From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Carter v. Owens-Illinois, Inc.

Supreme Court of Arkansas (Division II)
May 31, 1977
551 S.W.2d 209 (Ark. 1977)

Summary

In Carter v. Owens-Illinois, Inc., 261 Ark. 728, 551 S.W.2d 209 (1977), we interpreted that statute as applying only to prohibit identical actions from proceeding between identical parties in two courts of this state.

Summary of this case from National Bank of Commerce v. Dow Chem. Co.

Opinion

No. 77-8

Opinion delivered May 31, 1977

1. COURTS — FEDERAL STATE COURTS — CONCURRENT JURISDICTION EXERCISED SIMULTANEOUSLY. — Federal district courts and state courts are separate jurisdictions, and identical cases between the same parties can be pending in each court at the same time. 2. COURTS — IDENTICAL CASES PENDING IN SEPARATE JURISDICTIONS — JUDGMENT IN CASE TRIED FIRST BINDING ON PARTIES. — When identical cases between the same parties are pending in federal and state courts having jurisdiction or in courts in different states, the first forum to dispose of the case by trial enters judgment that is binding on the parties. 3. CIVIL PROCEDURE — IDENTICAL CASES IN DIFFERENT COUNTIES, STATUTORY PROHIBITION AGAINST — VENUE. — Arkansas law prohibits identical cases between the same parties from proceeding in different Arkansas counties, but this is a matter of venue and not jurisdiction. [Ark. Stat. Ann. 27-1115 (Repl. 1962).]

Appeal from Sebastian Circuit Court, Fort Smith District, John G. Holland, Judge; affirmed.

Robert S. Blatt, for appellant.

Bethell, Callaway Robertson, for appellee.


The only issue in this case is, can a federal district court and a state circuit court have jurisdiction at the same time of the same subject matter involving identical parties? The trial court ruled that they could and we agree.

The appellant, Joe H. Carter, sued the appellee, Owens, Illinois, Inc., in the Federal District Court at Fort Smith over a vehicle accident that occurred in Fort Smith. Owens filed an answer to the lawsuit and later a counter-claim for property damages. After the lawsuit was filed in federal court, Owens filed a lawsuit in Sebastian Circuit Court against Joe Carter over the same accident. Therefore, we have identical claims involving the same parties concerning the same subject matter pending in two courts at the same time.

Carter asked the federal court to enjoin the state court from hearing the lawsuit. The federal court denied the request. See Carter v. Owens-Illinois, Inc., 420 F. Supp. 927 (1976). Apparently the case is still pending in federal court.

Carter next filed a motion for summary judgment in the state court asking the case to be dismissed because the federal case was filed first, involved the same matter, between the same parties. The trial court denied the motion, the case was tried before a jury, judgment was entered for Owens and denied Carter. Carter raises only the one issue of jurisdiction on appeal.

Federal district courts and state courts are separate jurisdictions. Identical cases between the same parties can be pending in each court at the same time. See Baker, et al v. Harrison, Judge, 247 Ark. 377, 445 S.W.2d 498 (1969). It is the same situation as if identical cases between the same parties were ending in different states. In such a situation the first forum to dispose of the case by trial enters a judgment that is binding on the parties.

Arkansas law does prohibit identical cases between the same parties from proceeding in different Arkansas counties. However, this is a matter of venue and not jurisdiction. See Ark. Stats. Ann. 27-1115 (Repl. 1962).

Affirmed.

We agree: HARRIS, C.J., and FOGLEMAN and BYRD, JJ.


Summaries of

Carter v. Owens-Illinois, Inc.

Supreme Court of Arkansas (Division II)
May 31, 1977
551 S.W.2d 209 (Ark. 1977)

In Carter v. Owens-Illinois, Inc., 261 Ark. 728, 551 S.W.2d 209 (1977), we interpreted that statute as applying only to prohibit identical actions from proceeding between identical parties in two courts of this state.

Summary of this case from National Bank of Commerce v. Dow Chem. Co.
Case details for

Carter v. Owens-Illinois, Inc.

Case Details

Full title:Joe H. CARTER v. OWENS-ILLINOIS, Inc

Court:Supreme Court of Arkansas (Division II)

Date published: May 31, 1977

Citations

551 S.W.2d 209 (Ark. 1977)
551 S.W.2d 209

Citing Cases

National Bank of Comm. v. the Dow Chem. Co.

[4, 5] We have also recognized that identical cases between the same parties may be pending in a federal…

Baptist Health v. Murphy

          It is well settled that federal district courts and state courts are separate jurisdictions, and…