Opinion
Case No.3:11-cr-183-001
02-01-2013
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, v. PAUL DAVID MUSGRAVE, Defendant.
Attorneys for Plaintiff: Dwight Keller Alex Sistla Attorneys for Defendant: William Terpening Matthew DeAntonio
Judge Timothy S. Black
Minutes for a Jury Trial (Day 5) before
the HONORABLE TIMOTHY S. BLACK, U.S. DISTRICT JUDGE
COURTROOM DEPUTY: Mary Rogers
LAW CLERK: Michael Rhinehart
COURT REPORTER: Jodie Perkins, Official Court Reporter
TIME: Began: 8:45 am Concluded: 1:20 pm
Attorneys for Plaintiff:
Dwight Keller
Alex Sistla
Attorneys for Defendant:
William Terpening
Matthew DeAntonio
WITNESSES
Andrea Kinzig; Defendant called John Staub and Barbara Musgrave
PROCEDURES
_x_ Counsel present
___ Voir Dire started/concluded
___ Jury Selected
___ Opening Statements made by both Plaintiff and Defendant
_x_ Plaintiff calls witnesses
_x_ Plaintiff admits exhibits
_x_ Plaintiff rests
_x_ Defendant calls witnesses
___ Defendant admits exhibits
___ Defendant rests
_ Plaintiff's rebuttal ___ No rebuttal
_ Closing Arguments
Remarks: Argument heard regarding Defendant's Motion (Doc 99); the Court GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART the Defendant's Motion and addressed the parties regarding summary evidence and provided instructions in that regard; Government called Andrea Kinzig (sworn); Government rests; Offers Exhibits (marked and admitted); Defendant makes oral Rule 29 Motion, reserves argument pending witness testimony; Calls witnesses: John Staub, Barbara Musgrave, (sworn); Jury admonished and released for the day; Oral argument heard on Defendant's oral motion for Rule 29; Jury Charge Conference conducted; Trial to resume on 2/4/2013 at 9:15 a.m.