Opinion
4:19-CV-02107
10-12-2023
CLAYTON ANDREWS, Plaintiff, v. THE BRETHREN MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, Defendant.
ORDER
MATTHEW W. BRANN, CHIEF UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
In accordance with the accompanying Memorandum Opinion, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that:
1. Plaintiff Clayton Andrews' Motions in Limine to exclude evidence of the purchase price of the property (Doc. 63) and to exclude evidence of the post-fire sale and sale price of the property (Doc. 69) are DENIED.
2. Andrews' Motions in Limine to exclude evidence of the prior water loss (Doc. 65); evidence of Andrews' brothers' prior fire losses (Doc. 67); the expert report and testimony of Richard Andress (Doc. 73); and evidence that Andrews sought a certain amount of replacement value insurance (Doc. 75) are GRANTED.
3. Defendant The Brethren Mutual Insurance Company's Motion in Limine to exclude evidence of the absence of an arrest or prosecution arising from the fire (Doc. 77) is GRANTED.
4. The Court reserves judgment on Andrews' Motion in Limine to exclude evidence or argument limiting the amount of damages recoverable to the actual cash value of the property (Doc. 71).