City of Seguin v. Berman

3 Citing cases

  1. Crow v. City of Corpus Christi

    146 Tex. 558 (Tex. 1948)   Cited 49 times
    Holding city ordinance requiring payment of illegal cab operator's license fee under threat of forfeiting the right to do business constituted payment under duress or business compulsion as a matter of law

    The Court of Civil Appeals did not err in holding that petitioner did not pay the taxes and fees under duress. Such payment was voluntary on their part. City of Seguin v. Berman, 205 S.W. 990; Mooers v. Hunter, 67 S.W.2d 860; Galveston Co. v. Gorham, 49 Tex. 279; City of Houston v. Feizer, 76 Tex. 365, 13 S.W. 266. (In the Texas Reports this name is spelled Feeser.) MR. JUSTICE TAYLOR delivered the opinion of the Court.

  2. Robbins v. Limestone County

    114 Tex. 345 (Tex. 1925)   Cited 85 times
    Holding that county and road districts can sue the state highway commission on the ground of the invalidity of statutes

    Road District No. 15 is authorized (1) to sue the tax collector, and (2) to sue the State Highway Commission and its officers, in respect of the matters here involved. Rev. Stats., art. 637; Baker v. Panola County, 30 Tex. 87, 93; Seguin v. Berman, 205 S.W. 990; Wilson v. Reeves County, 256 S.W. 346; Castleman v. Rainey, 211 S.W. 630. Not a suit against State: Cyc., 917; 25 R.C.L., 414, par. 51; Lossing v. Hughes, 244 S.W. 556; Neal v. Scott, 247 S.W. 689; Austin v. Cemetery Assn., 87 Tex. 330; Kaufman v. Lee, U.S., 27 L.Ed., 171; Terrill v. Middleton, 187 S.W. 367; Same case, 108 Tex. 14; Stanley v. Schwalby, 85 Tex. 348; Connerly v. Daughters of Republic, 106 Tex. 80. The whole chapter 75, Acts, 38th Leg., is void, because it is duplicitous and contrary to art. 3, Sec. 35 of the Constitution of the state, in regulating the operation of motor vehicles on the public roads, and also in regulating the construction and maintenance of public roads.

  3. City of San Antonio v. Grayburg Oil Co.

    259 S.W. 985 (Tex. Civ. App. 1924)   Cited 7 times
    In City of San Antonio v. Grayburg (Tex.Civ.App.) 259 S.W. 985, 986, the court says: "The chief inquiry, then, is, Was the payment of the taxes voluntary or involuntary? The trial court found that the payment was involuntary and was made under protest, and we have concluded that the evidence warranted that finding. It was shown that, when the company sought to pay its taxes to the city for the year in question, it sent its check to the collector for the amount of the taxes assessed against it, less the item in question.

    The facts stated warranted the finding of the court that the taxes were paid involuntarily and under protest, and, the tax having been improperly assessed, the taxpayer is entitled to recover the amount thus paid. Galveston City Co. v. Galveston, 56 Tex. 486; City of Seguin v. Berman (Tex.Civ.App.) 205 S.W. 990, and authorities there cited. This conclusion disposes of appellant's first proposition and the assignment on which it is predicated.