From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Burke v. Gardenhire

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jun 25, 1957
313 P.2d 1099 (Okla. 1957)

Opinion

No. 37476.

June 25, 1957.

Appeal from the District Court of Sequoyah County; E.A. Summers, Judge.

Suit for damages alleged to have resulted from defendant's negligence in conducting certain aerial spraying operations. Judgment for plaintiffs and defendant appeals. Reversed and remanded for new trial.

Roy Frye, Sr., Roy Frye, Jr., Sallisaw, for plaintiff in error.

J. Fred Green, Fred D. Green, W.S. Agent, Sallisaw, for defendants in error.


This is an appeal from a judgment rendered upon a jury verdict, in the third successive case tried (November 30, 1955) against the defendant at the same term of court. The issues involved were the same as case No. 37,474, Burke v. McKenzie, Okla., 313 P.2d 1090.

Of the jurors empaneled to try the case, over defendant's objection that the jurors had sat in the previous cases wherein verdicts had been returned against defendant and so were no longer fair and impartial, it appeared that: five jurors had signed verdicts in both previous cases, while the other seven had signed a verdict in one of the other cases.

The decisive question in this appeal has been determined by our decision in No. 37,474, Burke v. McKenzie. The judgment accordingly is reversed and the case remanded with directions to grant a new trial.


Summaries of

Burke v. Gardenhire

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jun 25, 1957
313 P.2d 1099 (Okla. 1957)
Case details for

Burke v. Gardenhire

Case Details

Full title:E.J. BURKE, PLAINTIFF IN ERROR, v. TOM GARDENHIRE AND LULA GARDENHIRE…

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Jun 25, 1957

Citations

313 P.2d 1099 (Okla. 1957)
1957 OK 158