From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Buell v. Oil Well Supply Co.

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Oct 14, 1919
184 P. 572 (Okla. 1919)

Opinion

No. 10152

Opinion Filed October 14, 1919.

(Syllabus by the Court.)

Appeal and Error — Frivolous Appeal — Dismissal.

Where plaintiff sues upon a promissory note and defendant answers by unverified general denial, and, upon motion of plaintiff, judgment is rendered for plaintiff on the pleadings, an appeal, assigning the rendition of such judgment as error, without stating any defense to plaintiff's action, will be dismissed as frivolous.

Error from District Court, Creek County; Ernest B. Hughes, Judge.

Action by Oil Well Supply Company against J. Garfield Buell on promissory note. Judgment for plaintiff and defendant brings error. Dismissed.

John B. Meserve, for plaintiff in error.

J.B. Bartlett and Smith Walker, for defendant in error.


On motion to dismiss the appeal it appears defendant in error, Oil Well Supply Company, brought suit upon a promissory note against plaintiff in error, J. Garfield Buell. The petition was verified, a copy of the note attached as an exhibit and made a part of the petition. Defendant Buell by way of answer filed an unverified general denial. Upon motion of plaintiff, judgment was rendered on the pleadings, from which judgment this appeal was prosecuted. Under the provisions of section 4759, Rev. Laws 1910, the allegations of the petition must be taken as true since the answer, by way of general denial, was not verified, and on authority of Bilby v. Natl. Reserve Bank, 53 Okla. 566, 157 P. 1198, and Bilby v. Cochran, 47 Okla. 545, 149 P. 143, the appeal will be dismissed as frivolous.

It is so ordered.


Summaries of

Buell v. Oil Well Supply Co.

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Oct 14, 1919
184 P. 572 (Okla. 1919)
Case details for

Buell v. Oil Well Supply Co.

Case Details

Full title:BUELL v. OIL WELL SUPPLY CO

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Oct 14, 1919

Citations

184 P. 572 (Okla. 1919)
184 P. 572

Citing Cases

Edge v. Security Building Loan Ass'n

This court has repeatedly held that an unverified general denial to a petition on a promissory note, where…

Crabtree v. American Nat. Bank

"Where plaintiff sues upon a promissory note and defendant answers by an unverified general denial, and upon…