Civil Action No. 09-85J.
October 15, 2010
CATHY BISSOON, Magistrate Judge
Defendants have filed a Motion for Summary Judgment regarding 326 of the opt-in Plaintiffs ("opt-ins"). See Defs.' Am. Mot. for Summ. J. (Doc. 408). For the reasons stated in the Order filed today in Taylor v. Pittsburgh Mercy Health System, Inc., Civil Action No. 09-377 (W.D. Pa.), which is incorporated by reference herein, Defendants' Amended Motion for Summary Judgment ( Doc. 408) is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART. Summary judgment is denied regarding the 96 opt-ins who have submitted affidavits in opposition to Defendants' Motion:
Although Defendants purport to seek summary judgment regarding 339 opt-ins, Plaintiffs' and the Court's calculations place the number at 326. Defendants' proposed order (Doc. 408-4) contains not five duplicate names, as indicated in Defendants' Reply Brief (Doc. 414), but eighteen. At the risk of stating the obvious, movants should know the number of plaintiffs regarding which they seek summary judgment. This problem easily could have been avoided by entering the opt-ins' names into a computerized spreadsheet and sorting them, as the Court had to do to resolve the discrepancy.
See Doc. 207 in Civil Action No. 09-377.
Ando, Barbara Holfelder, Lorraine M. Parsons, Linda A. Badamo, JoAnn Bernice Hutchinson, Carol Philips, Marie Barnett, Bernita Gloria Jackson, Steven J. Pollard, Louise Berry, Cathy Jackson, Tracy Relihan, Timothy Billick, Darlene Jones, Tondaliere W. Ricketts, Timothy J. Binder, Leslie Kania, Rita M. Riley, Diane Blasko, Joyce Kelly, Mara Robinson, George Bolz, Linda Kirkwood, Clea Romaniello, Judith Taylor Bonner, Jazzmin Kolonay, Barbara A. Sanders, Marilyn Boyd, Michele Krebs, Luanne Mary Saylor, Terri Lea Buzzell, Kimberly Kunselman, Tawnya Schwartz, Carol Calcek, Nadine Lanasa, Susan Sciubba, Dada S. Campbell, Joyce Lang, Diana J. Seiling, Darlene Cole, Lynn M. Large, Laurie J. Semian, Thomas J. Cook, Regina Len, Carolyn L. Silberman, Linda Joan Cordero, Margaret Lind, Kathleen Silvagni, Susan Crock, Tamara Long, Terra Slifkey, Mellisa M. DeFrancesco, RuthAnn Mahone, Rosemarie Smith, Jo-Ann Denucci, Brandon Malloy, Joyce Speicher, Renada Donaldson, Barbara J. Marsico, Mary Lynn Spencer, Galen Doughtery, Rosalie A. Martin, Charles R. Spohn, Marilyn Dyer, Earlene R. Marziale, Renee M. Springel, Jaime Dyer, Judith A. Maxin, Michelle Diana Stang, Christina Evasovich, Denise Mazon, Audrey J. Streiner, Michele A. Fair, Susan McGee, Carla Switalski, Elizabeth A. Field, Najet K. Mead, Maria Lynn Trautman, Arleen Fowler, Janet M. Mermon, Amy Trew, Neil Gorny, Francis Morris, Shirley Trussell, Georgia Ann Hamilton, Kenneth R. Mostyn, Stacy Tyler, Tanya M. Harr, Sandra Myers, Irma J. Weigand, Patricia J. Harris, Jeanne E. Neiman, Reva L. Wells, Keir M. Henry, Lance Oddis, Kelly Wilson, Susan E. Summary judgment is granted regarding the 230 opt-ins who did not file affidavits: Adamson-Deulin, Victoria Artim, Sheila Bertok, Dorothy E. Aiken, Jane Baird, Gary Beyers, Stephen Aker, Patricia L. Baluch, Marjorie Birmingham, Maureen Alfred, Sam Bandalo, John Black, Jannifer Altman, Penny Barlow, Diane G. Borcik, Shelly Amrhein, David B. Bartoli, Amy Brettschneider, Lynda Anderson, Kevin H. Baselj, John Bretz Cresta, Jennifer Andzelik, Norma B. Bauer, Marie J. Brewton, Marlena Antonucci, Stacey Lynn Bell, Sheila Brink, Rita Appelt, Chad E. Bercik, Marcia L Britton, Violet Brooks, Mona Gladis, Mary Beth Lewis, Carrol L. Brophy, Charlotte Glenn, John F. Lis, Darrell G. Brown, Alexandria Gonot, Douglas Lista, Lauren Brunner, Bonnie Gorman, Marlene M. Livingston, Lorraine Bubonovich, Brittany Gratton, Patricia A. Lorson, Christine Burns McFadden, Donna Gray, Andrea Lovelace, William Buszinski, Dawn Greenawalt, Barbara Lundberg, Mary Bynoe, Lisa Gretz, Susan W Mack, Barbara Campbell, Steven Griffin, Elaine Madden, Beverly Carr, Deborah Haff, George B. Magdic, Rosemary Cavlovich, Doris J. Hamrock, Mary F. Maletta, Michaelle Ceberio-Lanese, Mary Hanna, Mark Malinowski, Carleen A. Cecere, Camille B. Hartle, Tara Manley, Tamara Chapman, Dreama Hartz, David Marchionna, Jane Clark, Sueanne Hastings, Leslie Martone, Lucianna Conover, Noelle C. Healey, Diana Matthews, Judith Conti, Theresa C. Henze, Heather Jean Mayger, Carolyn Conwell, Jennifer R. Hofius, Cynthia Kay Mayher, Debra Stock Costa, Theresa Homer, Marcia C. Mazza, Kelly Cox, Mary Hopkins, Kimberly Duke McCalla, Evelyn J. Damer, Sharon A. Hubert, Joshua McCracken, Ashleen Davenport, Aleica Hudson, Samantha Lee McGee, Alice L Dean, Shanda Jack, Lynn A. McKinnis, Susan Carole Deiley, Mary Sue Jendrasik, Jennifer L. Metz, Erin Delucia, Susan Johnson, Amber Michalski, Hyacinth P. Dephillips, Laura Johnston, Don Milchick, Mary E. Derdock, Antoinette L. Jones, Tricia Ann Mitch-Resignalo, Ann E. DiFrancesco, Rita Jones-Harshaw, Annie M. Montgomery, Dana Yvette D'Orazio, Linda Lee Kaib, Cynthia Moye, Bertha Lee Druga, Christine Karabetsos, Kimberly Murray, William J. Eger, Nancy L. Karscig, Mary Myrgo, Candace J. Eisner, Gertrude Ellen Kasey, Nancy Nauer, Kevin L. Eleam, Marlon Kennedy, Judi A. Nixon, Jill Emanuelson, Kathleen Khoujmal, Christine Noel, Aimee L. Fannie, Nancy Kilinski, Bethany Nutter, Margaret A. Finnerty-Folan, Maureen King, Ann Patricia O'Connor, Jennifer F. Fiumara, Carla Rose King, Dolores O'Donnell, Colleen S. Flohr, Jareen Margaret King, Mary Colleen O'Hare, Diane J. Fox, Patricia Klonowski, Carolyn Olabopo, Bola F Franciscus, Margaret Knights, Veronica Lois Oross, Lisa A. Fuga, Lynn Koziarski, Jeffrey S. Owens, George Fuller III, Ralph Wesley Kubatka, Mia Owens, Lesley Susan Fussenegger, Diane K. Kysor, Anita Page, Margaret Ann Garcia, Robin Layhew, Richard Peelor, Martha C. Gasparik, Cynthia Leonard, Kathleen A. Perry, Carole Ann Gemeinhart, Richard R. Lester, Denise Pivirotto, Veronica Prince, Janet Shuck, Dean Valenti, Katherine Rao, Joanne G. Smith, Ann R. Vandevort, Suzanne Reimond, Barbara A. Smith, Sharon L. Vensak, Judith L. Rittle Jr, Charles H. Sofranko, Payge Craven Wachter, Janet Kay Roberts, Kimberly Spooner, Suzanne M. Wagner, Karen Eileen Robinson, Pamela L. Spore, Bridget Walker, Steven Rocco, Darla J. Spurbeck, Cynthia Webb, Tiffany Roolf, Jean A. Starr, Allan Weinroth, Kathleen Rudzinski, Catherine Stephenson, Amber L. Wesche, Jacqueline A. Ruffalo, Patricia A. Strachan, Tracy Dawn Whelan, Suzanne Marie Rush, Ashley Suber, Sherry A. Whitaker, Shanda N. Russen, Jennifer Sukenik, Catherine White, MaryAnnWhite, Sair, Deborah L. Suter, Charlene A. Tracey Huguley Salafranca, Jennifer L. Swierczewski, Kristin Jean Wiggins, Britt Samuels, Nicole Tallon, Patrick Williams, Constance E. Scanga, Thomas P. Taylor, Patricia Wisilosky, Lisa Schaaf, Donna Thomas, Theresa Young, Laura Loretta Schaaf, Rachel Thompson, Regina Young, Michael R. Schmitt, Erin Travers-Barney, Bonnie Yuhaniak, Susan Schuster, Jill Tucker, Sandra J. Zembrzuski, Melanie Schwer, William Turner, Andrea Lee Summary judgment is granted regarding the FLSA and RICO claims asserted by these opt-ins. In addition, Plaintiffs' Motion ( Doc. 419) to strike Defendants' Reply Brief and Affirmations, or to sur-reply, is DENIED AS MOOT. IT IS SO ORDERED.
October 15, 2010