 2 Affirmed; Sentences om Counts 1 and 2 Vacated; Remanded with Instructions PARRO, J. McDonald, J., concurs Woodrow Wilson Const. Co., Inc. v. Coker Equipment Co., Inc. 2002 Ca 0829 03/28/2003 Amended East Baton and as Rouge Amended, Affirmed McDONALD, J., PARRO, J., concurs Martin v. Morgan 2002 CA 1596 03/28/2003 Affirmed East Baton McDONALD, Rouge J. CLAIBORNE, J., concurs for the reasons given by the trial court State v. Poindexter 2002 KA 2007 03/28/2003 Conviction Terrebonne and Sentence Affirmed McDONALD, J. PARRO, J., concurs CLAIBORNE, J., dissents and assigns reasons Mount v. St. Anne General Hosp. 2002 CA 0630 03/28/2003 Affirmed Lafourche IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. Harrell v. Sibley 2002 CA 0934 03/28/2003 Reversed Livingston and Remanded IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. Elder v. State 2002 CA 0994 03/28/2003 Affirmed East Baton IAN W. Rouge CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. Smith v. Tidelands Seafood Co., Inc. 2002 CA 1072 03/28/2003 Affirmed Terrebonne IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. State v. Shoals 2002 KA 2058 03/28/2003 Convictions East Baton and Rouge Sentences Affirmed IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. Brockhaus v. Regions Bank 2002 CA 0654 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany FOIL, J. Armstead v. Harris Chevrolet, Inc. 2002 CA 0898 03/28/2003 Affirmed East Baton FOIL, J. Rouge McCLENDON, J., dissents and assigns reasons KLINE, J., concurs Arms v. Arms 2002 CA 0986 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany FOIL, J. Allen v. Thomas 2002 CA 1003 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany FOIL, J. McCLENDON, J., concurs Mallet v. City of Maringouin 2002 CA 1095 03/28/2003 Reversed Iberville and Rendered FOIL, J. McCLENDON, J., concurs Hibernia Nat. Bank v. Sandiford 2002 CA 1106 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Mary FOIL, J. Succession of Saunders 2002 CA 1283 03/28/2003 Affirmed East Baton in Part, Rouge Reversed in Part, and Remanded FOIL, J. Matthews v. Thompson 2002 CA 1286 03/28/2003 Affirmed Terrebonne FOIL, J. McCLENDON, J., concurs Hines v. McGrath 2002 CA 0723 03/28/2003 Reversed St. Tammany McCLENDON, J. Charpentier v. Accardo 2002 CA 1141 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Mary McCLENDON, J. Garner v. New Hampshire Ins. Co. 2002 CA 0635 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Mary WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. McCLENDON, J., agrees in part and dissents in part with reasons International Paper Co. v. East Feliciana Parish School Bd. 2002 CA 0648 03/28/2003 Affirmed East Feliciana WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. Owens v. Brandt 2002 CA 0724 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. McField v. Virginia's Medical Transp. 2002 CA 0834 03/28/2003 Affirmed East Baton WILLIAM F. Rouge KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. McCLENDON, J., dissents with reasons Toups v. Toups 2002 CA 0888 03/28/2003 Affirmed Terrebonne WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. McCLENDON, J., agrees in part and dissents in part with reasons Doe v. Doe 2002 CA 0940 03/28/2003 Amended, East Baton and as Rouge Amended, Affirmed WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. Bergeron v. The Family Doctor Clinic of Thibodaux 2002 CA 1001 03/28/2003 Affirmed Lafourche WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. Riles v. Swiftships, Inc. 2002 CA 1132 03/28/2003 Affirmed St. Mary WILLIAM F. KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. Rogers v. The Dow Chemical Co. 2002 CA 1325 03/28/2003 Affirmed East Baton WILLIAM F. Rouge KLINE JR., J. Pro Tem. McCLENDON, J., concurs Patin v. Landry; Patin v. Applied Indus. Technologies-Dixie Inc.; Patin v. Soileau 2002 CA 0118, 03/28/2003 Amended, East Baton 2002 CA 0119, and as Rouge 2002 CA 0120 Amended, Affirmed PARRO, J. Allen v. Georgia Cas. and Sur. 2002 CA 1016 04/02/2003 Affirmed East Feliciana FITZSIMMONS, J. Columbia Gulf Transmission Co. v. Faith Rentals, L.L.C. 2002 CA 1249 04/02/2003 Affirmed Terrebonne in Part; Reversed in Part, Recast, and Remanded FITZSIMMONS, J. GUIDRY, J., concurs Washington v. Dept. of Health and Hospitals 2002 CA 1358 04/02/2003 Affirmed Civil Serv. FITZSIMMONS, J. State v. Springer 2002 KA 1633 04/02/2003 Conviction East Baton Affirmed; Rouge Sentence Amended; and Affirmed as Amended FITZSIMMONS, J. State v. Pursell 2002 KA 1841 04/02/2003 Conviction St. Tammany and Sentence Affirmed FITZSIMMONS, J. Jarrell Mackson 2002 CA 0650 04/02/2003 Amended, East Baton and as Rouge Amended, Affirmed GUIDRY, J. FITZSIMMONS, J., dissents in part and assigns reasons PETTIGREW, J., concurs Almond v. Almond 2002 CU 2522 04/02/2003 Amended, Livingston and as Amended, Affirmed GUIDRY, J. FITZSIMMONS, J., concurs and assigns reasons PETTIGREW, J., concurs in part and dissents in part and assigns reasons Stewart v. Our Lady of Lake Hosp., Inc. 2002 CA 0633 04/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton PETTIGREW, Rouge J. GUIDRY, J., dissents. I do not find the trial courts finding of the 2-5 minute delay to be a reasonable one Lambert v. Estate of Caballero 2002 CA 0831 04/02/2003 Affirmed Assumption PETTIGREW, J. Thomas v. The LA Dept. of Public Safety and Corrections 2002 CA 1379 04/02/2003 Reversed East Baton and Rouge Remanded PETTIGREW, J. Edwards v. Greenwood 2002 CA 1464 04/02/2003 Affirmed Pointe Coupee PETTIGREW, J. State v. Johnson 2002 KA 1796 04/02/2003 Conviction, Terrebonne Habitual Offender Adjudication, and Sentence Affirmed PETTIGREW, J. FITZSIMMONS, J., concurs GUIDRY, J., concurs Cole v. LSU Health Scienses Center 2002 CA 0671 04/02/2003 Affirmed Civil Serv. KUHN, J. Ajala v. State 2002 CA 0805 04/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton KUHN, J. Rouge DOWNING, J., dissents and assigns reasons Smart v. State Farm Ins. Companies 2002 CA 0990 04/02/2003 Reversed East Baton and Rouge Rendered in part; Affirmed in Part KUHN, J. DOWNING, J., concurs Jackson v. Louisiana Dept. of Public Safety Corrections 2002 CW 1085 04/02/2003 Application East Baton for Rouge Supervisory Writs Denied KUHN, J. Altazan v. Smith 2002 CA 1155, 04/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton 2002 CA 1156 KUHN, J. Rouge State v. Ausbon 2002 KA 1403 04/02/2003 Conviction East Baton and Rouge Sentence Affirmed KUHN, J. State v. Davis 2002 KA 1558 04/02/2003 Conviction West Feliciana and Sentence Affirmed KUHN, J., DOWNING, J., concurs State v. Hacker 2002 KA 1474 04/02/2003 Convictions East Baton and Rouge Sentences Affirmed KUHN, J. Achee v. Baimbridge; Achee v. Trahan 2002 CA 0594, 04/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton 2002 CA 0595 DOWNING, J. Rouge Weaver v. Owens 2002 CA 0669 04/02/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany DOWNEY, J. State ex rel. C.T. 2002 CA 0778 04/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton DOWNEY, J. Rouge GAIDRY. J., dissents with reasons Ramey v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. 2002 CA 0784 04/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton DOWNING, J. Rouge In re Succession of Brown 2002 CA 1131 04/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton DOWNING, J. Rouge Armstrong v. Kaylo 2002 CA 1398 04/02/2003 Affirmed East Baton DOWNING, J. Rouge Garner v. Adams 2002 CA 1731 04/02/2003 Affirmed Tangipahoa State v. White 2002 KA 1866 04/02/2003 Convictions St. Tammany Affirmed, Sentences Vacated, and Remanded for Resentencing DOWNING, J. State ex rel. Dennis v. Brady 2002 CA 0531 04/02/2003 Affirmed Livingston GAIDRY, J. KUHN, J., concurs DOWNING, J., dissents and assigns reasons Adams v. Teague 2002 CA 0645 04/02/2003 Reversed East Baton GAIDRY, J. Rouge Gateway Ford, Inc. v. Gaule 2002 CA 0804 04/02/2003 Affirmed Tangipahoa GAIDRY, J. DOWNING, J., agrees in part and dissents in part and assigns reasons Perrodin v. St. Paul Fire Marine Ins. Co. 2002 CA 1213 04/02/2003 Reversed Assumption in part; Amended in Part; and as Amended Affirmed GAIDRY, J. DOWNING, J. Brown v. Clark 2002 CA 1445 04/02/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany GAIDRY, J. State v. Claville 2002 KA 1585 04/02/2003 Both East Baton Convictions Rouge and Sentences Affirmed GAIDRY, J. State v. Williams 2002 KA 1938 04/02/2003 Affirmed Assumption GAIDRY, J. KUHN, J., dissents and assigns reasons Strain v. Strain 2002 CU 2373 04/02/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany GAIDRY, J. KUHN, J., concurs and assigns reasons DOWNING, J., concurs for the reasons assigned by KUHN, J.