Opinion
Argued April 18, 1872
Decided April 23, 1872
D.C. Calvin for the appellant.
Samuel A. Noyes for the respondent.
GROVER, J., reads opinion for affirmance. FOLGER, ALLEN and RAPALLO, JJ., concur; CHURCH, Ch. J., and PECKHAM, J., dissent.
(There was a question in the case as to the rejection of evidence. The court held the rejection error, but the majority held that the plaintiff could not have been injured thereby. The dissent was to this view.)