April 14, 1916. Hugo Hirsh [ Emanuel Newman and Benjamin Reass with him on the brief], for the plaintiff. Andrew F. Van Thun, Jr. [ William A. Kirk with him on the brief], for the defendants Maud Archer and others. Charles L. Craig, for Madelaine E. Damon, guardian ad litem for the defendant Samuel P. Barker, Jr. Robert H. Haskell [ James M. Gorman with him on the brief], for the infant defendant Beatrice Arabelle Barker. THOMAS, J.: The testator, dying in 1875, gave by will to his daughters annuities