From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Combined Transport, Inc. v. Employment Division

Oregon Court of Appeals
Dec 16, 1986
82 Or. App. 127 (Or. Ct. App. 1986)

Opinion

84-T-72; CA A35561

On petitioner's reconsideration filed October 8, 1986, reconsideration allowed.

Former opinion ( 81 Or. App. 31, 724 P.2d 832) modified and adhered to as modified November 12, petition for review denied December 16, 1986 ( 302 Or. 460).

Judicial Review from Employment Division Referee.

Daniel C. Thorndike, and Blackhurst, Hornecker, Hassen Brian, Medford, for petition.

No appearance contra.

Before Joseph, Chief Judge, and Van Hoomissen and Young, Judges.


JOSEPH, C. J.

Reconsideration allowed; former opinion modified and adhered to as modified.


Petitioner has filed a petition for review in the Supreme Court, which we treat as a petition for reconsideration. ORAP 10.10. In our opinion, 81 Or. App. 31, 36, 724 P.2d 832 (1986), we said:

"The owner-operators maintain their trucks, but petitioner pays all fuel costs, fuel taxes, road taxes, equipment use fees, equipment license fees, driver's license fees, permits, tolls and any other fees and fines assessed on the equipment being used for it. Petitioner also pays the insurance premiums on the leased trucks."

Petitioner correctly points out that that is a misstatement of the facts. Owner-operators are responsible for all costs incurred in transporting loads for petitioner. If petitioner is required by state or federal regulatory agencies to advance fees or taxes, the amounts it pays are deducted from payments due owner-operators. Furthermore, owner-operators pay for insurance coverage, even if it is provided under policies procured by petitioner.

We grant reconsideration only to correct the factual errors. We still conclude that petitioner failed to prove that owner-operators involved in the deficiency assessments conduct independently established businesses, and we affirm our former opinion.

Reconsideration allowed; former opinion modified and adhered to as modified.


Summaries of

Combined Transport, Inc. v. Employment Division

Oregon Court of Appeals
Dec 16, 1986
82 Or. App. 127 (Or. Ct. App. 1986)
Case details for

Combined Transport, Inc. v. Employment Division

Case Details

Full title:In the Matter of the Deficiency Assessment of Combined Transport, Inc.…

Court:Oregon Court of Appeals

Date published: Dec 16, 1986

Citations

82 Or. App. 127 (Or. Ct. App. 1986)
727 P.2d 979

Citing Cases

Employment Div. v. NW Contract Carriers

Employment Division appeals a referee's order holding that services performed by owner-operators who lease…

Combined Transport, Inc. v. Employment Division

Argued and submitted February 7, 1986Affirmed September 3, 1986 Reconsideration allowed November 12, 1986 See…