Opinion
249PA19-2
01-06-2023
ASHE COUNTY v. ASHE COUNTY PLANNING BOARD, et al.
John C. Cooke, Attorney at Law, Raleigh, For Ashe County, North Carolina. Gene Hafer, Chairman, For Ashe County Planning Board. Amy C. Crout, Attorney at Law, Raleigh, For Ashe County, North Carolina. Tyler R. Moffatt, Attorney at Law, Boone, For Appalachian Materials, LLC. Craig D. Justus, Attorney at Law, Asheville, For Appalachian Materials, LLC. William Douglas Curtis, Attorney at Law, Raleigh, For Ashe County, North Carolina. William J. Brian, Jr., Attorney at Law, Durham, For North Carolina Home Builders Association, Inc. Jeffrey L. Roether, Attorney at Law, Durham, For North Carolina Home Builders Association, Inc. J. Michael Carpenter, General Counsel, For North Carolina Home Builders Association, Inc. Brian D. Gulden, Attorney at Law, Asheville, For Appalachian Materials, LLC. Jonathan H. Dunlap, Attorney at Law, Asheville, For Appalachian Materials, LLC. F. Bryan Brice, Jr., Attorney at Law, Raleigh, For Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League, et al. Andrea C. Bonvecchio, Attorney at Law, For Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League, et al. Anne M. Harvey, Attorney at Law, For Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League, et al.
John C. Cooke, Attorney at Law, Raleigh, For Ashe County, North Carolina.
Gene Hafer, Chairman, For Ashe County Planning Board.
Amy C. Crout, Attorney at Law, Raleigh, For Ashe County, North Carolina.
Tyler R. Moffatt, Attorney at Law, Boone, For Appalachian Materials, LLC.
Craig D. Justus, Attorney at Law, Asheville, For Appalachian Materials, LLC.
William Douglas Curtis, Attorney at Law, Raleigh, For Ashe County, North Carolina.
William J. Brian, Jr., Attorney at Law, Durham, For North Carolina Home Builders Association, Inc.
Jeffrey L. Roether, Attorney at Law, Durham, For North Carolina Home Builders Association, Inc.
J. Michael Carpenter, General Counsel, For North Carolina Home Builders Association, Inc.
Brian D. Gulden, Attorney at Law, Asheville, For Appalachian Materials, LLC.
Jonathan H. Dunlap, Attorney at Law, Asheville, For Appalachian Materials, LLC.
F. Bryan Brice, Jr., Attorney at Law, Raleigh, For Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League, et al.
Andrea C. Bonvecchio, Attorney at Law, For Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League, et al.
Anne M. Harvey, Attorney at Law, For Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League, et al.
The following order has been entered on the motion filed on the 6th of January 2023 by Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League and its Chapter Protect Our Fresh Air to Withdraw as Counsel:
"Motion Allowed by order of the Court in conference, this the 6th of January 2023."
Berger, J., recused