Opinion
No. 647 M.D. 2020
10-03-2022
BUTLER AREA SCHOOL DISTRICT; Alvin Vavro, in his official capacity as President of the Board of School Directors; Jennifer Cummings, in her official capacity as Vice President of the Board of School Directors; John Conrad, in his official capacity as a member of the Board of School Directors; Jennifer Daniels-Wells, in her official capacity as a member of the Board of School Directors; Bill Halle, in his official capacity as a member of the Board of School Directors; Thomas Harrison, in his official capacity as a member of the Board of School Directors; Alice Nunes, in her official capacity as a member of the Board of School Directors; Gary Shingleton, in his official capacity as a member of the Board of School Directors; Mary Waggoner, in her official capacity as a member of the Board of School Directors; Philip A. Melnick, Sr. and Chattle Melnick, husband and wife, as parents of three children within the Butler Area School District, as taxpayers within the Butler Area School District; and as voters within the Butler Area School District; Michael Carben and Julie Carben, husband and wife, as parents of two children within the Butler Area School District, as taxpayers within the Butler Area School District, and as voters within the Butler Area School District; Michele Curzi, as a parent of five children within the Butler Area School District, as a taxpayer within the Butler Area School District, and as a voter within the Butler Area School District; Laura Ice, as a parent of two children within the Butler Area School District, as a taxpayer within the Butler Area School District, and as a voter within the Butler Area School District; James Lindsay and Meredith Lindsay, husband and wife, as parents of one child within the Butler Area School District, as taxpayers within the Butler Area School District, and as voters within the Butler Area School District; and Brad D. Leslie, as a parent of a student-athlete within the Butler Area School District, as a taxpayer within the Butler Area School District, and as a voter within the Butler Area School District, Petitioners v. Dr. Rachel LEVINE, Secretary of the Pennsylvania Department of Health; Noe Ortega, acting Secretary of the Pennsylvania Department of Education; and The Honorable Thomas W. Wolf, Governor of Pennsylvania, Respondents
Withdrawn. Overruled.