From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Carson v. Carson

Supreme Court of Minnesota
Oct 31, 1930
232 N.W. 788 (Minn. 1930)

Opinion

No. 28,084.

October 31, 1930.

Nonappealable order.

An order directing the representative of an estate to pay a certain amount of money as fees to an attorney is not appealable.

Plaintiff, one of the heirs at law of Mary J. Carson, deceased, appealed from an order of the district court for Renville county, Baker, J. granting the motion of defendant J.I. Carson as administrator of the estate to dismiss plaintiff's appeal to the district court from an order of the probate court, Lindquist, J. allowing the claim of defendant Frank Hopkins for attorney's fees against the estate. Affirmed.

O.A. Allen and L.J. Lauerman, for appellant.

A.C. Dolliff, for respondents.



The representative of the estate of Mary J. Carson, deceased, filed his final account in probate court. It included an item of $3,132.80 as attorney's fees. Upon the day for hearing on said account an objection was made to this item, and a trial thereon was had. From an order directing the representative to pay the item the objecting heir appealed to the district court, which granted a motion to dismiss the appeal on the ground that the order was not appealable. The appeal to this court followed.

The order did not allow a claim against the estate. Nor did it allow or disallow the final account. The order related only to the one item in the account and directed its payment. It was not appealable. G. S. 1923 (2 Mason, 1927) § 8983; State ex rel. Krey v. Probate Court, 51 Minn. 241, 53 N.W. 463; Smith v. Pence, 62 Minn. 321, 64 N.W. 822; State ex rel. Neuman v. Probate Court, 76 Minn. 132, 78 N.W. 1039. Such an order is reviewable by certiorari. 1 Dunnell, Minn. Dig. (2 ed.) § 1394.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Carson v. Carson

Supreme Court of Minnesota
Oct 31, 1930
232 N.W. 788 (Minn. 1930)
Case details for

Carson v. Carson

Case Details

Full title:H. J. CARSON v. J. I. CARSON AND ANOTHER

Court:Supreme Court of Minnesota

Date published: Oct 31, 1930

Citations

232 N.W. 788 (Minn. 1930)
232 N.W. 788