From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Wakeman v. Bultman

Supreme Court of South Dakota
May 8, 1954
64 N.W.2d 296 (S.D. 1954)

Opinion

File No. 9403.

Opinion filed May 8, 1954.

1. Wills.

In will contest, evidence sustained findings that testatrix was competent to make will, that it was duly executed and attested, and that the signing of the instrument was not accomplished by undue influence and fraud.

Appeal from Circuit Court, Lincoln County; Hon. John T. Medin, Judge.

In a will contest case, judgment was entered admitting will to probate, and contestants appeal.

Judgment affirmed.

Bogue Masten, Canton, for Contestants-Appellants.

T.R. Johnson, Sioux Falls, for Proponents-Respondents.


The probate of the purported will of Ada Thorpe, deceased, was opposed on the grounds that (1) she was not competent to make a will, (2) it was not duly executed and attested, and (3) the signing of the instrument was accomplished by undue influence and fraud. The evidence was conflicting upon all of these issues. These conflicts were resolved by the trial court in favor of the proponents, and the will was admitted to probate.

The ultimate issue on appeal is whether the evidence is sufficient to sustain the findings of the trial court. For us to decide that the evidence is insufficient to sustain any one of those findings, we would be compelled to conclude the trial court acted unreasonably in believing the testimony of the proponents and their witnesses. We find no sound basis for such a conclusion in the record. Therefore, the judgment must be affirmed. Houck v. Hult, 63 S.D. 290, 258 N.W. 142; Rhode v. Farup, 67 S.D. 437, 293 N.W. 632, and Scott v. Liechti, 70 S.D. 89, 15 N.W.2d 1.

All the Judges concur


Summaries of

Wakeman v. Bultman

Supreme Court of South Dakota
May 8, 1954
64 N.W.2d 296 (S.D. 1954)
Case details for

Wakeman v. Bultman

Case Details

Full title:In re THORPE'S ESTATE WAKEMAN et al., Appellants v. BULTMAN et al.…

Court:Supreme Court of South Dakota

Date published: May 8, 1954

Citations

64 N.W.2d 296 (S.D. 1954)
64 N.W.2d 296

Citing Cases

In re Estate of Anders

Contrary to the assertions of the appellants, this uncontradicted evidence is sufficient to uphold the trial…