Opinion
NOS. CAAP-19-0000505 CAAP-19-0000576
06-04-2024
Ivy H. ANDRADE, Personal Representative of the Estate of Carlos Lawrence Andrade, Deceased, Plaintiff-Appellee/Cross-Appellee, v. KUOLULU (K); Manuel Raposo a.k.a. Manuel Rapozo; Maria Alvina Jose a.k.a. Maria Alvina Rapozo; Manuel Jose, Sr.; Albert J. Jose; Wayne Kenneth Jose; May Clara Jose; Francis Durfee; Debra Dianne Joyce; Michelle Wood; Tracy Ann Waldron; Mary F. Webb; Raymond Edward Jose; Lydia S. Jose; Dorothy Tavares a.k.a. Dorothy Jose; Jacintho "Jack" Jose; Adam Thomas Jose; Norma J. Wagner, Thomas Adam Jose; Judy Jose; Eva "Evelyn" Chang a.k.a. Mary Eva "Evelyn" Chang; Janice Pang Hackbarth a.k.a. Janice Pang a.k.a. Janice Chang; Gordon N. Chang; Gayle N. Morihara; Reginald Derrick Newberry a.k.a. Reginald Derrick Chang; Margarette "Peggy" Kaleiwahea; William E. Kaleiwahea, Jr.; Wayne A. Kaleiwahea; Phillis Grado; Antoinette K. Johnson; Jacqueline "Jackie" Kaleiwahea; Kim Kaleiwahea; Alice G. Moore; Herbert G. Moore; Amelia "Emily" J. Abren a.k.a. Amelia Silva; John "Jack" Jose; Byron Johnson Jose; Jacqueline Knobbe a.k.a. Jacqueline Block; Robert John Knobbe; Alfred "Fred" Jose; James Randolph Jose; Alfred Jose, Jr.; Angeline Cordeiro a.k.a. Angelina Cordeiro; Sister Jeanne Cordeiro a.k.a. Genevieve Cordeiro; Herbert Cordeiro; Irene Teresa Cordeiro; Denis G. Cordeiro; John H. Cordeiro; Charlotte Weekley; Michelle L. Weekley; Chardra Leah Bryant; Cheryl Beth Beshore a.k.a. Cheryl Beth Weekley; Gerold Beshore; Robert Cordeiro; Natalie Cordeiro; Roxane Marie Miller, Lory Ann Quipotla; Kenneth N. Cordeiro a.k.a. Norman Kenneth Cordeiro; John P. Cordeiro; Luis Draper, Nicole Kelson; Haley Carter; Debra Vittore; Sandra Luana Cordeiro; Alexander Jose; Jr.; Betty Jose Long a.k.a. Jacqueline "Peggy" Long; Paul V. Long; Doris Hedgepeth Long; Clarence R. Jenkins; John H. Jenkins; Hubert Levi Jenkins; Edward Earl Jenkins, Jr.; Betty Ann Bass a.k.a. Betty Ann Pinero a.k.a. Betty Ann Balai a.k.a. Betty Ann Long; Cameron Pinero; Paul Lewis Pinero; Sharnell Koger; Paul Lewis Pinero, Jr.; Patricia Pinero; Margaret Jane Taylor; Jodie Pedro; Brian Taylor; Robert A. Taylor, Jr.; Paka Charles Taylor; Kehau Charles Taylor, Patricia Jean Ferreira a.k.a. Patricia Jean Jose; Charles Ferreira; Sharon Martinez; Pamela Umiamaka; Deann Ferreira; William Stephen Jose; Georgina "Jean" Woods; Barbara Jean Myers; Shirley Ann Myers; George Jose, Sr.; George Jose, Jr.; Wayne Jose, Son of George Jose, Jr.; Rose Cobo a.k.a. Rose Jose; Joyce Coffin; Maria Pearl; Randy Jose; David Jose; Thomas Jose, Son of George Jose Jr.; Roselyn Duncan a.k.a. Roslin Jose; Joni M. Field; Randolph Matthew Field, Jr.; Edward Celestine Jose; Donald R. Jose; Sharon Marie Jose; Edward Jose, Jr.; Dorothy Jose; Derek Jose; Douglas Jose; Debora Anderson a.k.a. Debora Jose; Dorie Baker; Elizabeth Santiago a.k.a. Elizabeth Jose; Charles L. Jose; Edward Jose; Dawn Basuil; Theresa Flores; Delores C. Swayne a.k.a. Catherine D. Jose; Diana Shirley Britt a.k.a. Diana Jose; Lisa Ann Kyle a.k.a. Lisa Ann Brown a.k.a. Lisa Ann Britt; Bryant D. Britt; Crystal Maria Costilla Britt a.k.a. Chrystal Colicher; Shelby M. Wise a.k.a. Shelby M. Britt; Bryanne Diana Belanger; Helen Blackwell a.k.a. Martha Helen Jose; Anthony "Tony" Jose; Barbara Jean Thompson; Cynthia Louise Camacho; Kenelm K. Chang; Lillian Chang; Naline M. Lee; Francisco "Frank" Jordan; Manuel Jordan, Jr.; Joseph "Bill" Jordan; Alice S. Jordan; Walter Simao, Sr.; Ellen Simao; Enid Simao; Lee Downs; Earl Simao; Deanna Carrera; Richard Simao; Harold W. Simao; Angelina "Jean" Mills; Allan Douglas Beerman; Susan Rene Ware; Joseph A Silva; Margaret F. Silva; Peter J. Silva, Sr.; Joseph A. Silva, Jr.; Margie L. Galindo; Carol Marie Waters; Alfred Silva Ganansa; Anthony Silva; Joyce A. Silva; Nicholas G. Silva; Beatrice Silva; Margaret J. Cameron; Patricia Frances Pila; Robert Pila, Jr.; Diane Hayashi; Robert Pila III; Cameron Pila; Helen Deperriera; Ernest Deperriera; Jr.; Stephen D. Perriera, Sr.; Stephen D. Perriera, Jr.; Jesse Perriera; Scott Alan Perriera; Dean A. Perriera; Tabitha M. Perriera; Amber Leigh Murphy; Tiffany J. Perriera; Nicholas William Perriera; Adam P. Perriera; Jonathan M. Perriera; Amanda Skawski; Danny Perriera; Barbara Jean Brown; Adam Rapozo Jordan; Helen Jordan; Robert Jordan; Lawrence Jordan; Eva Janda a.k.a. Eve Jonda; Linda J. Gill; Ida J. Mariano; Joseph "Sonny" Mariano; Hildegard C. Mariano; Thomas Joseph Mariano; John Clark Mariano; Jeannette Chavez; Beatrice Campbell; Patrick Mariano; Joseph Mariano III; Waltraud "Dolly" Heitz; Hans Jurgen; Sandra Noll; Rodney E. Mariano; David C. Mariano; Michelle N. Garcia; Gerald "Jerome" Mariano; Beverly Kaliko Mariano; Marjory M. Starmen a.k.a. Margie Starman; Michael Duarte; Mark Duarte; Debra Shoffit; Betty Ann Lee; Jeanette Johnson; Manuel Rapozo, Jr.; Georgina "Jeannie" Isabella Reay; Arthur Marion Reay; Caroline Isabell Rathburn; Marvin Arthur Rathburn; Norma Rathburn; Marvin S. Rathburn; Vanessa Marie Rathburn; Levi Rathburn; Kenneth Rathburn; Thomas R. Rathburn; Renee Rathburn; David A. Rathburn; Richard A. Rathburn; Renellen Henry a.k.a. Renellen Begbie; Raymond A. Reay; Olivia McMahel; Ann Donna Jacobi; Bruce T. Jacobi; Nola Susan Smith;’ Clifford A. McMahel; Dean McMahel; Terry Lynn Herman-Santos a.k.a. Terry Lynn Hermann; Timothy McMahel; John Rapozo; Jackie Dias a.k.a. Josephine Rapozo; Merlin Norton Rapozo; Robert Rapozo; Duane Rapozo; Marian J. Tavares; Leonard Rapozo; Ronald Rapozo; William "Willie" Rapozo; Violet Rapozo; Charlotte L. Cummings; Andrew Cummings; Angeline Souza a.k.a. Angelina Souza; Manuel Raymond Souza; Lydia Edith Souza; Beverly June Bigongiari; Nello Bigongiari; Joseph Souza; Gabriel Souza; James Benjamin "Benny" Souza; Frank Rapozo, Sr.; Joseph Rapozo; Edward Rapozo; Raymond Rapozo; Frank (Frankie) Rapozo, Jr.; Marie Sardina Rapozo a.k.a. Mary "Girlie" Rapozo; Joseph Sardina Rapozo; Joseph Ronald Rapozo a.k.a. Ronald Rapozo; Gordon Rapozo; Gerald Rapozo a.k.a. Jerry Rapozo; Mary Rapozo; Gilbert Rapozo; Raymond R. Rapozo; Russell Rapozo; Nicholas Rapozo; Ellen Rapozo; Stephen Rapozo; Mervin Rapozo; Madeline Yamaguchi a.k.a. Madeline Rapozo; Doreen Rita a.k.a. Doreen Rapozo; Antone Rapozo; Mary Rapozo a.k.a. Mary Silva; Reginald Joseph Silva; Mervin "Stan" Silva; Kathleen Koerte; Katherine Silva; Antone Rapozo, Jr.; Lillian V. Rapozo; Olivia Evans; Eugene Evans, Sr.; Martin "Mark" Rapozo; George Victor Rapozo; Mark Rapozo; Geraldine Rapozo; Martin Rapozo; Gerald Rapozo; Karen Rapozo; Alfred R. Rapozo; Patricia Rapozo; Barry Raphael Rapozo; Larry Stephen Rapozo; Peggy Poncini-Rapozo; Russell Rapozo Trustee of the Edward S. Rapozo Trust; Pilaa Kuleana LLC; Department of Taxation, State of Hawaii; Northshore Kalo LLC, a Hawaii Limited Liability Company; their respective heirs and assigns, Defendants-Appellees/Cross-Appellees, and Wayne J. Rapozo, Proposed Intervenor-Appellant/Cross-Appellee, and Shannon Buckner, Defendant-Appellant/Cross-Appellee, and Merwin Andrew Stapp, Jr.; Sharon Margaret Stapp; Jennie Guerrero; Teri Ferreira-Ige; Eugene Evans, Jr.; Mathew Evans and Shamus Evans, Defendants-Appellees/Cross-Appellants, and Doe Defendants 1-200; and all whom it may concern, Defendants Wayne Rapozo and Shannon Buckner, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. Ivy H. Andrade, Personal Representative of the Estate of Carlos Lawrence Andrade, Deceased, Defendant-Appellee, and Doe Defendants 1-100; Doe Corporations 1-100; and Doe Entities 1-100, Defendants
APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTH CIRCUIT (CIVIL NO. 5CC161000209), (CIVIL NO. 5CC191000044) MEMORANDUM OPINION
Affirm. Vacate in part. Remand. Vacate in part. Affirm.