From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. McDowell

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Oct 1, 1885
93 N.C. 541 (N.C. 1885)

Opinion

(October Term, 1885.)

Appeal — Record — Certiorari.

1. An appeal to the Supreme Court will be dismissed when the transcript of the record fails to show that a court was held, or that a grand jury presented the indictment, and when it appears from the case on appeal that the grounds on which the defendant appealed are frivolous.

2. A certiorari will not be granted to perfect the record and constitute the appeal in the Supreme Court, when it appears from the case on appeal that the appellant has no merits.

( S. v. Butts, 91 N.C. 524; S. v. Johnston, post, 559, cited and approved.)

(542) MOTION to dismiss the defendant's appeal, heard at October Term, 1885, of the Supreme Court.

Attorney-General for the State.

No counsel for defendant.


The papers in the case on file in this Court, purporting to be the transcript of the record in the Superior Court of the county of Bladen, fail to show that a court was held by a judge at the time and place prescribed by law. Nor does it appear that a grand jury presented an indictment against the defendant; nor does a judgment appear. For these and other less important defects the Attorney-General moved at the present term to dismiss the appeal.

Enough, however, appears in the papers — not the transcript of a record — to satisfy us that there is, or ought to be, a record in the court mentioned, and we might direct the writ of certiorari to issue to the clerk of that court commanding him to certify to us a perfect transcript thereof, but on looking into what purports to be the case settled upon appeal for this Court, we find that the defendant's ground of exception is without the slightest merit, and we deem it proper to grant the motion to dismiss the supposed appeal. S. v. Butts, 91 N.C. 524; S. v. Johnston, post, 559.

Appeal dismissed.

Cited: S. v. Walker, 103 N.C. 413; S. v. Preston, 104 N.C. 735; S. v. May, 118 N.C. 1205; S. v. Stafford, 203 N.C. 603.


Summaries of

State v. McDowell

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Oct 1, 1885
93 N.C. 541 (N.C. 1885)
Case details for

State v. McDowell

Case Details

Full title:STATE v. ANN McDOWELL

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Oct 1, 1885

Citations

93 N.C. 541 (N.C. 1885)

Citing Cases

State v. Stafford

In Spence v. Tapscott, 92 N.C. 576, it was held (as stated in first head-note): "In order for the Supreme…

State v. May

CLARK, J. The transcript fails to show that the court was held by a judge at the time and place required by…