Opinion
No. 42554.
February 18, 1963.
1. Workmen's compensation — Commission's findings — heart attack — disability not work connected.
Finding of Workmen's Compensation Commission that permanent total disability sustained by employee, who suffered a heart attack, was not work connected was supported by substantial evidence.
Headnote as approved by McGehee, C.J.
APPEAL from the Circuit Court of Clay County; JOHN D. GREENE, Judge.
Daniel, Coker Horton, Jackson, for appellants.
I. The order of the Workmen's Compensation Commission was based upon substantial evidence; and the Commission being the fact finder, such order should have been affirmed. Capitol Broadcasting Co. v. Wilkerson, 240 Miss. 64, 126 So.2d 242; Cole v. Superior Coach Corp., 234 Miss. 287, 106 So.2d 71; Cudahy Packing Co. v. Ward, 241 Miss. 595, 130 So.2d 858; Ed Bush Sandwich Shop v. Strauss, 243 Miss. 507, 138 So.2d 741; Itawamba Manufacturing Co. v. Dependents of Christian, 244 Miss. 587, 145 So.2d 161; Johnson v. Pearl River Sand Gravel Co., 242 Miss. 349, 134 So.2d 434; Potts v. Lowery, 242 Miss. 300, 134 So.2d 474; Rivers Construction Co. v. Dubose, 241 Miss. 527, 130 So.2d 865; United Funeral Home v. Culliver, 240 Miss. 878, 128 So.2d 579.
II. The Commission properly held that the appellee failed to meet the burden of proof as to the causal relation between the disability and his employment. Brookhaven Steam Laundry v. Watts, 214 Miss. 569, 59 So.2d 294; Majure v. William H. Alsup Associates, 216 Miss. 697, 63 So.2d 113; Pearson v. Dixie Electric Power Assn., 219 Miss. 884, 70 So.2d 6; Potts v. Lowery, supra; Smith v. St. Catherine Gravel Co., 220 Miss. 402, 71 So.2d 221; Sullivan v. C. S. Poultry Co., 234 Miss. 126, 105 So.2d 558; Sunnyland Contracting Co. v. Davis, 221 Miss. 744, 74 So.2d 858; Wallace v. Copiah County Lumber Co., 223 Miss. 70, 77 So.2d 316.
III. The Circuit Court committed prejudicial error in rendering its order against the appellants without notice and without giving them an opportunity to appear and defend the appeal. Partoll v. Anaconda Copper Mining Co., 122 Mont. 305, 203 P.2d 974; Wallace v. Copiah County Lumber Co., supra; Sec. 6998-26, Code 1942; Dunn, Mississippi Workmen's Compensation, Sec. 177.
Josh Morse, University; Lester Williamson, Meridian, for appellee.
I. The medical proof that Roby's interstitial pulmonary fibrosis was causally connected with his employment is uncontradicted and not inherently untrustworthy, hence it was error for the Commission to reject it. International Paper Co. v. Handford, 223 Miss. 747, 78 So.2d 895; King v. Westinghouse Electric Corp., 229 Miss. 209, 92 So.2d 209; Lucedale Veneer Co. v. Rogers, 211 Miss. 613, 53 So.2d 69; Reyer v. Pearl River Tung Co., 219 Miss. 211, 68 So.2d 442; Webster Construction Co. v. Bates, 227 Miss. 207, 85 So.2d 795; Dunn, Mississippi Workmen's Compensation, Sec. 167.
II. But if mistaken in the foregoing, claimant contends that he is totally disabled as a result of work-precipitated heart failure, and the testimony of Dr. Smith as to the heart condition is uncontradicted by the report of Dr. McClanahan, as the latter is unbelievable and has no probative force. Capitol Broadcasting Co. v. Wilkerson, 240 Miss. 64, 126 So.2d 242; Lewis v. Trackside Gasoline Station Pacific Indemnity Co., 233 Miss. 663, 103 So.2d 868; Poole v. Learned Son, 234 Miss. 363, 103 So.2d 396; Williams v. Vicksburg Wholesale Poultry Co., 233 Miss. 384, 102 So.2d 692.
III. Reply to brief of appellee. Goodnite v. Farm Equipment Co., 234 Miss. 342, 103 So.2d 391; Hargroves v. Thompson, 31 Miss. 211; Mississippi Fire Ins. Co. v. Evans, 153 Miss. 635, 120 So. 738; Robertshaw Trustees v. Columbus G.R. Co., 185 Miss. 717, 188 So. 308; Thornton v. Fitzhugh, 10 Sm. M. (18 Miss.) 438; Dunn, Mississippi Workmen's Compensation, Secs. 53, 54.
This is an appeal from the Circuit Court of Clay County, Mississippi, which on July 26, 1962, entered a judgment reversing the order of the majority of the Workmen's Compensation Commission of June 22, 1961, and reinstated the award theretofore made by the attorney-referee for permanent total disability of the claimant King David Roby. The claimant had worked for the appellant Babcock and Wilcox Company for nearly eight years before becoming totally and permanently disabled.
In the spring of 1957 he had then been working for the said employer for about three and a half years in the "blasting" department where steel was blasted by machinery; the operation was conducted within a closed room and it caused steel dust and small particles to get into the lungs of the claimant and he was sent by his employer to see Dr. S. Gwin Robbins at Memphis, Tennessee. Dr. Robbins recommended to the employer that the claimant be taken off of the blasting job, except for emergencies, since Dr. Robbins, as shown by his written report to the employer, was of the opinion that "withdrawal of the patient from heavy concentration of this material should adequately relieve his symptoms, that he was suffering from allergic bronchitis, as a result of inhalation of iron dust." The claimant was then transferred to what is referred to in the record as a "buffing operation with a wire brush", located 450 feet from the place where he had theretofore been working.
The claimant testified that while he was working at the buffing operation in September 1959, "about fifteen minutes before quitting time, he had a hurting in his left side, with his shoulders hurting, and that he couldn't see." He was next seen by Dr. Flowers and then by Dr. McCharen, who advised him to quit work. The last day that he worked for this employer was on September 28, 1959. Claimant says in substance that on that day he started upstairs in the plant, and that his arm and shoulder started hurting and that he then blacked out. At that time he had been away from the steel blasting machinery room for more than two years. The record discloses that the claimant had been treated by a Dr. Braddock of West Point, Mississippi, for high blood pressure beginning in 1955 and continuing until he quit work in September 1959.
Dr. Robbins and Dr. McClanahan, who filed written reports in the record by agreement of the parties, stated that in their opinion there was no relation between claimant's illness and his employment. Dr. McClanahan's report was filed on May 11, 1961. All these doctors seem to be in agreement that the employee was permanently and totally disabled, but all were of the opinion that his disability was not work connected. In Dr. McClanahan's report he states: "There is no doubt whatsoever in my mind that this man is totally and permanently disabled by reason of hypertensive cardiovascular disease with angina pectoris. * * * By his own statement to me, following his episode of cough and fever he worked for a period of two years before becoming disabled. By his own description of the work involved, it was essentially light work with no heavy manual labor involved."
Another hearing before the attorney-referee was held on December 13, 1960, in Meridian, Mississippi, at which time Dr. Alanson Brown Smith, a specialist in internal medicine, who examined the claimant on that date only, testified that he found from his examination indications of a combined heart strain with the possibility of a drug effect, an enlarged heart, and increased interstitial fibrosis, which would make it more difficult for him to breathe.
The claimant contends on this appeal that the testimony of Dr. Smith to the effect that he found interstitial fibrosis is wholly uncontradicted, but we find from the report of Dr. McClanahan, which was made a part of the record by agreement of the parties, that he did not find the interstitial fibrosis testified about by Dr. Smith.
Dr. Smith further testified that in his opinion the dust and steel fragments, without respiratory protection would have a bearing on the present status of his lungs, but Dr. Smith was of the further opinion that the condition of the claimant was not causally connected with the work, but said that if it be assumed that the claimant did suffer a heart attack on September 28, 1959, the same would, in his opinion, have been causally related to the work he was doing at the time. But it is not shown by the record that Dr. Smith had any knowledge of what the claimant was doing at the time he had the episode on September 28, 1959. This is shown by the following excerpt from the doctor's testimony, on cross-examination: "Q. And it was your understanding that when he had this so-called heart attack in September of 1959 he was working in this enclosed room and inhaling these dust particles and steel particles at that time? A. Yes, sir."
In other words, when Dr. Smith examined the claimant on December 13, 1960, he had not worked in the steel blasting room since 1957.
The Workmen's Compensation Commission was warranted in believing that the claimant was never retransferred to the steel blasting room at any time after he was moved to the buffing job about 450 feet away in 1957, upon the recommendation of Dr. Robbins.
In other words, it seems from the record that Drs. Robbins and McClanahan were of the opinion that there was no relation between the claimant's illness and his employment, whereas Dr. Smith thought otherwise, but he was under the impression that when the claimant had his episode on September 28, 1959, he was "still working in this enclosed room and inhaling these dust and steel particles at that time," when the truth was that he had been away from this job more than two years at the time he was examined by Dr. Smith.
(Hn 1) We are therefore of the opinion that the decision of the Workmen's Compensation Commission in reversing the decision of the attorney-referee was supported by substantial evidence, even though there might be room for disagreement on that issue. The Commission had the right to evaluate the conflicting medical testimony, if there was in fact a conflict therein, and the judgment of the Circuit Court which reversed the finding of the Commission — the trier of facts — should be reversed and the decision of the Workmen's Compensation Commission reinstated, as being supported by substantial evidence. Cole v. Superior Coach Corp., 234, Miss. 287, 106 So.2d 71; 2 Larson, Workmen's Compensation, Secs. 79.50-79.54; United Funeral Homes, Inc. v. Culliver, 240 Miss. 878, 128 So.2d 579; Cudahy Packing Co. v. Ward, 241 Miss. 595, 130 So.2d 858; Rivers Construction Co. v. Dubose, 241 Miss. 527, 130 So.2d 865; Johnson v. Pearl River Sand Gravel Co., 242 Miss. 349, 134 So.2d 434; Ed Bush Sandwich Shop v. Strauss, 243 Miss. 507, 138 So.2d 741; Itawamba Manufacturing Co. v. Dependents of George Christian, (Miss.), 145 So.2d 161.
Reversed and judgment of Workmen's Compensation Commission reinstated.
Kyle, Gillespie, McElroy and Jones, JJ., concur.