Opinion
2:18-cv-03736-RGK-E 2:18-CV-08220-RGK-E
02-17-2022
ANGEL OMAR ALVAREZ, et al., Plaintiffs, v. XPO LOGISTICS CARTAGE, LLC dba XPO LOGISTICS, et al., Defendants. AND CONSOLIDATED ACTIONS
FINAL ORDER AND JUDGMENT
Hon. R. Gary Klausner Judge
CLASS ACTION
WHEREAS, Plaintiffs and Class Representatives Angel Omar Alvarez, Alberto Rivera, Fernando Ramirez, Juan Romero, Jose Paz, Jairo Moreno Martinez, Jesus Carreon, Rodolpho Moreno, and Edgar Mendoza (collectively, “Plaintiffs”), on behalf of themselves and the Class, and Defendants XPO Logistics Cartage, LLC, XPO Cartage, Inc., XPO Logistics, Inc., XPO Logistics, LLC, XPO Intermodal Solutions, Inc., and XPO Intermodal Services, LLC (collectively, “Defendants”), by and through their respective duly-authorized counsel, entered into a Class Action Settlement Agreement (hereafter, the “Settlement”) in the above-captioned litigation (hereafter, the “Action”), filed on February 26, 2018;
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Order Granting Preliminary Approval of Class Action Settlement, Approving Form and Manner of Notice, and Setting Date for Fairness Hearing, entered on October 8, 2021 (the “Preliminary Approval Order”), the Court scheduled a hearing for December 18, 2021 at 9:00 a.m. (the “Fairness Hearing”) to, among other things: (i) determine whether the proposed settlement of the Action on the terms and conditions provided in the Settlement is fair, reasonable and adequate, and should be approved by the Court, and (ii) determine whether a judgment as provided for in the Settlement should be entered;
WHEREAS, the Court ordered that the Notice of Proposed Class Action Settlement, substantially in the form attached as Exhibit 3 to the Settlement, be mailed by first-class mail, postage prepaid, within 15 days after the date of entry of the Preliminary Approval Order (“Notice Date”) to all Class Members identified through reasonable effort;
WHEREAS, the Notice of Proposed Class Action Settlement advised Class Members of the date, time, place and purpose of the Fairness Hearing, and further advised that any objection to the Settlement was required to be filed with the Court, and served on the Settlement Administrator, CPT Group, on or before December 6, 2021;
WHEREAS, the provisions of the Preliminary Approval Order as to notice of the settlement were fully complied with, and notice to the Class was given in the manner required by the Court;
WHEREAS, on December 13, 2021, Plaintiffs moved for Final Approval of the Settlement, as set forth in the Preliminary Approval Order;
WHEREAS, the Fairness Hearing was duly held before this Court on January 10, 2022 at which time all interested persons were afforded the opportunity to be heard;
WHEREAS, the Plaintiffs' Motion for Final Approval of the Settlement includes a request for final approval of the settlement of claims under the California Labor Code Private Attorney General Act (“PAGA”), as required by California Labor Code section 2699, subdivision (1), for the civil penalties sought as part of the Settlement;
WHEREAS, this Court has duly considered the Plaintiffs' Motion, all papers and evidence submitted in connection therewith, the Settlement, and all of the submissions and arguments presented at the Fairness Hearing with respect to the proposed Settlement;
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED as follows:
1. This Final Order and Judgment (“Judgment”) incorporates by reference the definitions in the Settlement, and all capitalized terms used in this Judgment that are not otherwise defined shall have the same meanings as those set forth in the Settlement.
2. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of the Action, and over all parties and all those found by the Court to be members of the Class, which means the class certified by the Court's Order of September 16, 2020, excluding (except for purposes of the PAGA claim) those individuals who previously, timely, and validly opted out, which included Michael Tesfamariam Yebio, Ignacio Lopez, Noe Campos, Firas Qanbar, Alvaro Baez Duarte, Armando Henriquez, Luis Humberto Montalvo, Mariano A. Saravia, and Osman Rafael Garcia, as well as those who settled their claims prior to the said certification order. A list of the members of the Class is attached hereto as Exhibit A. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Court does retain jurisdiction over the opt outs for the limited purposes of the settlement of the PAGA claim.
3. The notification provided for and given to the Class: (i) was provided and made in full compliance with the Court's Preliminary Approval Order; (ii) constituted the best notice practicable under the circumstances; (iii) constituted notice that was reasonably calculated to apprise the Class of the terms of the Settlement, of the proposed plan of allocation, of Class Counsel's application for an award of attorneys' fees and litigation expenses incurred in connection with this Action, of Class Counsel's application for Service Awards to Plaintiffs and certain active class members, and of the right of Class Members to appear at the Fairness Hearing; (iv) constituted due, adequate, and sufficient notice to all persons entitled to receive notice of the proposed Settlement; and (v) fully satisfied the notice requirements of Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the United States Constitution (including the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution), and all other applicable law and rules.
4. In light of the substantial benefits provided to the Class by the Settlement, the complexity, expense and possible duration of further litigation of the Action, including any possible appeals, the risks of establishing liability and damages, and the costs of continued litigation, the Court hereby fully and finally approves the settlement as set forth in the parties' Class Action Settlement Agreement in all respects, including, without limitation, the PAGA penalties sought therein, and finds that the Settlement is, in all respects, fair, reasonable and adequate, and in the best interests of the Plaintiffs, the Class, and the Class Members.
5. This Court further finds that the Settlement is the result of arms-length negotiations conducted under the supervision of a neutral mediator by highly experienced counsel representing the interests of their respective parties.
6. Plaintiffs and Defendants (collectively, the “Settling Parties”) are hereby ordered to consummate the Settlement in accordance with the terms and provisions therein, except with respect to the attorneys' fees, costs, and incentive payments, on which the Court separately ruled on February 8, 2022. In accordance with the Court's February 8, 2022 order, the Court has approved attorneys' fees to class counsel in the amount of $6,666,660, with 90 percent of the award allocated to counsel for the Alvarez and Martinez Plaintiffs to be divided per their agreement and the remaining 10 percent of the award allocated to counsel for the Mendoza Plaintiff. Also in accordance with the Court's February 8, 2022 order, the Court has approved an award of litigation costs in the amount of $386,225.67 to the Alvarez counsel and $14,800.16 to the Martinez counsel, and the Court has approved incentive payments in the amount of $15,000 to each Alvarez Plaintiff, $10,000 to each Martinez Plaintiff and Mendoza, and $2,000 to each Active Class Member.
7. The settlement of the PAGA claims released in the Settlement is approved on behalf of the “aggrieved employees, ” as that term is used in California Labor Code section 2698, et seq. Settlement of the PAGA claims is binding on the parties, aggrieved employees, and the California Labor and Workforce Development Agency, including all members of the Class as well as those that opted out..
8. The operative Fourth Amended Complaint in this Action, filed on December 13, 2019, is hereby dismissed in its entirety, with prejudice, and without costs to any party, except as otherwise provided in the Settlement.
9. The Court further finds that during the course of the Action, the Settling Parties and their respective counsel at all times complied with the requirements of Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
10. Upon the Effective Date of the Settlement, Plaintiffs and all other Class Members, on behalf of themselves and each of their respective heirs, executors, trustees, administrators, predecessors, successors, and assigns, shall be deemed to have fully, finally and forever waived, released, discharged, and dismissed each and every one of the Released Claims as against each and every one of the Releasees, and shall forever be barred, enjoined and restrained from commencing, instituting, prosecuting or maintaining any and all of the Released Claims against any and all of the Releasees.
11. Each Class Member is bound by this Judgment, including, without limitation, the release of claims set forth above. The persons listed in Exhibit 2 to the Settlement have validly and timely requested exclusion from the Class, such that those persons are excluded from the Class and are not Class Members but remain bound by the Settlement with respect to the resolution of the PAGA claim.
12. This Judgment and the Settlement, whether or not consummated, and any discussions, negotiations, proceedings or agreements relating to the Settlement, and any matters arising in connection with settlement discussions or negotiations, proceedings, or agreements, shall not be offered or received against or to the prejudice of the settling parties, or their respective counsel, for any purpose other than in an action to enforce the terms hereof, and in particular:
a. do not constitute, and shall not be offered or received against or to the prejudice of Defendants as evidence of, or construed as, or deemed to be evidence of any presumption, concessions, or admissions by Defendants with respect to the truth of any allegation by Plaintiffs and the Class, or the validity of any claim that has been or could have been asserted in the Action or in any litigation, including, but not limited to, the Released Claims, or of any liability, damages, negligence, fault or wrongdoing of Defendants or any person whatsoever;
b. do not constitute, and shall not be offered or received against or to the prejudice of Defendants as evidence of a presumption, concession, or admission of any fault, misrepresentation, or omission with respect to any statement or written document approved or made by the Defendants, or against or to the prejudice of Plaintiffs or any other Class Member(s) as evidence of any infirmity in the claims of Plaintiffs or the other Members of the Class;
c. do not constitute, and shall not be offered or received against or to the prejudice of Defendants, the Named Plaintiffs, and any other Class Member(s), or their respective counsel, as evidence of a presumption, concession, or admission with respect to any liability, damages, negligence, fault, infirmity or wrongdoing, or in any way referred to for any other reason against or to the prejudice of any of the Defendants, Named Plaintiffs, other members of the Class, or their respective counsel, in any other civil, criminal or administrative action or proceeding, other than such proceedings as may be necessary to effectuate the provisions of the Settlement;
d. do not constitute, and shall not be construed against Defendants, the Named Plaintiffs, or any other Class Member(s), as an admission or concession that the consideration to be given hereunder represents the amount which could be or would have been recovered after trial; and e. do not constitute, and shall not be construed as or received in evidence as an admission, concession, or presumption against the Named Plaintiffs or any other
Class Member(s) that any of their claims are without merit or that damages recoverable in the Action would not have exceeded the Settlement amount.
13. In the event that the Settlement does not become effective in accordance with the terms provided therein, then this Judgment shall be rendered null and void to the extent provided by and in accordance with the Settlement and shall be vacated; and in such event, all orders entered and releases delivered in connection herewith shall be null and void to the extent provided by and in accordance with the Settlement.
14. Without further order of the Court, the Settling Parties may agree to reasonable extensions of time to carry out any of the provisions of the Settlement.
15. Without affecting the finality of this Judgment in any way, this Court hereby retains continuing jurisdiction over: (i) implementation of the Settlement; (ii) any award or distribution of the Class Settlement Fund; (iii) disposition of the Class Settlement Fund; (iv) all Settling Parties for the purpose of construing, enforcing and administering the Settlement and this Judgment; and (v) all other matters related or ancillary to the foregoing.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
EXHIBIT A
Class Member Name
INAYA, MUSTAFA
SHAMOON, SAIFAN
MOSHI, LAYTH
BRAN, PEDRO ANTONIO
UZHAKHOV, USMAN MAGOMETOVICH
UGALDE, JOSE LUIS
TRAN, TRONG MINH
GILL, CHAINVARINDER
ISAACS, DONAVON
AGUILAR, BECKER ELIU
TSOLAKYAN, MIKAYEL
ELBASHIER MOHAMED, ELHINDI
LEWIS, IRVING ED
MEKAEL, ANTWAN
TATLA, INDERPAL SINGH
INTERIANO, GARY
SILL, GOVIND
BUIE, CRAIG
SPENCER, TRAVIS LEONARD
GOAD, DAVID LAMAR
HAMID, REFAT
MITCHELL, DAVID MARCELLA
AGUILAR, ROBERTO R.
VIORATO LOPEZ, JOSE LUIS
MOORE, DENNIS
AL BARBARAWI, ISSAM
ABDELHALIM, YASSER
HASAN, MAHMOUD
ABDUL KHALEK REBOLLOO, TUFIK JIHAD
ROSAS, JOSE C
YOUSIF, RAAD HEKMET
ABARCA, RINGO
ALEXANDER, MARION
BERRIEN, RICKESIA EVETTE
PERERA, ANTON
JOHNSON, BRADLEY M.
DAVIS, BLAIR E.
SCOTT, TODD ALEXANDER
POOLE, MICHAEL LASHAWN
DAMPEER, RICKY LEWIS
DAY, DARRELL
DECOUD, LAWRENCE M
PEREZ, JAVIER LOPEZ
PALAFOX, GUILLERMO
C HASKELL, CHARLES
RANGEL, JORGE JOSE
Class Member Name
PEREZ CHAVEZ, JULIO
DRESSLER, CHRISTOPHER A
HIRMIZ, MARIO
GAYTAN, ERMILIO FELIPE
WILLIAMS, TRACY
PHELPS, BRIAN
CASTRO, JOSE
NUNEZ ALBA, PABLO
AMADOR NUNO, LEOPOLDO A
VILLA, CARLOS DAVID
ROSILES, MANUEL
SRAI, NIRMAL
MENDOZA, HECTOR
CASTRO, ALEJANDRO JOSE
NUNEZ DUARTE, FELIX
SUTTON, JOHN THOMAS
NORTH, ROBERT
LUDDEN, ALVIN JAMES
SINGH, ASHWINDAR
COBBS, KENNETH
WILLIAMS, THEODORE RAY
ALCALA, MAURICIO
VALENZUELA, JORGE LUIS
RUADA, JOSE W
VENTURA CHAVARRIA, JOSE
ACKLING, MICHAEL D
HARO, HECTOR
RUIZ, VIRGILIO JUAREZ
CEBALLOS, ROBERT
RAY WHITE, JIMMY
BUESA, FRANK
MARTIN, DAMONIQUE
GUERRERO LOOR, LUIS ANTONIO
CASTRO, JESUS
THOMPSON, DOUGLAS
PALOMINO, JORGE
LOPEZ, JOEL
ZAMORA, EMANUEL
SHEPHERD, DERRICK
FLORES, SERGIO
THOMAN, FLOYD STANLEY
LOPEZ ANGULO, JOSE ZARATIEL
MENDOZA, EDGAR
GONZALEZ, LUIS
HEARST, TIMOTHY
LEAL, DANIELL
Class Member Name
SALCEDO, HUGO
MENDOZA, RICARDO
LOPEZ, MIGUEL
SMITH, WALTER ROBERTO
MUNOZ, JOSUE
NEWTON, PAUL JULIAN
PARTIDA, CARLOS
GALAVIZ JR, MIGUEL
MITCHELL, JERRY
REDD, JAVAR DANDRE
FELIX JR, RUDOLPH
SOWELL, MARCUS
MIZIOLEK, TOMASZ
HOYOS, GERMAN GALLEGO
WILLIAMS, STANLY BERNARD
DIAZ, ERNESTO MARTIN
GARCIA, MANUEL DOZAL
BEDOLLA, JORGE JAVIER
RIVERA, FRANCISCO
ALFARO, BENJAMIN
HARO, MAURILIO
HERNANDEZ, VICTOR M.
PONCE-WARD, JOSE MANUEL
ZAPIEN, BRIAN
GUTIERREZ, VICENTE
MORAN, MARSIANO
ROJAS, RICARDO MANUEL
LARA, JESUS
GARCIA, ISMAEL
YAZELL, BRUCE E.
MOORE, LARRY DEWAYNE
THOMAS, JEREMY CARL
CALDERA, EVERARDO
FAVELA, MIGUEL OSCAR
CERVANTES, JOSE
CRUZ, ARTHUR T.
HART, ANDRE LAMAR
MENDEZ, MEDARDO
DEON, TERRY LYNN
RAMIREZ, JOSE ANGEL
ANTONIO FRIAS, JOSE
FIGUEROA, FRANKLIN
GARCIA, ABRAHAM
RODRIGUEZ, ISIDRO
MARSHALL, KEITH L
CUADROS, ROSIE
Class Member Name
ZENDEJAS, HERMAN
MORALES, JOE SONORA
LEE WILLIAMS, CHRISTOPHER
RAWLS, REGINALD
LUKE, KEVIN
CANTY, ISAAC BLAKE
WOODS, VERNON ALEXANDER
FIGUEROA, JOSE ALEJANDRO
ROMERO, CARLOS
RODRIGUEZ, CARLOS
NATHAN MCKENZIE, HOWARD
GRANADOS ALVIDREZ, DANIEL
CASTRO III, JOHNNY
TORRES, MICHAEL F.
LEYVA, JESUS
SERMENO, ANGELICA
STEVENS, DAVID MARTIN
BROWN, WALTER
HOWARD JR, KENNETH F
FIGUEROA, RAUL ARMANDO
MEAVE, JOSE LUIS
RODRIGUEZ, JOSE L.
C HERNANDEZ, ERIC
ZAMORA, CHRISTIAN
MALDONADO, JAVIER
RAMIREZ, FERNANDO GARCIA
OLMASSAKIAN, VAHE
CAMPOS-FRANCO, RAFAEL
PEREZ, SALVADOR
FRANCO, RICARDO ALBERTO
LEO SCOTT, PETER
GAITAN, NAPOLEON
DURAN, MIGUEL
SALAZAR, ROBERT
GONZALEZ, JOSE
BROWN, THOMAS EDWARD
LOPEZ, GUILLERMO
PRIETO, ARMANDO
WEST, TROY ALLEN
RODRIGUEZ, MARCO ANTONIO
RIVERA, EDGAR JOSE
DAVIS, FREDERIC MICHAEL
MARQUEZ, FLORENCIO
MONTENEGRO, MARIO ANIBAL
ALCALA, CARLOS
LEDESMA, JOSEPH LUIS
Class Member Name
FUENTES, DAVID RAUL
WATSON, DAVID
TADEO JR, JOHN
JARAMILLO, GUS
RAMIREZ, ALFREDO
SANDEZ, HUGO
PARADA, EDWIN OSWALDO
ROCHA, ARTEMIO
MCARTHUR YOUNG, KEITH
CESAR MARTINEZ CAMPILLO, JULIO
MARTINEZ, MANUEL OSCAR
JOEL WIECHENS, CORBIN
HERNANDEZ, LUIS E
BERNAL, ADALBERTO
CHAVEZ, FRANCISCO ANTONIO
GONZALEZ, MAURICIO
LEON LOPEZ, ENRIQUE
RODRIGUEZ, JOSE LUIS
HERRERA ISLAS, JESUS
RIVERA AMADOR, MARIO
RUIZ VASQUEZ, FAUSTINO
BONILLA, LUIS
SANCHEZ, EMER A.
ROCHA, JUAN ERNESTO
CHIBUKHCHYAN, ARMEN
DE LA CRUZ MORENO, ISMAEL
KALKAT, SANDEEP S
MERIDA, JULIO E
MONTES, MARLON
SANDOVAL VILLA, PABLO
PEREZ SMITH, MARTIN
LOPEZ, JOSE ABRAHAM
GUTIERREZ DURAN, OCTAVIANO
GOMEZ ARTEAGA, RAYMUNDO
GARCIA, RUBEN
MARTINEZ CRUZ, MARIO
MOLINA, LUIS R.
RAMIREZ, JOSE
JIRJEEZ, SAL
SINGH, GURWINDER
DIAZ, RAFAEL
HERNANDEZ, JOSE LUIS
SANDOVAL, HUGO ODILIO
BARRAZA, ELIAS ARMANDO
RAMIREZ, CARLOS FERNANDO
SALGADO, FELIPE
Class Member Name
BURTON, CHRISTOPHER ARTHUR
LOPEZ, CARLOS NOEL ORTEGA
VASQUEZ, JUAN MANUEL
SANDHU, HARDEEP
SANDHU, GURDEEP
RAMIREZ PALACIOS, SAMUEL
KUMAR, ASHISH
VILLALVAZO CHAVEZ, JAIME
MADRID, SILVERIO
DHILLON, AMARJOT SINGH
BOLANOS, RAFAEL HARO
ALVARADO, JOSE ANTONIO
SANTOSCOY, JORGE
LEAL, ARTURO
MEDINA, ANICETO
GONZALEZ, VIRGILIO
ALVARADO ESPINOZA, ARNULFO
LANDEROS, RUBEN OCHO
ZAZUETA, MARCO ANOTNIO
VALERIO, FRANCISCO
CAZAREZ LOPEZ, JOSE ARMANDO
RUELAS GARCIA, JORGE EDUARDO
MEJIA, ATENOGENES CORONEL
GUZMAN, JANIS ANTONIO
MIRANDA, MARIO MATA
ELIAS, METHAK
ZILFA, SAM SABAH
ZILFA, RYAN
SOLTERO, GABRIEL
VALDEZ, RAUL
RETENA-ELIZARRARAZ, JAVIER
MACIAS, CARLOS
AGUIRRE, JAIME
CRUZ, JOSE MANUEL
SINGH, BHUPINDER
PEREZ, NEFTALY
GALVAN, ALBERT
F MARTINEZ, MARIO
MONROY, OSWALDO
CHRISTOPHER, FRED PAUL
MARKOVICS, KEVIN
SAHIB, OMAR
ALJBORY, ALI, F/K/A HUSSEIN, ALI
HERNANDEZ, IGNACIO
ESQUER, MARIO
HERNANDEZ, ERNESTO
Class Member Name
MARTINEZ, JAIRO MORENO
MENDOZA, HELADIO CLIMACO
CARREON, JESUS
ALVAREZ, REYES
VALDIVIA, JESUS
RAMIREZ, NICANOR
MEJIA FLORES, CARLOS H
GOMEZ, MIGUEL ANGEL
HIDALGO CORRALES, JOSE HENRY
ACOSTA, RUBEN EZIO
ALVAREZ, JOSUE ISRAEL
ALCALA, JOSE MARTIN
C CASTANEDA, JUAN
ACOSTA, REYNALDO GOMEZ
SANCHEZ, BRIAN ALLEN
LOPEZ, RAUL ORTIZ
RIVERA, ERNESTO
CALDERA, JULIO ANTONIO
RODRIGUEZ, MARTIN
FUNES MUNOZ, WILLIAM ISAAC
GUTIERREZ, FERNANDO
GOMEZ, GABRIEL
SOLIS SANCHEZ, JOSE JAVIER
PEREZ, DOMINGO
FLORES, ALLEN
CRUZ BONILLA, JOSE B
LOPEZ, RUDY ALBERTO
KORKES, LORANS
LOPEZ VILLAREAL, OSCAR IVAN
SINGH, MANJIT
ACHA ALIPIO, ENRIQUE
TAMAYO, DELIA
PAZ MENDOZA, MAXIMINO
ALANIZ, EDGAR ULISES ALEJO
ISLAS JR, JUAN MANUEL
HERNANDEZ, GREGORIO LOMELI
SALAZAR, ARTURO
GIRON, CELSO
RIVERA, RAUL
BELTRAN, ALVARO
MARTINEZ VALDEZ, LUIS JESUS
FRASQUILLO CARDOSO, JORGE ENRIQUE
LOPEZ, MARIO ALBERTO
MOSQUEDA, SERGIO
RUIZ, VICTOR
ARCEO, VICENTE
Class Member Name
SINGH, HARAMRIT N
LIZARRAGA, RUBEN
MENERA VARGAS, JULIO
AVILA, SERVANDO
VALDIVIA, JACK
ALVARENGA, JOSE CARLOS
GORGES, WAAD
DHILLON, JASPAL SINGH
ELIAS, RICARDO ANTONIO
RAMIREZ, JAVIER
LARA, JOSE AMILCAR
FUENTES ROQUE, MAURICIO
WHITE, MICHAEL ALLAN
SINGH, JOGA
GARCIA, JUAN
CATARINO SANCHEZ, JUAN MANUEL
DASHTO, TONY
OROZCO GARCIA, REYES DE JESUS
GARCIA, JOSE A
HERRERA, MARTIN
SALAZAR OROZCO, FRANCISCO ARMANDO
KUFFO, LUIS E
AGUILAR HERNANDEZ, LUIS A
CHAVEZ OLIVAREZ, MIGUEL
BARRAGAN, JOSE DAVID
MURRIETA, CARLOS
PARRILLAS MARTINEZ, OSCAR
SINGH, NARINDER
MONTANO CARVAJAL, EDUARDO
YUK, SOPHEAROATH
PAHUAMBA, JAVIER PABLO
ESCOBEDO HERNANDEZ, RODRIGO
CEVALLOS, DAVID S
ALVAREZ, JOAQUIN
PAYAN, JOSE AMBROCIO
CARRILLO, PEDRO
ROMO ROMERO, JESUS
SERPAS, FRANKLIN SAUL
ARREOLA, DONACIANO
RODRIGUEZ, EDGAR NAVARRETE
GARCIA, CANDELARIO
SANCHEZ, CELIN A
ORDONEZ, JUAN F NIEVES
PLEITEZ, NEFTALY
QUINTEROS, MARVIN ALEXANDER
GARCIA GONZALEZ, GUADALUPE
Class Member Name
HERRERA, JOSE SANTIAGO
CHAVEZ, FRANCISCO
RODRIGUEZ, RAMON
RODRIGUEZ, MAURICIO
CONTRERAS, MIGUEL
MARTINEZ, ARMANDO
ZERMENO, EDGAR FRANCISCO
AGUILAR, MANUEL
SINGH, JASWINDER
ATWAL, KULWINDER SINGH
DHANOA, IQBAL
PEREZ CORTES, JESUS A.
HALL, RANDY JAMES
POZUELOS, RAFAEL
PENILLA, CARLOS ANTONIO
ALBERTO RAMIREZ, LUIS
BARRETO, JOSE
ARELLANO, VICTOR CORTES
GOMEZ, GABRIEL
KRAMER, ALEX
BONILLA, ALVARO FERNANDO
GIRON, MARIO
CHAMORRO, ANIBAL
JHAJJ, KASHMIRA
BUKSH, SHAMEER
TREJO, LEONARDO
RIVAS PINEDA, OSWALDO
RAMOS, EDUARDO BENITO
SOSA LOPEZ, ALEXANDER
IFEACHO, KINGSLEY
RAMIREZ IBARRA, RICARDO
CAUDILLO LOPEZ, LUANGEL
LOMELI, JOSE ANGEL
ZEPEDA, GILBERTO
IBARRA, TOMAS
LOPEZ FUENTES, OSCAR A
VELAZQUES DIAS, MANUEL
FELIX MOJICA, ARTURO
THEWENY, SARMAD
HIDALGO, MARLO A CRUZ
DACOSTTA MARMOLEJOS, WILLIAM A
SINGH, UPINDER
RIVERA LIZARRAGA, ALBERTO
LOPEZ, ROBERTO
LOPEZ, EFRAIN PLASCENSIA
CEBALLOS, SERGIO J.
Class Member Name
FLORES, DAVID
IBARRA, ROGELIO
VERDUZCO, JULIO C.
GOMEZ, ALLAN JAVIER
LEON, FREDI RAMON LEAL
VALDEZ ZAMBANO, COSME D
TORRES, ROBERT CHARLES
MARTINEZ, JOSE O
NERIO JUAREZ, RENE GUSTAVO
ELIZALDE, JOSE C.
SEDEEK, MUSTAFA TAHA
SAENZ, CARLOS
TORRES SANDOVAL, RIGOBERTO
LARRAIN, GIOVANNE A SANABRIA
SANCHEZ, EFREN
TORRES, HUGO
MONGE, DENIS X.
NAVARRO DELGADO, OSCAR
PAREDES, LEODAN
RODRIGUEZ, OSCAR
DA SILVA, GRANT ANTHONY
LUGO, GUILLERMO
LOPEZ, ANTONIO
GAZCON, FERNANDO
MORENO MORA, PEDRO
FLORES, ALFONSO
LUNA, HORACIO
PEREZ GAMBOA, FRANCISCO AARON
RODRIGUEZ VARGAS, ALFREDO
DANIAL, DANIAL
BARRERA, CARLOS
GOMEZ, ANGEL
DIAZ AGUILAR, JUAN M
ARBY, TAREQ
ORTIZ, FELIX
ZEDAN, MEJDY GHAZI
MENDEZ, DAGOBERTO ABAC
AVALOS, ADOLFO ROGELIO
PAZ, JOSE A.
TIRADO, JESUS LOZANO
ALVARADO PAEZ, JOSE ISRAEL
VILLATORO, EDGARDO
FLORES NUNEZ, JOSE DE JESUS
ALDRETE, RUBEN
CABRERA, JOSE F
CONTRERAS, ABEL
Class Member Name
GONZALEZ, CARLOS
FRANCO, FRANCISCO
IGLESIAS, CRISPIN
TRUJILLO, PABLO
GUERRERO SEGURA, ALEJANDRO
CAZAREZ, JAVIER
GONZALEZ, JOSE RAUL
PERAZA, JOSE T
GONZALEZ, RAUL
ORTIZ, JAVIER G
ALVAREZ SURUKI, CARLOS
TORRES, SERGIO
DISUS, ALBERT
DOMINGUEZ, GUILLERMO
SOTO PEREZ, JUAN
YEGIAZARYAN, ARMEN
ROBINSON, JONTE LEE
TERAN, FRANCISCO
SERRANO, JORGE
VALDOVINOS, RODRIGO ITURBURO
MONTIEL, ARMANDO
DOMINGUEZ DIAZ, RODOLFO
MELENDEZ, NESTOR ANTONIO
CRUZ NORORI, LESTER G
PAZ, GILBERTO SANTOS
BHANGU, HARINDER SINGH
FIGUEROA RANGEL, LUIS MARTIN
MORENO, JESUS EDUARDO
NEIDIFFER, JOSE MARTIN
GONZALEZ, FRANCISCO
GONZALEZ VILLASENOR, SALVADOR
GOYAL, ANIL
TIMBO, ALHAJI
QUINTANAR GUEVARA, GERARDO
ROMERO, JUAN DESIDERIO
MIRANDA CORDOVA, FRANCISCO ANTONIO
SANDOVAL ESCALANTE, HECTOR
LOPEZ MORAN, MARIO
FERNANDEZ, KARLA
COTTO, FERNANDO
REYES CARDENAS, LUIS
GARDUNO PEREZ, JOSE GUADALUPE
PAULIK, VICTOR
CAMPOS, ALFONSO LIMON
THOMAS, MORRIS KENDRICK
MORA, ERICK JOSE
Class Member Name
TISTOJ, MYNOR OSWALDO
FLORES, BRYAN
DE LEON, FREDY ROLANDO
MONZO NQUEVEDO, BYRON
GONZALEZ, JORGE
ISCOA, JOSE FRANCISCO
SINGH, HARBANS
MIKHA, RAMI
MEZA, JUAN CARLOS
HERNANDEZ, MIGUEL EMILIO
SANCHEZ, GERARDO
AGUILAR, EDDY RAUL
MORENO CARRASCO, RODOLFO
ROJAS, JOSE OSCAR
MALDONADO, TONI E PEREZ
HERNANDEZ, JUAN CARLOS
SOTO PRIETO, MARTIN
MIGUEL ORTIZ, ANGEL
GARCIA, OSCAR EDUARDO
QUIROZ, MIGUEL
MAZARIEGOS, FRANCISCO G
SOSA, RAFAEL ANTONIO
CAMINOS, JULIO A
MARTINEZ MARQUEZ, JORGE
ORTIZ BRAVO, SIGIFREDO
GARCIA, ALEJANDRO
ROSAS, CESAR
SOTO, JUAN
PIMENTEL, PEDRO
GOMEZ ROSA, JULIO FERNANDO
SINGH, JAGAT BIREN
ALVAREZ, ANGEL
SANTIESTEBAN RODRIGUEZ, ISRAEL
OLGUIN GUTIERREZ, ALEJANDRO
GUZMAN, MIGUEL MOLINA
COBIAN, JULIO C
RUIZ, MARCO A
MORENO, ULYSES ISMAEL
BRIBIESCAS, JUAN MANUEL
ARIAS GARCIA, PABLO
JAVIER REGALADO JR, FRANCISCO
HUSSEIN, SAHARDID A.
SULTANOV, VIDADI
ROCHA, GERARDO
VILLA HERRERA, CESAR ABELINO
TOTEV, SABIN ATANASCOV
Class Member Name
ZARAGOZA DIMAS, GERARDO
ALSADOON, MOHAMMED
SHEKHAR, VINOD KUMAR
SAEED, SAEED Z
CERROS, JOSE DARWING
GUILLERMO AGUIAR, LUIS
SINGH, HARPINDER
AYALA, DANILIO DE JESUS
CHAVEZ-MONTANO, ARTURO
ZOURI, STEVEN
WRIGHT, DONNELLY LEANDER
MIXON, ANTONY DUSCHE
LOPEZ, JOSE CARLOS
HILLS, RONALD LYNN
ALVAREZ JR, ALEJANDRO
CABRAL, ALEJO
CHUN, EDGAR FRANCISCO SANTAY
MANZO, ERIC
BARRAGAN, FEDERICO
HERNANDEZ, FEDERICO
KACOGUI, JOSE L.
LEMUS, MIGUEL A
LOE, RAFAEL SERVIN
FITE, REGENIA
AGUAYO, REYMUNDO CASTRO
MARTINEZ, RICARDO
SHAMON, ROBERT
PARRA MACIAS, ROBERTO
MALDONADO, IVAN
SALGADO, MARIO
GARBA, MURTALA
SARMIENTO ROJAS, ARMANDO
DUNAWAY RIZO, MICKER EDEN