From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Stadler v. Nativity Lutheran Church

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine
Nov 9, 1981
436 A.2d 892 (Me. 1981)

Opinion

Argued November 5, 1981.

Decided November 9, 1981.

Appeal from the Superior Court, Knox County.

Strout, Payson, Pellicani, Cloutier, Hokkanen Strong, Robert J. Levine (orally), Rockland, for plaintiff.

Richardson, Tyler Troubh, Jeffrey A. Thaler (orally), Portland, for defendants.

Before McKUSICK, C.J., and GODFREY, NICHOLS, CARTER, VIOLETTE and WATHEN, JJ.


MEMORANDUM OF DECISION.

This is an appeal from a pro forma decree of the Superior Court (Knox County) reflecting a Workers' Compensation Commission decision which denied petitioner's claim for compensation. The Superior Court decree provides as follows: "The Decree of the Worker's Compensation Commission dated February 5, 1981 and further amplified by Decree dated March 31, 1981 is hereby affirmed." The decree is not a final judgment and accordingly the petitioner's appeal is premature. Murphy v. City of Bangor, Me., 422 A.2d 1013, 1014 (1980) establishes that the decree must expressly state the relief granted and "should contain within its four corners the mandate of the court without reference to other documents."

If, after remand, another appeal is filed, further briefs and oral argument shall not be required. The Court has had the benefit of briefs and argument upon the merits.

The entry is:

Appeal dismissed.

Remanded to Superior Court for further action consistent with the opinion herein.

All concurring.


Summaries of

Stadler v. Nativity Lutheran Church

Supreme Judicial Court of Maine
Nov 9, 1981
436 A.2d 892 (Me. 1981)
Case details for

Stadler v. Nativity Lutheran Church

Case Details

Full title:George M. STADLER v. NATIVITY LUTHERAN CHURCH and Atlantic Mutual…

Court:Supreme Judicial Court of Maine

Date published: Nov 9, 1981

Citations

436 A.2d 892 (Me. 1981)

Citing Cases

Stadler v. Nativity Lutheran Church

We deny the appeal. The pro forma decree here involved follows the dismissal of an earlier appeal found to be…

Russell v. Duchess Footwear

Failure to articulate in the judgment appealed from the particular relief granted deprived the judgment of…