From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Collins v. Garvey

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Oct 9, 1917
171 P. 330 (Okla. 1917)

Opinion

No. 9373

Opinion Filed October 9, 1917. Rehearing Denied October 30, 1917.

(Syllabus.)

Appeal and Error — Transcript of Record — Case-Made.

Where the only errors alleged are in overruling the motion for a new trial, and in not rendering judgment for plaintiff in error on pleadings, this court will not consider same upon a transcript of the record and in the absence of a case-made.

Error from District Court, Woodward County; J.C. Robberts, Judge.

Action between Luke B. Collins and another and John Garvey and another. Judgment for the latter, and the former bring error. Dismissed.

Swindall Wybrant, for plaintiffs in error.

D.P. Marum and Embry, Crockett Johnson, for defendants in error.


The only assignments alleged in the petition in error are that the court erred in overruling the motion for a new trial, and that the court erred in not rendering judgment for plaintiff in error on the pleadings. The appeal was taken by transcript, and there has been no case-made or bill of exceptions filed. Defendant in error has filed motion to dismiss the appeal. Under the rule announced by this court the case of Miller v. Markley, 49 Okla. 177, 152 P. 345, and authorities there cited, the motion must be sustained. The appeal is therefore dismissed.


Summaries of

Collins v. Garvey

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Oct 9, 1917
171 P. 330 (Okla. 1917)
Case details for

Collins v. Garvey

Case Details

Full title:COLLINS et al. v. GARVEY

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Oct 9, 1917

Citations

171 P. 330 (Okla. 1917)
171 P. 330

Citing Cases

Williams v. Kelly

A motion for new trial, and the action of the court in overruling the same, being no part of the record,…

Shinn v. Hoopes

An examination of the trancript fails to disclose any demurrer to the defendants' answers or any order of the…