Summary
In Brown v. Lee, 167 Va. 284, 189 S.E. 339, the collision occurred at an intersection where the land was fairly level, and under the evidence it seemed incredible that the plaintiff could have failed to see defendant's vehicle when it was about seventy-five feet from the intersection.
Summary of this case from Leo Butler Co. v. WilbunOpinion
January 14, 1937
Present, All the Justices
1. AUTOMOBILES — Right of Way — Section 2154(123) of the Code of 1936. — Section 2154(123) of the Code of 1936, providing that when two vehicles approach an intersection at approximately the same time, the driver of the vehicle on the left must ordinarily yield the right of way to the vehicle on his right, does not authorize blind driving.
2. AUTOMOBILES — Collision between Automobile and Truck — Contributory Negligence — Case at Bar. — In the instant case, an action to recover for injuries sustained when plaintiff, driving a truck in an easterly direction, collided with a car being driven in a southerly direction by the individual defendant, plaintiff testified that he never saw the car until he hit it, although the land was fairly level, the truck could be seen for at least three hundred feet, and plaintiff could have seen the car when it was about seventy-five feet from the intersection.
Held: That plaintiff's negligence contributed to his injury as a proximate cause and he could not recover.
Error to a judgment of the Circuit Court of the city of Williamsburg and James City county. Hon. Frank Armistead, judge presiding. Judgment for plaintiff. Defendants assign error.
Reversed.
The opinion states the case.
James H. Price and Ashton Dovell, for the plaintiffs in error.
No appearance for the defendant in error.
The plaintiff, Frank J. Lee, has obtained a judgment in an action for injuries suffered in an automobile accident. From that judgment comes this appeal.
On May 4, 1934, Lee, accompanied by a colored man named Parker, drove a light unloaded Ford truck along what is known in the record as Five Forks road in an easterly direction towards Williamsburg. That road which is improved and paved crosses a dirt road known as the Old County road, practically at right angles. Down this dirt road southbound driving a Chevrolet coupe came A. B. Brown, an employee of the Oliver Farm Equipment Sales Company, on the business of his master. It was at the intersection of these roads that this collision occurred. The cars came to rest about twenty feet away.
If Lee was negligent and if his negligence contributed to his hurt plainly he cannot recover.
The land is fairly level, and from the crossing the truck could be seen for at least three hundred feet, its driver could have seen the coupe when it was about seventy-five feet from the intersection, beyond which his view was obstructed by woodland.
Incredible as it may seem, he tells us that he never saw this coupe until he struck it, and for this he offers no excuse.
It is true that when two vehicles approach an intersection at approximately the same time, the driver of the vehicle on the left must ordinarily yield the right of way to the vehicle on his right (Code, section 2154(123)), but this does not authorize blind driving.
The negligence of Lee is too plain for argument. As a proximate cause it contributed to his injury and he cannot recover.
Reversed.