From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Patrick

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jun 1, 1859
51 N.C. 308 (N.C. 1859)

Opinion

June Term, 1859.

That a person "was generally reputed to be free, and had acted and passed as a free man," can be adduced in a trial to operate against him, as well as when such evidence operates in his favor.

THIS was an INDICTMENT against the defendant, as a free negro, for carrying fire arms, tried before SAUNDERS, J., at the last Spring Term of Brunswick Superior Court.

Attorney General, for the State.

Baker, for the defendant.


In order to show that the defendant was a free negro, the solicitor for the State, asked a witness whether the defendant passed as and was reputed in the neighborhood in which he lived, to be a free negro. The witness answered in the affirmative. On the question being propounded, the defendant's counsel objected, and on the admission of the evidence, he excepted. To a question of the solicitor, the witness stated he had the appearance, and looked like a negro. This was also objected to, but admitted by the Court, and the defendant's counsel again excepted. Verdict, guilty. Judgment and appeal.


It is clearly settled that it is evidence in favor of negro, in a suit for his freedom, that he is generally reputed to be free, and has always acted and passed as a free man. See Jarman v. Humphrey, ante 28, and Brookfield v. Stanton, ante 156. If such evidence be admissible to establish the fact of a negro's being free, when it is to operate in his favor, it seems to us, that it must equally be so when it is to operate against him.

That a man's color may be proved to show that he is a negro, is a proposition too plain to admit of a doubt. State v. Chavers, 5 Jones' Rep. 11.

PER CURIAM, Judgment affirmed.


Summaries of

State v. Patrick

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jun 1, 1859
51 N.C. 308 (N.C. 1859)
Case details for

State v. Patrick

Case Details

Full title:STATE v . WILLIAM PATRICK

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Jun 1, 1859

Citations

51 N.C. 308 (N.C. 1859)

Citing Cases

Cole v. District Board of School Dist

But on this point we have found more authorities than on the other. Bryan v. Walton, 20 Ga. 480, 508, White…

State v. Miller

Another method was approved in Hare v. Board of Education, 113 N.C. 9, 18 S.E. 55, where the Court said:…