From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Davis

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Hancock
Jun 2, 1944
37 A.2d 762 (Me. 1944)

Opinion

Opinion, June 2, 1944.

Statutes.

The statute relied upon by the prosecution was repealed previous to the bringing of the action and so the question presented was abstract and required no determination.

ON AGREED STATEMENT OF FACTS.

Complaint for a violation of Chapter 130, Public Laws 1929. The offense charged was the unlawful digging of clams for commercial purposes in the town of Trenton in violation of Rule and Regulation 42 of the Commission of Sea and Shore Fisheries. Said statute had been repealed. Report discharged. The case fully appears in the opinion.

Ralph C. Masterman, County Attorney, for the State.

O. H. Emery, for the respondent.

SITTING: STURGIS, C.J., THAXTER, HUDSON, MANSER, MURCHIE, CHAPMAN, JJ.


This criminal prosecution, originating in the municipal court of Ellsworth, on appeal to the Superior Court is reported for final determination upon an agreed statement of facts. Although the offense charged is the unlawful digging of clams for commercial purposes in the town of Trenton in violation of Rule and Regulation 42 of the Commissioner of Sea and Shore Fisheries and contrary to the form of the statute in such cases made and provided it is agreed that the complaint is for a violation of Chapter 130, Public Laws 1929, a general statute.

The rejection of the recital of Rule and Regulation 42 in the complaint as surplusage is authorized. Rawlings v. State, 2, Md., 201; Mayer v. State, 64 N.J.L. 323, 45 A. 624; 1 Chitty's Crim. Law, 276; 31 C. J., 703. But the statute, Chapter 130, P. L. 1929, relied upon, was repealed by Sec. III, Chap. 2, P. L. 1933 and does not exist. As a result the question presented is abstract and does not require determination.

Report discharged.


Summaries of

State v. Davis

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Hancock
Jun 2, 1944
37 A.2d 762 (Me. 1944)
Case details for

State v. Davis

Case Details

Full title:STATE OF MAINE vs. CHARLES H. DAVIS

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Maine. Hancock

Date published: Jun 2, 1944

Citations

37 A.2d 762 (Me. 1944)
37 A.2d 762