From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. County Election Board of Comanche County

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jun 22, 1937
69 P.2d 35 (Okla. 1937)

Opinion

No. 27263.

April 6, 1937. Rehearing Denied May 25, 1937. Application for Leave to File Second Petition for Rehearing Denied June 22, 1937.

(Syllabus.)

Appeal and Error — Dismissal Where Question Becomes Moot.

When the question presented by an appeal has become moot, the appeal will be dismissed.

Appeal from District Court, Comanche County; Eugene Rice, Judge.

Application for a writ of mandamus by the State on relation of T.G. Dorland against the County Election Board of Comanche County. Writ denied, and relator appeals. Dismissed.

S.R. Harper and Robert Landers, for plaintiff in error.

Dwight Malcolm, Charles Bledsoe, and C.S. McCuiston, for defendant in error.


On the 28th day of April, 1934, plaintiff filed a proceeding against the county election board of Comanche county, Okla., seeking a writ of mandamus to declare him the holder of an office as councilman of the city council of the city of Lawton, in one of the several wards of that city. We are of the opinion that this proceeding must be dismissed under the rule announced in Edwards v. Welch, 29 Okla. 335, 116 P. 791; Hudson v. Moore, 169 Okla. 12, 35 P.2d 886; Revard v. Givens, 139 Okla. 60, 281 P. 233. In Hudson v. Moore, supra, it is said:

"When the question presented by an appeal has become moot, the appeal will be dismissed."

Therein it is pointed out that the term of office actually involved in the proceeding ended in 1933, and that when the term of office had expired the office was properly filled at the biennial city election in the spring of 1933.

Under the holdings of the above cases, if, as a matter of law, the writ should have originally been granted, the term of plaintiff expired in the spring of 1936.

The appeal is therefore dismissed.

OSBORN, C. J., BAYLESS, V. C. J., and PHELPS, GIBSON, and HURST, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

State v. County Election Board of Comanche County

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jun 22, 1937
69 P.2d 35 (Okla. 1937)
Case details for

State v. County Election Board of Comanche County

Case Details

Full title:STATE ex rel. DORLAND v. COUNTY ELECTION BOARD OF COMANCHE COUNTY

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Jun 22, 1937

Citations

69 P.2d 35 (Okla. 1937)
180 Okla. 334

Citing Cases

State ex Inf. McKittrick v. Wymore

18 C.J. 1303; Watts v. Gerking, 228 P. 135, 34 A.L.R. 1493; United States v. Woody, 2 F.2d 262; State ex rel.…

Pierson v. Canupp

An appeal will be dismissed if it appears that only a moot question is involved or that a party has failed to…