Opinion
SCWC-19-0000505
09-26-2024
IVY H. ANDRADE, Personal Representative of the Estate of CARLOS LAWRENCE ANDRADE, Deceased, Respondent and Petitioner/Plaintiff-Appellee/Cross-Appellee, v. KUOLULU (k); MANUEL RAPOSO A.K.A. MANUEL RAPOZO; MARIA ALVINA JOSE A.K.A. MARIA ALVINA RAPOZO; MANUEL JOSE, SR.; ALBERT J. JOSE; WAYNE KENNETH JOSE; MAY CLARA JOSE; FRANCIS DURFEE; DEBRA DIANNE JOYCE; MICHELLE WOOD; TRACY ANN WALDRON; MARY F. WEBB; RAYMOND EDWARD JOSE; LYDIA S. JOSE; DOROTHY TAVARES A.K.A. DOROTHY JOSE; JACINTHO "JACK" JOSE; ADAM THOMAS JOSE; NORMA J. WAGNER; THOMAS ADAM JOSE; JUDY JOSE; EVA "EVELYN" CHANG A.K.A. MARY EVA "EVELYN" CHANG; JANICE PANG HACKBARTH A.K.A. JANICE PANG A.K.A. JANICE CHANG; GORDON N. CHANG; GAYLE N. MORIHARA; REGINALD DERRICK NEWBERRY A.K.A. REGINALD DERRICK CHANG; MARGARETTE "PEGGY" KALEIWAHEA; WILLIAM E. KALEIWAHEA, JR.; WAYNE A. KALEIWAHEA; PHILLIS GRADO; ANTOINETTE K. JOHNSON; JACQUELINE "JACKIE" KALEIWAHEA; KIM KALEIWAHEA; ALICE G. MOORE; HERBERT G. MOORE; AMELIA "EMILY" J. ABREN A.K.A. AMELIA SILVA; JOHN "JACK" JOSE; BYRON JOHNSON JOSE; JACQUELINE KNOBBE A.K.A. JACQUELINE BLOCK; ROBERT JOHN KNOBBE; ALFRED "FRED" JOSE; JAMES RANDOLPH JOSE; ALFRED JOSE, JR.; ANGELINE CORDEIRO A.K.A. ANGELINA CORDEIRO; SISTER JEANNE CORDEIRO A.K.A. GENEVIEVE CORDEIRO; HERBERT CORDEIRO; IRENE TERESA CORDEIRO; DENIS G. CORDEIRO; JOHN H. CORDEIRO; CHARLOTTE WEEKLEY; MICHELLE L. WEEKLEY; CHARDRA LEAH BRYANT; CHERYL BETH BESHORE A.K.A. CHERYL BETH WEEKLEY; GEROLD BESHORE; ROBERT CORDEIRO; NATALIE CORDEIRO; ROXANE MARIE MILLER; LORY ANN QUIPOTLA; KENNETH N. CORDEIRO A.K.A. NORMAN KENNETH CORDEIRO; JOHN P. CORDEIRO; LUIS DRAPER; NICOLE KELSON; HALEY CARTER; DEBRA VITTORE; SANDRA LUANA CORDEIRO; ALEXANDER JOSE; JR.; BETTY JOSE LONG A.K.A. JACQUELINE "PEGGY" LONG; PAUL V. LONG; DORIS HEDGEPETH LONG; CLARENCE R. JENKINS; JOHN H. JENKINS; HUBERT LEVI JENKINS; EDWARD EARL JENKINS, JR.; BETTY ANN BASS A.K.A. BETTY ANN PINERO A.K.A. BETTY ANN BALAI A.K.A. BETTY ANN LONG; CAMERON PINERO; PAUL LEWIS PINERO; SHARNELL KOGER; PAUL LEWIS PINERO, JR.; PATRICIA PINERO; MARGARET JANE TAYLOR; JODIE PEDRO; BRIAN TAYLOR; ROBERT A. TAYLOR, JR.; PAKA CHARLES TAYLOR; KEHAU CHARLES TAYLOR; PATRICIA JEAN FERREIRA A.K.A. PATRICIA JEAN JOSE; CHARLES FERREIRA; SHARON MARTINEZ; PAMELA UMIAMAKA; DEANN FERREIRA; WILLIAM STEPHEN JOSE; GEORGINA "JEAN" WOODS; BARBARA JEAN MYERS; SHIRLEY ANN MYERS; GEORGE JOSE, SR.; GEORGE JOSE, JR.; WAYNE JOSE, son of George Jose, Jr.; ROSE COBO A.K.A. ROSE JOSE; JOYCE COFFIN; MARIA PEARL; RANDY JOSE; DAVID JOSE; THOMAS JOSE, son of George Jose Jr.; ROSELYN DUNCAN A.K.A. ROSLIN JOSE; JONI M. FIELD; RANDOLPH MATTHEW FIELD, JR.; EDWARD CELESTINE JOSE; DONALD R. JOSE; SHARON MARIE JOSE; EDWARD JOSE, JR.; DOROTHY JOSE; DEREK JOSE; DOUGLAS JOSE; DEBORA ANDERSON A.K.A. DEBORA JOSE; DORIE BAKER; ELIZABETH SANTIAGO A.K.A. ELIZABETH JOSE; CHARLES L. JOSE; EDWARD JOSE; DAWN BASUIL; THERESA FLORES; DELORES C. SWAYNE A.K.A. CATHERINE D. JOSE; DIANA SHIRLEY BRITT A.K.A. DIANA JOSE; LISA ANN KYLE A.K.A. LISA ANN BROWN A.K.A. LISA ANN BRITT; BRYANT D. BRITT; CRYSTAL MARIA COSTILLA BRITT A.K.A. CHRYSTAL COLICHER; SHELBY M. WISE A.K.A. SHELBY M. BRITT; BRYANNE DIANA BELANGER; HELEN BLACKWELL A.K.A. MARTHA HELEN JOSE; ANTHONY "TONY" JOSE; BARBARA JEAN THOMPSON; CYNTHIA LOUISE CAMACHO; KENELM K. CHANG; LILLIAN CHANG; NALINE M. LEE; FRANCISCO "FRANK" JORDAN; MANUEL JORDAN, JR.; JOSEPH "BILL" JORDAN; ALICE S. JORDAN; WALTER SIMAO, SR.; ELLEN SIMAO; ENID SIMAO; LEE DOWNS; EARL SIMAO; DEANNA CARRERA; RICHARD SIMAO; HAROLD W. SIMAO; ANGELINA "JEAN" MILLS; ALLAN DOUGLAS BEERMAN; SUSAN RENE WARE; JOSEPH A. SILVA; MARGARET F. SILVA; PETER J. SILVA, SR.; JOSEPH A. SILVA, JR.; MARGIE L. GALINDO; CAROL MARIE WATERS; ALFRED SILVA GANANSA; ANTHONY SILVA; JOYCE A. SILVA; NICHOLAS G. SILVA; BEATRICE SILVA; MARGARET J. CAMERON; PATRICIA FRANCES PILA; ROBERT PILA, JR.; DIANE HAYASHI; ROBERT PILA III; CAMERON PILA; HELEN DePERRIERA; ERNEST DePERRIERA; JR.; STEPHEN D. PERRIERA, SR.; STEPHEN D. PERRIERA, JR.; JESSE PERRIERA; SCOTT ALAN PERRIERA; DEAN A. PERRIERA; TABITHA M. PERRIERA; AMBER LEIGH MURPHY; TIFFANY J. PERRIERA; NICHOLAS WILLIAM PERRIERA; ADAM P. PERRIERA; JONATHAN M. PERRIERA; AMANDA SKAWSKI; DANNY PERRIERA; BARBARA JEAN BROWN; ADAM RAPOZO JORDAN; HELEN JORDAN; ROBERT JORDAN; LAWRENCE JORDAN; EVA JANDA A.K.A. EVE JONDA; LINDA J. GILL; IDA J. MARIANO; JOSEPH "SONNY" MARIANO; HILDEGARD C. MARIANO; THOMAS JOSEPH MARIANO; JOHN CLARK MARIANO; JEANNETTE CHAVEZ; BEATRICE CAMPBELL; PATRICK MARIANO; JOSEPH MARIANO III; WALTRAUD "DOLLY" HEITZ; HANS JURGEN; SANDRA NOLL; RODNEY E. MARIANO; DAVID C. MARIANO; MICHELLE N. GARCIA; GERALD "JEROME" MARIANO; BEVERLY KALIKO MARIANO; MARJORY M. STARMEN A.K.A. MARGIE STARMAN; MICHAEL DUARTE; MARK DUARTE; DEBRA SHOFFIT; BETTY ANN LEE; JEANETTE JOHNSON; MANUEL RAPOZO, JR.; GEORGINA "JEANNIE" ISABELLA REAY; ARTHUR MARION REAY; CAROLINE ISABELL RATHBURN; MARVIN ARTHUR RATHBURN; NORMA RATHBURN; MARVIN S. RATHBURN; VANESSA MARIE RATHBURN; LEVI RATHBURN; KENNETH RATHBURN; THOMAS R. RATHBURN; RENEE RATHBURN; DAVID A. RATHBURN; RICHARD A. RATHBURN; RENELLEN HENRY A.K.A. RENELLEN BEGBIE; RAYMOND A. REAY; OLIVIA McMAHEL; ANN DONNA JACOBI; BRUCE T. JACOBI; NOLA SUSAN SMITH; CLIFFORD A. McMAHEL; DEAN McMAHEL; TERRY LYNN HERMAN-SANTOS A.K.A. TERRY LYNN HERMANN; TIMOTHY McMAHEL; JOHN RAPOZO; JACKIE DIAS A.K.A. JOSEPHINE RAPOZO; MERLIN NORTON RAPOZO; ROBERT RAPOZO; DUANE RAPOZO; MARIAN J. TAVARES; LEONARD RAPOZO; RONALD RAPOZO; WILLIAM "WILLIE" RAPOZO; VIOLET RAPOZO; CHARLOTTE L. CUMMINGS; ANDREW CUMMINGS; ANGELINE SOUZA A.K.A. ANGELINA SOUZA; MANUEL RAYMOND SOUZA; LYDIA EDITH SOUZA; BEVERLY JUNE BIGONGIARI; NELLO BIGONGIARI; JOSEPH SOUZA; GABRIEL SOUZA; JAMES BENJAMIN "BENNY" SOUZA; FRANK RAPOZO, SR.; JOSEPH RAPOZO; EDWARD RAPOZO; RAYMOND RAPOZO; FRANK (FRANKIE) RAPOZO, JR.; MARIE SARDINA RAPOZO A.K.A. MARY "GIRLIE" RAPOZO; JOSEPH SARDINA RAPOZO; JOSEPH RONALD RAPOZO A.K.A. RONALD RAPOZO; GORDON RAPOZO; GERALD RAPOZO A.K.A. JERRY RAPOZO; MARY RAPOZO; GILBERT RAPOZO; RAYMOND R. RAPOZO; RUSSELL RAPOZO; NICHOLAS RAPOZO; ELLEN RAPOZO; STEPHEN RAPOZO; MERVIN RAPOZO; MADELINE YAMAGUCHI A.K.A. MADELINE RAPOZO; DOREEN RITA A.K.A. DOREEN RAPOZO; ANTONE RAPOZO; MARY RAPOZO A.K.A. MARY SILVA; REGINALD JOSEPH SILVA; MERVIN "STAN" SILVA; KATHLEEN KOERTE; KATHERINE SILVA; ANTONE RAPOZO, JR.; LILLIAN V. RAPOZO; OLIVIA EVANS; EUGENE EVANS, SR.; MARTIN "MARK" RAPOZO; GEORGE VICTOR RAPOZO; MARK RAPOZO; GERALDINE RAPOZO; MARTIN RAPOZO; GERALD RAPOZO; KAREN RAPOZO; ALFRED R. RAPOZO; PATRICIA RAPOZO; BARRY RAPHAEL RAPOZO; LARRY STEPHEN RAPOZO; PEGGY PONCINI-RAPOZO; RUSSELL RAPOZO TRUSTEE OF THE EDWARD S. RAPOZO TRUST; PILAA KULEANA LLC; DEPARTMENT OF TAXATION, STATE OF HAWAIʻI; NORTHSHORE KALO LLC, a Hawaii Limited Liability Company; their respective heirs and assigns, Respondents/Defendants-Appellees/Cross-Appellees, and WAYNE J. RAPOZO, Petitioner and Respondent/ Proposed Intervenor-Appellant/Cross-Appellee, and SHANNON BUCKNER, Petitioner and Respondent/Defendant-Appellant/Cross-Appellee, and MERWIN ANDREW STAPP, JR.; SHARON MARGARET STAPP; JENNIE GUERRERO; TERI FERREIRA-IGE; EUGENE EVANS, JR.; MATHEW EVANS and SHAMUS EVANS, Petitioners and Respondents/ Defendants-Appellees/Cross-Appellants. (CAAP-19-0000505; CASE. NO. 5CC161000209) WAYNE RAPOZO and SHANNON BUCKNER, Petitioners and Respondents/Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. IVY H. ANDRADE, Personal Representative of the Estate of CARLOS LAWRENCE ANDRADE, Deceased, Respondent and Petitioner/Defendant-Appellee. (CAAP-19-0000576; CASE NO. 5CC191000044)
CERTIORARI TO THE INTERMEDIATE COURT OF APPEALS
Recktenwald, C.J., McKenna, Eddins, Ginoza, and Devens, JJ.
ORDER REJECTING APPLICATION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
Petitioners' Application for Writ of Certiorari, filed on July 30, 2024, is hereby rejected.