From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

BIF a Unit of General Signal Corp. v. Des Roches

Supreme Court of Rhode Island
Sep 22, 1976
117 R.I. 914 (R.I. 1976)

Summary

declining to read into § 28-33-18 the right to take a deduction or credit for retirement benefits paid to an employee receiving workers' compensation

Summary of this case from Cole v. Davol, Inc.

Opinion

APPEAL No. 74-138.

September 22, 1976.

The petition for reargument is denied.

E. Howland Bowen, for petitioner.

Richard A. Skolnik, for respondent.


After the filing of our opinion the employer petitioned for permission to reargue the case. It urges in support of that petition that (1) we erroneously attributed to it an admission that the employee was partially "incapacitated" whereas it contends that it admitted only that he was partially "disabled"; and (2) it is unable to determine from our opinion whether the compensation benefits due the employee for partial incapacity shall be reduced by an amount equal to the pension benefits it is paying him.

Neither reason furnishes a sufficient warrant for granting reargument. The first is insufficient because the result in the case would in no way be affected had we not attributed to it the admission it finds offensive.

The second reason advanced for reargument is no more persuasive. We now make explicit what we thought was implicit in our opinion: retirement benefits paid to the employee shall not be deducted from, credited against, or used as an offset to workmen's compensation benefits due him. In our judgment neither § 28-33-18 nor § 28-33-21 of G.L. 1956 (1968 Reenactment) can fairly be read to permit a contrary conclusion.


Summaries of

BIF a Unit of General Signal Corp. v. Des Roches

Supreme Court of Rhode Island
Sep 22, 1976
117 R.I. 914 (R.I. 1976)

declining to read into § 28-33-18 the right to take a deduction or credit for retirement benefits paid to an employee receiving workers' compensation

Summary of this case from Cole v. Davol, Inc.
Case details for

BIF a Unit of General Signal Corp. v. Des Roches

Case Details

Full title:BIF A UNIT OF GENERAL SIGNAL CORPORATION et al. v. JOSEPH F. DES ROCHES

Court:Supreme Court of Rhode Island

Date published: Sep 22, 1976

Citations

117 R.I. 914 (R.I. 1976)

Citing Cases

Cole v. Davol, Inc.

There is no comparable provision in the Rhode Island WCA, and we reject Davol's attempt to redraft § 28-33-18…