From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Campion v. Director

Court of Appeals of Maryland
Feb 8, 1965
206 A.2d 703 (Md. 1965)

Opinion

[App. No. 76, September Term, 1964.]

Decided February 8, 1965.

DEFECTIVE DELINQUENTS — Redetermination Of Status As — Non-Jury Case — Evidence Held Legally Sufficient To Have Taken Case To Jury, Had There Been One, And Finding Of Defective Delinquency Amply Supported By Evidence. p. 641

Decided February 8, 1965.

From a redetermination that he was still a defective delinquent, David Lee Champion applied for leave to appeal.

Application denied.

Before the entire Court.


Upon this application for leave to appeal from a redetermination that applicant was still a defective delinquent, the applicant contends that: (a) the verdict was against the evidence; (b) there was no evidence legally sufficient for a finding by the court that applicant was a defective delinquent; (c) that the only testimony produced by the State was that of Dr. Boslow, and that applicant's psychiatrist refuted this testimony; and (d) the verdict of the court was against the weight of the evidence.

It will be noted that all of the contentions relate to the sufficiency and weight of the evidence. The hearing was held by a judge, sitting without a jury. A reading of the record shows that there clearly was legally sufficient evidence to have taken the case to the jury had there been one; and, with reference to the weight afforded the evidence by the court, his finding is amply supported by the evidence. Cf. Creswell v. Director, 234 Md. 620.

Application denied.


Summaries of

Campion v. Director

Court of Appeals of Maryland
Feb 8, 1965
206 A.2d 703 (Md. 1965)
Case details for

Campion v. Director

Case Details

Full title:CAMPION v . DIRECTOR OF PATUXENT INSTITUTION

Court:Court of Appeals of Maryland

Date published: Feb 8, 1965

Citations

206 A.2d 703 (Md. 1965)
206 A.2d 703

Citing Cases

Johns v. Director

We have not always made clear that the "clearly erroneous" standard provided for in Maryland Rule 886 a…