From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Carter v. Bishop

Supreme Court of Georgia
Jun 9, 1952
71 S.E.2d 216 (Ga. 1952)

Opinion

17869.

ARGUED MAY 12, 1952.

DECIDED JUNE 9, 1952.

Action for damages; constitutional question. Before Judge H. E. Nichols, presiding. Whitfield Superior Court. October 3, 1951.

Pittman, Hodge Kinney and R. Carter Pittman, for plaintiffs in error.

Mitchell Mitchell and Keener Keener, contra.


The exception here is to a judgment overruling an amended motion for a new trial in a suit for damages. It is contended that the Supreme Court has jurisdiction, however, because the constitutionality of certain rules promulgated by the Public Service Commission is drawn in question in the amended grounds by excepting to the charge applying those rules. The Constitution confers upon the Supreme Court jurisdiction to construe the Constitution and to determine the constitutionality of a State law. Constitution of 1945, art. 4, sec. 2, par. 4 (Code, Ann., § 2-3704). The various clauses of the Constitution here invoked are plain and unambiguous, hence require no construction but simply application which the Court of Appeals has jurisdiction to make. Constitution of 1945, art. 4, sec. 2, par. 8 (Code, Ann., § 2-3704); Atlanta-Asheville Motor Express v. Superior Garment Mfg. Co., 206 Ga. 882 ( 59 S.E.2d 382), and citations. Furthermore, the rules here assailed are not "State laws" in contemplation of the Constitution. Maner v. Dykes, 183 Ga. 118 ( 187 S.E. 699). The Court of Appeals has jurisdiction of this writ of error and it will, accordingly, be transferred to that court.

Transferred to the Court of Appeals. All the Justices concur, except Atkinson, P.J., not participating.

No. 17869. ARGUED MAY 12, 1952 — DECIDED JUNE 9, 1952.


Summaries of

Carter v. Bishop

Supreme Court of Georgia
Jun 9, 1952
71 S.E.2d 216 (Ga. 1952)
Case details for

Carter v. Bishop

Case Details

Full title:CARTER et al. v. BISHOP, by next friend

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: Jun 9, 1952

Citations

71 S.E.2d 216 (Ga. 1952)
71 S.E.2d 216

Citing Cases

Shelton v. Housing Authority of the City of Atlanta

1. The question calling for a "construction" of the Georgia Constitution was held in Bowers v. Fulton County,…

Porter v. Jack's Cookie Company, Inc.

However, here the question is: Where an employee is expressly forbidden to work during certain hours but does…