From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Benat v. Mutual Benefit Health Accident Ass'n

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Jan 4, 1961
402 Pa. 208 (Pa. 1961)

Summary

holding that an insurer's acceptance of new premiums created a new contract, where the insurer could terminate a quarterly policy by not accepting such premiums

Summary of this case from Hanover Ins. Co. v. Ryan

Opinion

November 22, 1960.

January 4, 1961.

Before JONES, C. J., BELL, MUSMANNO, JONES, COHEN, BOK and EAGEN, JJ.

Appeal, No. 360, Jan. T., 1960, from decree of Superior Court, Oct. T., 1959, No. 433, affirming decree of Municipal Court of Philadelphia County, Jan. T., 1958, No. 2702, in equity, in case of William F. Benat v. Mutual Benefit Health Accident Association. Order affirmed.

Same case in Superior Court: 191 Pa. Super. 547.

Equity. Before GILBERT, J.

Opinion filed finding for defendant; exceptions to opinion dismissed and decree entered dismissing complaint. Plaintiff appealed to Superior Court which affirmed the decree. Appeal to Supreme Court allowed.

Robert H. Malis, with him Malis, Malis Malis, for appellant.

Walter B. Gibbons, for appellee.


The order of the Superior Court is affirmed at appellant's costs on the opinion of Judge WRIGHT, reported at 191 Pa. Super. 547.

Mr. Justice BELL and Mr. Justice MUSMANNO dissent.


Summaries of

Benat v. Mutual Benefit Health Accident Ass'n

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Jan 4, 1961
402 Pa. 208 (Pa. 1961)

holding that an insurer's acceptance of new premiums created a new contract, where the insurer could terminate a quarterly policy by not accepting such premiums

Summary of this case from Hanover Ins. Co. v. Ryan
Case details for

Benat v. Mutual Benefit Health Accident Ass'n

Case Details

Full title:Benat, Appellant, v. Mutual Benefit Health Accident Association

Court:Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Date published: Jan 4, 1961

Citations

402 Pa. 208 (Pa. 1961)
166 A.2d 880

Citing Cases

Yoder v. American Travellers Life Insurance

Thus, Golden Rule, both because of the context of its holding, as well as its narrowness, is unhelpful to…

Snyder Bros., Inc. v. Pa. Pub. Util. Comm'n

"); O'Rourke v. Commonwealth , 566 Pa. 161, 778 A.2d 1194, 1201 (2001) (same); accord HellerBenat v. Mutual…