Opinion
2002-2003
DOCKET DISPOSITION TITLE NUMBER DATE AND JUDGES PARISH
Baham v. Intern. Maintenance Corp. 2001 CA 2128 10/17/2002 Affirmed East Baton FITZSIMMONS, Rouge J., GUIDRY, J., dissents and assigns reasons Blount v. Blount 2001 CA 2701 11/08/2002 Vacated and Livingston Rendered GAIDRY, J. LeBlanc Waddell, L.L.C. v. Maples 2001 CA 2481 11/08/2002 Motion East Baton Granted; Rouge Appeals Dismissed PER CURIAM Lambert ex rel. Lambert v. Harrington 2001 CA 2588 12/30/2002 Reversed and Tangipahoa Remanded PARRO, J. Lyons v. State ex rel. Dept. of Transp. and Development 2001 CA 2623 01/08/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany JAMES, J. Patrick v. Bayou Fabricators Mach. Pump, Inc. 2002 CA 0081 01/29/2003 Reversed and West Baton Remanded Rouge CARTER, J. WHIPPLE, J., concurs in the results Patrick v. Bayou Fabricators Mach. Pump, Inc. 2002 CA 1800 01/29/2003 Reversed West Baton CARTER, J. Rouge WHIPPLE, J., concurs in the results Hue v. Rodrigue 2002 CA 0246 02/14/2003 Affirmed Lafourche CARTER, J. Giarrusso v. Giarrusso 2002 CA 0389 02/14/2003 Appeal St. Tammany Dismissed CARTER, J. Rochon v. Sterling 2002 CA 0417 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton CARTER, J. Rouge Minvielle v. State Farm Ins. Cos. 2002 CA 0529 02/14/2003 Reversed and East Baton Remanded Rouge with Instructions CARTER, J. Dickerson v. Southern Bombay Enterprises, Inc. 2002 CA 0866 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton CARTER, J. Rouge Wright v. II Diamond Motors, Inc. 2002 CA 0188 02/14/2003 Vacated and East Baton Remanded Rouge WHIPPLE, J. Montez v. Reynolds 2002 CA 0363 02/14/2003 Affirmed Lafourche WHIPPLE, J. Lafayette Ins. Co. v. Pizzolato 2002 CA 0511 02/14/2003 Affirmed Ascension WHIPPLE, J. Shelmire v. Reed 2002 CA 0989 02/14/2003 Affirmed City Court WHIPPLE, J. Baton Rouge State v. Johnson 2002 KA 1459 02/14/2003 Conviction Terrebonne and Sentence Affirmed WHIPPLE, J. Muhammad v. Stalder 2002 CA 0400 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton PHILIP C. Rouge CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. Creighton v. Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. 2002 CA 0901 02/14/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. George v. Borden Chemicals and Plastics Operating Ltd. Partnership 2002 CA 0988 02/14/2003 Appeal Ascension Dismissed; Remanded PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. State v. Chisolm 2002 KA 1557 02/14/2003 Convictions West Feliciana and Sentences Affirmed PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. State v. Williams 2002 KA 1449 02/14/2003 Conviction East Baton Affirmed; Rouge Sentence Vacated; and Remanded for Resentencing PHILIP C. CIACCIO, J. Pro Tem. State v. Cochran 2002 KA 1454 02/14/2003 Convictions, East Baton Habitual Rouge Offender Adjudication, and Sentences Affirmed PARRO, J. Mechana v. Mechana 2002 CA 0391 02/14/2003 Affirmed Pointe Coupee McDONALD, J. Hebert v. Morvant 2002 CA 0515 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton McDONALD, J. Rouge CLAIBORNE, J., agrees in part and dissents in part with reasons Tarver v. Farmer 2002 CA 0565 02/14/2003 Reversed and Ascension Remanded McDONALD, J. PARRO, J., concurs Kinchen v. Morrison 2002 CA 0600 02/14/2003 Affirmed Livingston McDONALD, J. State v. Anthony 2002 KA 0906 02/14/2003 Conviction St. Tammany and Sentence Affirmed IAN W. CLAIBORNE, J. Pro Tem. Williams v. HBM River Plant, Inc. 2002 CA 0551 02/14/2003 Affirmed Ascension FITZSIMMONS, J. State v. Lorio 2002 KA 1623 02/14/2003 Conviction St. Tammany and Sentence Affirmed FITZSIMMONS, J. State v. Lorio 2002 KA 1624 02/14/2003 Conviction St. Tammany and Sentence Affirmed FITZSIMMONS, J. Love v. AAA Temporaries, Inc. 2002 CA 0615 02/14/2003 Vacated and East Baton Remanded Rouge with Instructions GUIDRY, J. State v. Matthews 2002 KA 1260 02/14/2003 Conviction East Baton and Sentence Rouge Affirmed; Defense Counsel's Motion to Withdraw, Granted GUIDRY, J. State v. Brumfield 2002 KA 1620 02/14/2003 Convictions St. Tammany Affirmed; Habitual Offender Adjudication and Sentence Vacated, and Remanded with Instructions GUIDRY, J. State v. Emerson 2002 KA 1717 02/14/2003 Conviction Ascension Sentence Vacated and Remanded for Resentencing GUIDRY, J. State v. Bickham 2002 KA 1129 02/14/2003 Conviction Washington and Sentence Affirmed PETTIGREW, J. State v. Dent 2002 KA 1475 02/14/2003 Convictions West Feliciana Affirmed; Sentences Vacated; Remanded for Resentencing PETTIGREW, J. State v. Casborn 2002 KA 1576 02/14/2003 Convictions St. Tammany Affirmed. Sentences Imposed Under Bills of Information 329936 and 329937 Affirmed. Sentence Imposed Under Bill of Information 329935 Vacated; Remanded for Resentencing PETTIGREW, J. Slaughter v. Alpha 2002 CA 0620 02/14/2003 Appeal Lafourche Marine Services, Dismissed Inc. KUHN, J. Slaughter v. North 2002 CA 0856 02/14/2003 Appeal Lafourche American Dismissed Shipbuilding KUHN, J. State v. West 2002 KA 1048 02/14/2003 Conviction Ascension Affirmed; Sentence Amended; and Affirmed as Amended KUHN, J. State v. Harris 2002 KA 1267 02/14/2003 Convictions East Baton and Rouge Sentences Affirmed KUHN, J. Young v. Rouses Enterprises 2002 CA 1335 02/14/2003 Reversed St. Mary KUHN, J. Deya v. Cascio 2002 CA 0249 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton DOWNING, J. Rouge KUHN, J., dissents. Baker v. Beatty 2002 CA 0367 02/14/2003 Affirmed Livingston DOWNING, J. Walker v. State 2002 CA 0574 02/14/2003 Appeal East Baton Dismissed Rouge DOWNING, J. KUHN, J., concurs Brown v. LeBlanc 2002 CA 0662 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton DOWNING, J. Rouge KUHN, J., concurs GAIDRY, J. concurs State v. McKinney 2002 KA 1254 02/14/2003 Conviction, St. Tammany Habitual Offender Adjudication, and Sentence Affirmed on Count II; Conviction Affirmed on Count I; Sentence Amended on Count I Sentence Affirmed as Amended on Count I DOWNING, J. State v. Stoves 2002 KA 1285 02/14/2003 Conviction Terrebonne and Sentence Affirmed DOWNING, J. State v. Pedelahore 2002 KA 1622 02/14/2003 Conviction, St. Tammany Habitual Offender Adjudication and Sentence Affirmed DOWNING, J. Carmona v. State 2002 CA 0253 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton GAIDRY, J. Rouge Gros v. Campo 2002 CA 0749 02/14/2003 Reversed in Assumption Part and Affirmed in Part GAIDRY, J. State v. Charles 2002 KA 1577 02/14/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany GAIDRY, J. Bernard v. General 2002 CA 0097 02/14/2003 Reversed Lafourche Sec. Property FOIL, J. Cas. Co. Shannon v. Bourgeois 2002 CA 0293 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton FOIL, J. Rouge Ribbeck v. Ribbeck 2002 CA 0427 02/14/2003 Amended and St. Tammany as Amended, Affirmed FOIL, J. Thibodeaux v. Amoco Corp. 2002 CA 0536 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton FOIL, J. Rouge Vansickel v. Tassin 2002 CA 0614 02/14/2003 Affirmed Livingston FOIL, J. Webre v. Webre 2002 CA 1317 02/14/2003 Affirmed Lafourche FOIL, J. McCLENDON, J., dissents for reasons assigned Terry-Sipos v. McGill 2002 CA 0537 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton McCLENDON, J. KLINE, J., dissents with reasons Bethley v. Bethley 2002 CU 2066 02/14/2003 Judgment East Baton Vacated Rouge McCLENDON, J. Thibodeaux v. Arthur Rutenburg Homes, Inc. 2002 CA 1332 02/14/2003 Reversed in Livingston Part; Affirmed in Part; and Rendered McCLENDON, J. Klaimon v. JS Investigations 2001 CA 2877 02/14/2003 Affirmed St. Tammany WILLIAM F. KLINE, J. Pro Tem. Hamilton v. Anco Insulation, Inc. 2002 CA 0221 02/14/2003 Reversed Ascension WILLIAM F. KLINE, J., Pro Tem. State v. Wells 2002 CA 0390 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton WILLIAM F. Rouge KLINE, J., Pro Tem. Wiggins v. Our Lady of the Lake Hosp., Inc. 2002 CA 0514 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton WILLIAM F. Rouge KLINE, J., Pro Tem. Alost v. Alost 2002 CA 0889 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton WILLIAM F. Rouge KLINE, J., Pro Tem. Angelette v. Lady of the Sea General Hosp. 2002 CA 0930 02/14/2003 Affirmed Lafourche WILLIAM F. KLINE, J., Pro Tem. Stroscher v. Stroscher 2002 CU 0871 02/14/2003 Affirmed in East Baton Part; Rouge Reversed in Part CARTER, J. WHIPPLE, J., concurs in part dissents in part for reason assigned FITZSIMMONS, J., dissents in part and assigns reasons Ezell v. Direct Labor, Inc. 2002 CA 0567 02/14/2003 Affirmed Terrebonne GUIDRY, J. Touranian v. Mizyed 2001 CA 2424 02/14/2003 Affirmed East Baton FITZSIMMONS, Rouge J. CARTER, J., concurs in the result GUIDRY, J., dissents and assigns reasons PETTIGREW, J. concurs in part, dissents in part and assigns reasons CLAIBORNE, J., concurs. Matherne v. Matherne 2001 CU 2029, 02/14/2003 Appeals St. Tammany 2001 CU 2030 Dismissed in Part and Reversed in Part PARRO, J. Robertson v. Neuromedical Center 2002 CA 0008 02/19/2003 Affirmed in East Baton Part, Rouge Reversed in Part, and Rendered JAMES, J.