Opinion
June 14, 1974.
September 23, 1974.
Criminal Law — Practice — Appeal to Court of Common Pleas from summary conviction before Justice of the Peace — Appeal dismissed by Court of Common Pleas — Requirement that judgment of Court of Common Pleas be "guilty" or "not guilty".
1. In this case, the defendant appealed from a summary conviction before a Justice of the Peace. After a hearing de novo, the court below dismissed the appeal. It was Held that the judgment of the lower court must be reversed.
2. On an appeal from the judgment of a Justice of the Peace in summary conviction proceedings, the judgment of the Court of Common Pleas must be either "guilty" or "not guilty".
3. A judgment affirming the Justice of the Peace, dismissing the appeal, or sustaining the appeal, is not sufficient and will be reversed.
Before WATKINS, P.J., JACOBS, HOFFMAN, CERCONE, PRICE, VAN DER VOORT, and SPAETH, JJ.
Appeal, No. 97, Oct. T., 1974, from order of Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County, April T., 1973, No. 1131, in case of Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. William Henry Carter. Order reversed with a procedendo.
Proceedings upon appeal from summary conviction before Justice of the Peace. Before STANZIANI, J., without a jury.
Order entered dismissing appeal from summary conviction. Defendant appealed.
David B. Fitzgerald, with him Fitzgerald Yatsko, for appellant.
Stewart J. Greenleaf, Assistant District Attorney, with him William T. Nicholas, First Assistant District Attorney, and Milton O. Moss, District Attorney, for Commonwealth, appellee.
Argued June 14, 1974.
This case is before us on appeal from the action of the court below dismissing Appellant's appeal from a summary conviction for disorderly conduct (a violation of 18 Pa. C.S. § 5503). After a hearing de novo, the lower court stated on the record: ". . . this Court finds that the Appeal from Summary Conviction should be dismissed and therefore dismisses it." As we have held repeatedly, on an appeal from the judgment of a justice of the peace in summary conviction proceedings, the judgment of the Court of Common Pleas should be either "guilty" or "not guilty"; a judgment affirming the justice of the peace, dismissing the appeal, or sustaining the appeal, is not sufficient and will be reversed. Commonwealth v. Alton, 209 Pa. Super. 168, 224 A.2d 792 (1966); Commonwealth v. Young, 184 Pa. Super. 658, 135 A.2d 774 (1957); Commonwealth v. Miller, 173 Pa. Super. 168, 96 A.2d 153 (1953). Even though a finding of guilt is implicit in the lower court's opinion, nowhere in the record of the case before us do we discern a specific finding of "guilty" or "not guilty"; therefore, we reverse the order of the court below and remit the record with direction to hear the case and enter such judgment as the law and evidence require.
Order reversed with a procedendo.