Opinion
19 Cr. 107 (AT)
07-09-2020
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, v. JOHN ULRICH, Defendant.
ORDER :
I. Setting Remote Proceeding
It is ORDERED that sentencing shall be held in this action on July 22, 2020, at 2:00 p.m. The hearing shall proceed by videoconference. Instructions for the parties' participation in and the public's observance of the proceeding are set out below.
Under the terms of Section 15002(b)(2) of the CARES Act, Pub. L. No. 116-136 (2020), the Judicial Conference of the United States has found that emergency conditions due to the national emergency declared by the President with respect to COVID-19 materially have affected and will materially affect the functioning of the federal courts, and the Chief Judge of this district has entered an order finding that "felony pleas under Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure [and] felony sentencings under Rule 32 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure . . . cannot be conducted in person without seriously jeopardizing public health and safety," and authorizing such proceedings to be conducted by "video teleconferencing, or telephone conferencing if video conferencing is not reasonably available . . . with the consent of the defendant . . . after consultation with counsel and upon a finding by the presiding judge that the proceeding cannot be further delayed without serious harm to the interests of justice." In re Coronavirus/Covid-19 Pandemic, 20 Misc. 176, ECF No. 1 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 30, 2020).
Defendant's counsel having represented to the Court that Defendant consents to this sentencing being conducted via videoconference, the Court finds that this proceeding cannot be further delayed without serious harm to the interests of justice, because of the age of the case and the fact that Defendant has expressed health concerns caused by the ongoing postponement of sentencing. See ECF No. 44. Accordingly, pursuant to Section 15002(b)(2)(A) of the CARES Act, it is ORDERED that the sentencing shall proceed by videoconference.
II. Instructions
The conference shall proceed via videoconference. Chambers will email directions directly to the parties. Members of the public may access the audio of the proceeding by calling 1-917-933-2166 and entering conference ID number 531877087.
Further, all participants must identify themselves every time they speak, spell any proper names for the court reporter, and take care not to interrupt or speak over one another. Finally, all of those accessing the conference — whether in listen-only mode or otherwise — are reminded that recording or rebroadcasting of the proceeding is prohibited by law.
If video conferencing does not work well enough and the Court decides to transition to its teleconference line, counsel should call 888-398-2342 or 215-861-0674, and enter access code 5598827.
If possible, defense counsel shall discuss the attached Waiver of Right to be Present at Criminal Proceeding with the Defendant prior to the proceeding. If the Defendant consents, and is able to sign the form (either personally or, in accordance with Standing Order 20 Misc. 174 of March 27, 2020, by defense counsel), defense counsel shall file the executed form at least 24 hours prior to the proceeding. In the event the Defendant consents, but counsel is unable to obtain or affix the Defendant's signature on the form, the Court will conduct an inquiry at the outset of the proceeding to determine whether it is appropriate for the Court to add the Defendant's signature to the form.
To the extent that there are any other documents relevant to the proceeding (e.g., proposed orders or documents regarding restitution, forfeiture, or removal), counsel should submit them to the Court (by email or on ECF, as appropriate) at least at least 24 hours prior to the proceeding. To the extent any documents require the Defendant's signature, defense counsel should endeavor to get them signed in advance of the proceeding as set forth above; if defense counsel is unable to do so, the Court will conduct an inquiry during the proceeding to determine whether it is appropriate for the Court to add the Defendant's signature.
SO ORDERED. Dated: July 9, 2020
New York, New York
/s/_________
ANALISA TORRES
United States District Judge WAIVER OF RIGHT TO BE PRESENT AT CRIMINAL PROCEEDING Check Proceeding that Applies ___ Entry of Plea of Guilty
I am aware that I have been charged with violations of federal law. I have consulted with my attorney about those charges. I have decided that I wish to enter a plea of guilty to certain charges. I understand I have a right to appear before a judge in a courtroom in the Southern District of New York to enter my plea of guilty and to have my attorney beside me as I do. I am also aware that the public health emergency created by the COVID-19 pandemic has interfered with travel and restricted access to the federal courthouse. I have discussed these issues with my attorney. By signing this document, I wish to advise the court that I willingly give up my right to appear in person before the judge to enter a plea of guilty. By signing this document, I also wish to advise the court that I willingly give up any right I might have to have my attorney next to me as I enter my plea so long as the following conditions are met. I want my attorney to be able to participate in the proceeding and to be able to speak on my behalf during the proceeding. I also want the ability to speak privately with my attorney at any time during the proceeding if I wish to do so.Date:
__________
Print Name
__________
Signature of Defendant ___ Sentence
I understand that I have a right to appear before a judge in a courtroom in the Southern District of New York at the time of my sentence and to speak directly in that courtroom to the judge who will sentence me. I am also aware that the public health emergency created by the COVID-19 pandemic has interfered with travel and restricted access to the federal courthouse. I do not wish to wait until the end of this emergency to be sentenced. I have discussed these issues with my attorney and willingly give up my right to be present, at the time my sentence is imposed, in the courtroom with my attorney and the judge who will impose that sentence. By signing this document, I wish to advise the court that I willingly give up my right to appear in a courtroom in the Southern District of New York for my sentencing proceeding as well as my right to have my attorney next to me at the time of sentencing on the following conditions. I want my attorney to be able to participate in the proceeding and to be able to speak on my behalf at the proceeding. I also want the ability to speak privately with my attorney at any time during the proceeding if I wish to do so.Date:
__________
Print Name
__________
Signature of Defendant I hereby affirm that I am aware of my obligation to discuss with my client the charges against my client, my client's rights to attend and participate in the criminal proceedings encompassed by this waiver, and this waiver and consent form. I affirm that my client knowingly and voluntarily consents to the proceedings being held with my client and me both participating remotely. Date:
__________
Print Name
__________
Signature of Defense Counsel
Addendum for a defendant who requires services of an interpreter:
I used the services of an interpreter to discuss these issues with the defendant. The interpreter also translated this document, in its entirety, to the defendant before the defendant signed it. The interpreter's name is: __________. Date:
__________
Signature of Defense Counsel
Accepted:
__________
Signature of Judge
Date: