Berk v. Rothman Inst. Orthopedic Found.

Full title: HOWARD R. BERK v. ROTHMAN INSTITUTE ORTHOPEDIC FOUNDATION, RECONSTRUCTIVE…

Court: United States District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania

Date published: Mar 28, 2024

Civil Action 23-1437 (E.D. Pa. Mar. 28, 2024)

Opinion

Civil Action 23-1437

03-28-2024

HOWARD R. BERK v. ROTHMAN INSTITUTE ORTHOPEDIC FOUNDATION, RECONSTRUCTIVE ORTHOPEDIC ASSOCIATES II, LLC, ROTHMAN ORTHO PA HOLDCO I., P.C., RECONSTRUCTIVE ORTHOPEDIC ASSOCIATES II, LLC, ROTHMAN ORTHO PA HOLDCO III, P.C., ROTHMAN ORTHO PA HOLDCO IV, P.C., ROTHMAN ORTHOPEDIC SPECIALTY HOSPITAL, L.P., ROTHMAN ORTHOPEDIC SPECIALTY HOSPITAL, LLC, ALEXANDER R. VACCARO, MD, DAVID I. PEDOWITZ, MD, STEVEN M. RAIKIN, MD

MURPHY J.

ORDER

MURPHY J.

AND NOW, this 28^th day of March 2024, upon considering defendants' amended motions to dismiss (DI 24, 25), plaintiff's oppositions (DI 33, 34), defendants' replies (DI 35, 36), plaintiff's motion for leave to file sur-reply (DI 37), defendants' opposition (DI 39), plaintiff's reply (DI 40), and for reasons in the accompanying memorandum, it is ORDERED:

1. Defendants' amended motions to dismiss (DI 24, 25) are GRANTED.

2. Plaintiff's motion for leave to file sur-reply (DI 37) is GRANTED; the attached sur-reply was duly considered as was the sur-sur-reply.

3. We dismiss the case with prejudice and the Clerk of Court shall mark this matter closed.