From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Collins v. Pearson

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Hillsborough
Dec 6, 1910
78 A. 495 (N.H. 1910)

Opinion

Decided December 6, 1910.

A writ of mandamus is not issued if an order requiring the defendant to comply with the prayer of the petition would be wholly nugatory.

PETITION for mandamus. Trial by the court. Facts found, and case transferred from the May term, 1910, of the superior court, by Wallace, C.J.

Stephen L. Hallinan, for the plaintiff.

Edwin G. Eastman, attorney-general, for the defendant.


In the petition filed in this proceeding, the plaintiff requested that a writ of mandamus be issued against the defendant compelling him to print the plaintiff's name on the official ballots to be used at the primary election to be held September 6, 1910, as a candidate for the republican nomination for senator in the twentieth senatorial district. In the superior court the petition was dismissed, and the plaintiff excepted.

Since the proceeding was instituted the primary election of September 6 and the general election of November 8, 1910, have been held. An order made at this time requiring the defendant to comply with the prayer of the petitioner would be wholly nugatory, and the issuance of the writ an idle and useless ceremony. Under such circumstances the court will not grant a mandamus, even though the plaintiff would otherwise be entitled. Mitchell v. Boardman, 79 Me. 469; Spiritual etc. Society v. Randolph, 58 Vt. 192; 26 Cyc. 156. There is, therefore, no occasion for considering whether the plaintiff, upon the facts alleged in the petition, would be legally entitled to have his name placed on the ballot. The order is, exception overruled.

Petition dismissed.

All concurred.


Summaries of

Collins v. Pearson

Supreme Court of New Hampshire Hillsborough
Dec 6, 1910
78 A. 495 (N.H. 1910)
Case details for

Collins v. Pearson

Case Details

Full title:COLLINS v. PEARSON

Court:Supreme Court of New Hampshire Hillsborough

Date published: Dec 6, 1910

Citations

78 A. 495 (N.H. 1910)
78 A. 495

Citing Cases

Wilkes v. Jackson

O'Brien v. Fuller, 93 N.H. 221. Prior decisions have assumed, although not expressly decided, that there…

Atwood v. Berry

The original petition should have been dismissed upon the event of the town meeting antecedent to any order…