From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Cooper v. Passmore

Supreme Court of Florida, Division B
Nov 30, 1931
138 So. 48 (Fla. 1931)

Opinion

Opinion filed November 30, 1931.

An appeal from the Circuit Court for Dade County; H. F. Atkinson, Judge.

Clark Johnson and Loftin, Stokes Calkins, for Appellant;

Chappell Allen, for Appellee.


A bill of complaint by C. W. Cooper sought the cancellation of record of notices of mechanics liens filed by W. H. Passmore upon real estate of Cooper, the theory being that the liens were not authorized by the statute. By answer and cross bill Passmore asserted the validity of his liens and prayed for their enforcement.

The Court dismissed the original bill and decreed an enforcement of the mechanic's liens. An appeal was taken by Cooper.

By a contract between the parties, Passmore agreed to build certain houses for Cooper who agreed to pay Passmore "five hundred dollars on each house, this in addition to his daily wages, this amount is due and payable upon completion of each house, garage and garage apartment, and accepted by * Cooper." "Passmore agreed to rush work to completion as rapidly and economically as possible and to do the work agreeable to * Cooper."

Assuming that Passmore was entitled to liens for "five hundred dollars on each house in addition to his daily wages," the burden was upon Passmore to prove that he did "rush work to completion as rapidly and economically as possible and" did "do the work agreeable to * Cooper;" and that each house was completed and accepted by Cooper. This is not shown by the probative force of the evidence. If the "completion of each house" and its acceptance by Cooper were prevented by Cooper in violation of the intendments of the contract, Passmore's remedy is at law for a breach of contract.

Mechanics liens are acquired under the statute by the performance of labor not by the breach of a contract to perform labor.

Reversed.

TERRELL AND DAVIS, J.J., concur.

BUFORD, C.J., AND ELLIS AND BROWN, J.J., concur in the opinion and judgment.


Summaries of

Cooper v. Passmore

Supreme Court of Florida, Division B
Nov 30, 1931
138 So. 48 (Fla. 1931)
Case details for

Cooper v. Passmore

Case Details

Full title:C. W. COOPER, Appellant, vs. W. H. PASSMORE, Appellee

Court:Supreme Court of Florida, Division B

Date published: Nov 30, 1931

Citations

138 So. 48 (Fla. 1931)
138 So. 48

Citing Cases

Twenty-Four Coll. v. M. Weinbaum

If after remand the trial court finds in favor of Weinbaum, then Weinbaum will be entitled, as it contends on…

Pitts v. Ahlswede

57 C.J.S. Mechanics' Liens § 96, p. 606. Cooper v. Passmore, 103 Fla. 744, 138 So. 48. We have not overlooked…